2 ms·
Well let's consider some scenarios You are a user of hot new site clown-mishaps.example and Jim is a Bad Guy of some sort. 1. Credential stuffing. Jim has 10M
by tialaramex 6y ago
Well let's consider some scenarios
You are a user of hot new site clown-mishaps.example and Jim is a Bad Guy of some sort.
1. Credential stuffing. Jim has 10M username / email address / password combos from some "Hacker" site and he is trying all of them on clown-mishaps.example because he just figured out their rate-limiting depends on session cookies (Oops)
If you have TOTP then this doesn't work, but, if you have a password manager you should also be using unique passwords, that is after all what the password manager is for, so, you should be immune to credential stuffing anyway. This seems like a wash.
2. Live Leak. Jim discovered that the credentials backend for clown-mishaps.example uses say a noSQL system in the cloud on a non-standard port, he connects to this system and queries your credentials to log in as you.
TOTP makes no difference here, no matter how you do it, the seed stored by clown-mishaps.example is enough for Jim to make TOTP codes. If they used a password hash and if your password manager makes decently strong passwords Jim can't figure out your password but TOTP didn't help.
3. Slow Leak. Jim found the S3 bucket "clown mishaps pwd backups July 2020" with a text SQL dump of a historical database. Oops.
TOTP still makes no difference here unless you didn't enable it until after July 2020, but then that's the same if you changed your password, or only created the account later.
4. Phishing site. Unfortunately clowns-mishap.example is a phishing site. It looks just like the real thing. Jim sets it up to capture live logins, cookies and so on. You can get tools to help do this for popular login systems.
If your password manager is hooked up to tell you about phishing attempts you might get some warning, but TOTP makes no difference to that. Whether not knowing your TOTP seed hurts Jim will depend on the details of the site's security systems, but in most cases if his phishing site fools you into attempting to log in it's game over.
WebAuthn completely protects you in all four scenarios, and a password manager does at least potentially help you in all four scenarios, but TOTP isn't really adding anything on top of the password manager except in scenario #4