7 ms·
In terms of single-player games, the figure is more like 85%. You can probably get an additional 5% to work with various levels of tweaking, but compatibility i
by smoldesu 6y ago
In terms of single-player games, the figure is more like 85%. You can probably get an additional 5% to work with various levels of tweaking, but compatibility is remarkably good these days. Many games perform better on Linux than they do on Windows (Borderlands, Overwatch), while others give you a chance to have a flawless experience with games that are pretty busted on modern Windows (Diablo 2, Fallout: New Vegas). As another commenter mentioned, the big issue is with anti-cheat: any game implementing EAC will outright not work, full stop. That makes it about a 50/50 chance that multiplayer titles will work on Linux, with some unfortunate casualties like Rainbow Six Siege and Halo MCC's online multiplayer.
With that being said, I truly and honestly believe Linux is the way to go if you're not into multiplayer. Valve's commitment to Linux is nothing short of herculean, and it's heartwarming to see them give back to the open source community in such a remarkable way. If it weren't for Proton (and DXVK), I'd still be using Windows on my main computer, which made development hell. Now, I feel comfortable moving to a system where I can enjoy Overwatch, Titanfall and Team Fortress on a regular basis without dual-booting.
- Zhyl 6y agoValve's commitment to Linux is outstanding. I am genuinely surprised that other vendors (GOG, Epic) haven't joined Valve in making Linux based hedges. Epic have given grants to Godot, Blender and other projects that commoditise their complement, but they still don't want to (or don't want to be seen) doing the same for their platform.
- smoldesu 6y agoThere's an open-source Epic launcher frontend called Legendary[1] that can automagically manage your Wine/DXVK files with minimal user intervention. It's not even close to how easy Valve makes it, but it's certainly an option if you want to get Epic games working on Linux with minimal hassle. [1] https://github.com/derrod/legendary https://github.com/derrod/legendary EDIT: i actually meant to reference the Heroic games launcher, which is the frontend for Legendary. you can find it here: https://github.com/flavioislima/HeroicGamesLauncher https://github.com/flavioislima/HeroicGamesLauncher
- Zhyl 6y agoI was thinking more from a point of view of Epic, the company, wanting to secure its future. In Epic's case they're actually currently suing (and running a propaganda campaign) against Apple and Google because the latter are charging 30% of all revenue including in-game purchases. Rather than funding the development of the similar initiatives on PC (i.e. Linux) to prevent Microsoft from doing the same thing, instead Tim Sweeney tweets about how switching to Linux is like moving to Canada and is generally rude and unpleasant about it. The fact that someone else had to make a launcher for Epic is further proof that Epic is not interested in even supporting Linux, let alone invest in it.
- smoldesu 6y agoSure, but that's always the case. Valve didn't offer native Linux support when Steam came out. With that being said, Tim Sweeney can be as unpleasant about it as he likes, I'm not begging for native Fortnite support anytime soon.
- Zhyl 6y agoThey didn't offer native Linux support, but from its inception Valve has been working to remove dependencies and combat existential threats. It used the quake engine for half life, then developed their own engine. They were dependent on bricks and mortar retail who were losing interest in PC, so they made Steam. Windows 8 made it look like Microsoft was making a land grab for a desktop store, so Valve made Steam OS and Steam machines (and latterly Proton). Epic is almost taking the opposite approach. Denying or not addressing a problem until it's already established to the point is a market norm. If Epic had caused the amount of fuss they are now in 2011, maybe it wouldn't have needed a hundred thousand dollar YouTube campaign and a multi-million dollar lawsuit to resolve. I dunno, it's true that's it's not Epic's MO, but it's not _smart_.
- arminiusreturns 6y agoEpic promised the linux community lots of love, and then something changed (or they were lying from the start). I am thankful for their contributions to Godot, but Tim S is openly anti-linux, so dont expect anything but massive market pressure to change that.
- dleslie 6y agoTim once referred to Win32 as a free and open standard. I don't think he _understands_ what it means to be a truly free and open standard. Which is a little troubling, considering all the other concerns with the EGS.
