3 ms·
What problems does this solve? This seem to negate the whole purpose of 2FA - now your second factor becomes "something you know" instead of "something you hav
by Nextgrid 6y ago
What problems does this solve?
This seem to negate the whole purpose of 2FA - now your second factor becomes "something you know" instead of "something you have".
What I really want (and would consider a "missing authenticator app") is an app that stays on the phone and keeps all keys there with a client companion app for desktop that communicates with the mobile via Bluetooth to automatically fill the 2FA codes.
- hirsin 6y agoCaBLE may be of interest to you. It's better than 2fa codes, since it's effectively FIDO/web AuthN (unphishable). https://github.com/w3c/webauthn/pull/909 https://github.com/w3c/webauthn/pull/909
- anang 6y agoI use krypton for this and I think it works well.
- CharlesW 6y agoHere's the URL, since finding it via search is hard: https://krypt.co/ https://krypt.co/
- watermelon0 6y agoIt seems like it hasn't been actively developed since 2019, when Akamai bought them, which is quite a shame. Does anyone know of a suitable alternative?
- toomim 6y agoWhat part about this app is "something you know"? It looks to me like it stores a private key in the app, just like all other 2FA apps.
- Nextgrid 6y agoIt talks about iCloud sync, so this means anyone who knows your iCloud credentials can now download your second factors.
- memco 6y agoI looked into the app a little bit and a few things I see that set it apart from the ones I'm familiar with: - Sync is optional: it is a premium ($4.99/yr) feature that is not enabled by default. Other tools I've used have iCloud sync turned on by default. - Auto-lock: you can set a password so that some guest user who might be using your computer can't just open and copy your codes. - Backup code storage: you can store the backup keys in the app. (Kinda strange, since if you have access to the backup codes, you also have access to the OTP itself so /shrug/). - Keys are availabe: most of the apps I've used do not allow you to see the key after creating the account, but this does. Whether these are good or desirable features, they are somewhat distinct from the apps I've used.