3 ms·
This is something I think of fairly often. Telling young people that the world is ruled by a clique of powerful old white men who conspire to keep them oppress
by inglor_cz 6y ago
This is something I think of fairly often.
Telling young people that the world is ruled by a clique of powerful old white men who conspire to keep them oppressed must be crushing, especially if done incessantly.
A cynical part of me says: see, sowing and cultivating frustration is precisely what some politicians need to reap power. They might not gain as much power if their voters had more self-esteem.
- bitwize 6y ago> Telling young people that the world is ruled by a clique of powerful old white men who conspire to keep them oppressed must be crushing, especially if done incessantly. If you're a young white man with a fighting chance of becoming one of the next generation of powerful old white men, I can understand where you might find that unnecessarily demoralizing. But for everybody else, it's the bitter truth they nevertheless need to know. And the only way to change this is at the systemic, political level.
- itronitron 6y agoReminds me of reading a story someone wrote about the epiphany they had when their therapist finally told them "the world does not wake up in the morning to fuck you"
- fjeifisjf 6y agoMany of live in a country with a long history of laws written explicitly for that purpose.
- inglor_cz 6y agoRunning a demoralization campaign on youngsters is unlikely to improve things, though. Would there be an Israel today if Jewish people convinced themselves that the world is forever going to hate and subjugate them and that they are powerless to change it? They could have done so, after all, the Holocaust was an unspeakable evil. But they chose the path of constructive defiance.
- sokoloff 6y agoIf I were a therapist, I'd probably have that made in vinyl and put on the ceiling over the couch.
- drewcoo 6y agoThat person must have been married to the world for a while already, then.
- bluefirebrand 6y ago> If you're a young white man with a fighting chance of becoming one of the next generation of powerful old white men, I can understand where you might find that unnecessarily demoralizing. Is this really the only situation where you think this is demoralizing? Not for women or minorities who are told they will never have a chance of making it anywhere because they're not white men? Personally I think that's pretty discouraging.
- drewcoo 6y agoParent quotes the grandparent saying "unnecessarily demoralizing" then proceeds to drop the modifier, thus changing the claim, and then doubts the newly-created straw man.