- bitwize 6y ago> Tim once referred to Win32 as a free and open standard. I don't think he _understands_ what it means to be a truly free and open standard. Sun tried to get the Windows API to be an open standard by submitting it to ISO, so that they could claim their alternate implementation (Wabi) was standards compliant. Microsoft told the standards committee "you can't do that! That API is our IP!" And so the Public Windows Initiative came to an end. Funny, now Microsoft is arguing against APIs as IP as an amicus in Oracle v. Google.
- ecf 6y agoTim S is openly anti-anything that he can’t insert himself as a rent seeking middleman in.
- MegaDeKay 6y ago"We love Linux!" said Epic back in 2014. Not so much, actually. It is really unfortunately that they didn't follow Valve's lead or Linux gaming would be that much further along. https://www.unrealengine.com/en-US/blog/41-update-preview https://www.unrealengine.com/en-US/blog/41-update-preview
- jorvi 6y agoI mean, if you go way way back to the days of Unreal Tournament 2004 and before (when Epic was still Epic Megagames) they were actually one of the few developers that supported Windows, Linux and macOS for most of their games.
- frankohn 6y agoI agree, I love the attention they have given to linux and their technical competence without any bullshit. I am glad to purchase games on Steam. They are also doing a great work supporting the SDL2 library. AFAIK they are employing its original author and developer Sam Lantinga.
- lrem 6y agoGOG deals mostly with games that no longer can be ported reasonably.
- anoncake 6y agoThose games can often be ported by bundling them with (a tested version of) WINE.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fuzxi 6y agoDespite shipping native Linux versions of quite a few titles, the GOG Galaxy client is still not supported on Linux (and both the client and API are closed, so no community port any time soon). That means no achievements, multiplayer matchmaking, cloud saves, update rollbacks, or game update notifications for Linux users (although the last one is do-able with the Lutris runner or Minigalaxy).
- im3w1l 6y agoIirc a gotcha with borderlands is that windows and linux players cannot multiplayer together, with very confusing error messages.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yial 6y agoI don't know if this is helpful for cross platform, but for many games with problematic multiplayer you can use https://www.zerotier.com/ https://www.zerotier.com/ (works great for original Warcraft III) and they have a linux version.
- pacificat0r 6y agoWait, overwatch works on linux? This is fantastic, i remember trying it a while back with pretty bad perf results
- ekianjo 6y agoit works very nicely nowadays: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=voXc1nCD4IA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=voXc1nCD4IA
- smoldesu 6y agoUse the Lutris installer [1] and it will work great. It feels about as native as it gets, and it manages to hit 120 fps on my 1440p monitor with my meek 1050ti. Unbelievable performance, if you ask me. There's currently an issue where it will regenerate the shader cache with every launch, but it should only take 1-2 minutes with a decent CPU, which I normally spend in the training grounds. Once the cache is ready, performance is blistering fast. [1] https://lutris.net/games/overwatch/ https://lutris.net/games/overwatch/
- linux_user_83 6y agoA lot of this is only true if you only have the most basic setup or you are playing the most played games. Outside of the top 100 or so games or unity games (unity games seem to just work as unity is cross platform anyway) it is extremely variable and there are all sorts of odd issues. While many games work there are hundreds of annoyances, crashes and quirks that don't exist on Windows at all. * alt-tabbing out of a game will often crash a lot of games, so you can't really use discord or similar team chat software properly without risking crashing out of the game. * If you have a multi-monitor system the game will frequently start on the wrong screen. Thanks to how mondern video drivers identify the monitors even switch the cables round might not work! * A lot of games will work fine at 1080p. At 4K you will see performance problems, also streaming to other people can be terrible. * Single player games that require high refresh rates and stable framerates like Doom Eternal will have variable performance for no reason what-so-ever and are rock solid on Windows (I had two game crashes in the past year and I play a lot of Doom Eternal). * Loads of older games that use the build engine or the KeX engine like Blood does not work properly with Proton. * Lots of indie games do not work at all. * Game streaming on discord will tank framerate on a lot of games in Linux, but it works flawlessly in Windows. * Some graphics setttings just don't take at all, it doesn't seem to error. Everytime one of these articles get posted there are comments such as this where people say that it is flawless and it simply isn't true. Having a dual screen setup isn't a strange setup these days at all and using Discord is the choice of most PC gamers these days. I stream games to friends (some are disabled and can't play the games, others might want just to watch me play the game as I am good at these games). I am quite proficient with Linux (I've been using it since 2002) and I cannot recommend it. Maybe it is good enough for you but you and many the people on this thread are giving a false impression of the solution. I have about 450 games in my steam library (I've had a steam account since Half life 2 was released) and about 50 in my GoG account and I've tried a fair few, everything from modern triple A titles to older games, so I have a good sample size for anyone claiming that is merely ancedotal.
