3 ms·
Has Bayesian verbiage become a form of virtue signaling? Don't get me wrong. I took statistics in college, and we covered Bayesian methods. They can't be contr
by analog31 6y ago
Has Bayesian verbiage become a form of virtue signaling?
Don't get me wrong. I took statistics in college, and we covered Bayesian methods. They can't be controversial because Bayes' Theorem is a theorem, meaning it's proven. But the attempt to apply its terminology to lengthy but "soft" arguments seems like pure clutter.
- andrewflnr 6y agoI think it's been common in the rationalist community for a while, in the 5-10 years that I've been aware of them.
- fractionalhare 6y agoI don't know if virtue signaling is the right term. The better term might be "shibboleth" for so-called rationalists. It's as if you took the kids who loved lists of logical fallacies and told them they could resolve all disputes if they just reduced them to first principles and used words like "prior." Nevermind that the first principles lose all context of the original issue - we're in a world of pure logic, where we can use theorems! To the rationalist community, everything looks like a good opportunity to write a lengthy essay reinventing the wheel with Bayes theorem. It's a cargo cult of basic statistics dressing up otherwise uninteresting arguments. It's very tedious for people like myself who actually studied statistics and apply it professionally. Bayes theorem is barely even a theorem - it's literally a basic rearrangement of the axioms of probability. It's not some supreme revelation that imbues arguments with more credibility. Most of the time I see it invoked in discussion, it's not even rigorously quantified. You can choose arbitrary priors, so at the end of the day you never arrive at an objective truth. It's profundity for its own sake, and nothing is really achieved.
- catlifeonmars 6y agoI can’t speak to how others interpret it, but to me, I read it as a way to apply a pretense of mathematical rigor in otherwise unrigorous contexts (like psychology or behavioral economics).
- sega_sai 6y agoNo, I don't think it is. Separately from rationalist community, there is substantial amount of work showing that Bayesian updating and reasoning is in some sense the optimal way of operating under uncertainty. It is also certainly true that garbage in and garbage out, i.e. if you feed garbage inputs, you'll get garbage out (Bayesian or not), but the advantage in my opinion of having a framework for making decisions in cases of uncertainties is extremely useful. It is often hard to really apply this for ordinary life situations, (and maybe often not worth it), but even then it's useful to think about priors/evidence, even if you don't particularly care about the final number.
- analog31 6y agoThat's fair. A lot of what I read about "Bayesian reasoning" boils down to: Check your assumptions, and update your beliefs when faced with new evidence. But those habits have been with us for millennia, and I'm not arguing against them. My parents were educated in an earlier rationalist movement, and I'm deeply influenced by them. Being able to think about probabilities is useful, if they're quantifiable. And conditional probability plays a useful role in that process.
- astrange 6y agoI see two main problems with the way the lesswrong-type people try to do Bayesianism as a life philosophy. The first is that claiming to be rational* and having "priors" and "updating" them instead of "beliefs" and "changing" them is humblebragging and doesn't admit that you have beliefs that might be wrong. Even if the original idea was to make you more humble, it's dangerous when it spreads to people like young male VCs and Elon Musk who already have the world's biggest egos. The second is there's no way to set priors for silly ideas and they won't admit some things just ain't gonna happen, which means they've accidentally started a religion by refusing to not believe in various logic traps they call "existential risks" like Roko's basilisk, evil AI gods enslaving them, and so on. * for some reason they call themselves rationalist which implies being "rational", aka "always right", even though they are explicitly not rationalist, but empiricist!
- fractionalhare 6y ago> No, I don't think it is. Separately from rationalist community, there is substantial amount of work showing that Bayesian updating and reasoning is in some sense the optimal way of operating under uncertainty. With the very important proviso that the events you're uncertain about are at least probabilistically quantifiable and the "priors" are credible. It's very easy to write a long winded essay arriving at any conclusion you want if it's a subject with significant uncertainty and you can make a halfway decent appeal to whatever priors you want.