2 ms·
Tesla is not allowed to do that in Europe.[1] In the US, they got away with a lot during the Trump administration. That seems to be changing. From the NTSB stat
by Animats 6y ago
Tesla is not allowed to do that in Europe.[1] In the US, they got away with a lot during the Trump administration. That seems to be changing.
From the NTSB statement:
"The success of these AVs depends on the driver completing a monitoring task that requires sustained attention; however, humans generally perform poorly in the role of monitor. Also, if the automated control system behaves consistently and reliably for prolonged periods, the user of that system can become complacent about its operation and may not respond appropriately when a situation requires him or her to act."
The NTSB people see this clearly because they investigate aviation accidents. Over reliance on automation is a known problem in aviation. The aviation systems are pretty good, but they are not yet good enough to be the pilot in command. Pilot training covers this in detail. Drivers are not trained that way.
[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/14/tesla-autopilot-self-driving-false-advertising-germany.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/14/tesla-autopilot-self-driving...
- prox 6y agoThat creates a strange situation where a monitor would need more training vs a driving license? Or would that require an overhaul of the training itself?
- neltnerb 6y agoI think that's not especially strange when these partially automated systems aren't fully autonomous yet. I would have a hard time arguing against requiring a few hours of class time learning about exactly what the systems do and what pitfalls there are because those things are not at all like what anyone has ever been taught in drivers ed before.
- Animats 6y agoYes. Again, "If the automated control system behaves consistently and reliably for prolonged periods, the user of that system can become complacent about its operation and may not respond appropriately when a situation requires him or her to act." That's what led to the accidents where a Tesla plowed into a freeway divide barrier (California), a street sweeper (China), a parked van (Germany), a fire truck (California), a semitrailer (Florida), an overturned truck (Taiwan) ... There's a certain similarity to Tesla autopilot crashes. Everything was going just great until Tesla's automated system failed to detect a big solid obstacle. Tesla drivers need to be very aware of that failure mode. It's amazing that Tesla is allowed to ship that. It's Musk's "we don't need LIDAR, we'll just kill people instead".