- tines 6y agoNot all these issues are specific to Linux though; I can't even alt-tab out of Skyrim on Windows 10 without it crashing.
- zelon88 6y agoI agree on most of your points. To expand a bit on some of the "tweaks" that must be endured.... To play War Thunder you must use the launcher to set it in a window at native screen resolution then start the game. Then you move the game to your desired monitor and Layer>Always on top, and Undecorate the window. Boom. War Thunder works.
- mjevans 6y agoI wonder if Proton as a PoW (Proton on Windows) wrapper would enable long term compatibility for games on Windows as well. While I use and prefer Linux personally I recognize there's many will continue to use Windows for years to come.
- xaduha 6y ago> Many games perform better on Linux than they do on Windows (Borderlands, Overwatch) Do you have anything to back that up? In my personal experience Overwatch absolutely doesn't perform better on Linux. Haven't tried Borderlands, but in any case two games don't count as 'many'. Unless you mean all Borderlands games.
- smoldesu 6y agoSomeone posted a pretty good comparison video of Overwatch performance on Windows vs Linux: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=voXc1nCD4IA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=voXc1nCD4IA Windows runs hotter and tends to have a slightly lower average framerate with a much lower 1% low. In the case of Borderlands, 1 and 2 have much better performance than what I saw on Windows, and TPS pretty much identical to Windows performance. Borderlands 3 is about a little slower on Linux, but I'm guessing that has to do with DXVK's incomplete DX12 support. Overall, the Borderlands franchise is completely playable on Linux, and oftentimes a better experience. Also, I refrained from listing more games out of respect for your time. Out of the games I've tried, I've noticed better performance in the following: Team Fortress 2, MGSV The Phantom Pain, Valheim, Fallout 4, CS:GO, Insurgency, Mirror's Edge, Payday 2, Warframe, Prey, Kerbal Space Program, DOOM (2016), and Terraria. If I had a larger library, I'd probably try more games.
- xaduha 6y agoI'd say there's something wrong with your Windows installation then, in my opinion if you tune your Linux distro for gaming, then maybe (depending on your hardware) you can get on par results with Windows. But more benchmarks are always nice, so let's leave it at that, everyone can decide for themselves https://www.youtube.com/c/FlightlessMango/videos https://www.youtube.com/c/FlightlessMango/videos https://www.youtube.com/user/beronori/videos https://www.youtube.com/user/beronori/videos
- 5d749d7da7d5 6y ago> can probably get an additional 5% to work with various levels of tweaking My big complaint is the number of titles that receive a Platinum rating on ProtonDB, in spite of technical issues. I have purchased more than one title with a Platinum rating that had significant issues running on my machine. This is compounded that Steam/ProtonDB user reports typically have an abysmal level of detail to replicate a working configuration. Someone got it to run flawlessly, but there is so much wine configuration jargon that each time I need to dig into the issues, I waste time on something that otherwise would work on Windows. I would love if there was a 'share my Proton configuration' per game that could be made available to the community.
- milesvp 6y agoI’ve experiences this, and it’s annoying. Worse is it’s never obvious if it’s a driver problem. That said, part of why I know anything about computers was trying to get games to work on my old 486. I sort of miss the feeling of reward of really wanting to play a game and needing to dig into the technical weeds to finally get the right boot disk. Proton almost scratches that itch for me, sadly there aren’t enough games anymore to really motivate me.