4 ms·
> …when was the last time Google spent their money on smear campaign and negative ads on a rival? That's a PR stunt. You should be Actually Concerned about how
by CharlesW 6y ago
> …when was the last time Google spent their money on smear campaign and negative ads on a rival?
That's a PR stunt. You should be Actually Concerned about how much Alphabet is spending on lobbying.
- gerash 6y agoLobbying is like the prisoner's dilemma. If you don't do it but your rival does then you'll end up with these extortion laws that hands Murdoch free money as we saw in Australia
- CharlesW 6y agoThat's totally fair, and I understand that Google isn't unique in that respect. My point is that just because Google isn't doing flashy ad campaigns doesn't mean that they're not surreptitiously doing everything they can to continue to establish and cement their position as an unavoidable toll-taker on the internet.
- Siira 6y agoThey provide much more value than what they capture, and what they capture is pretty much necessary to serve those services (in the search space, not Android etc). The only way to make them capture less value is by tax, as we have seen. Other big tech companies are much more rent-seeking and can actually unlock swaths of value with proper regulation.
- SllX 6y agoIf they’re spending a lot of money and still getting raked over the coals in various legislatures including Congress, why should we be worried? Lobbying only gets your interests on the table; it doesn’t get you a seat at the table.
- RHSeeger 6y agoBecause there is no real difference between lobbying and bribing. And I think a lot of us have a problem with companies bribing politicians to get laws passed; especially companies that have enough money to bribe <the number of politicians needed to pass the law regardless of what anyone thinks about it> of them.
- SllX 6y agoI question your premise that lobbying = bribery, but let’s let it stand unchallenged because it’s irrelevant here. If Google, Apple and Microsoft are all competing with each other and also doing business with each other in different markets, and they’re also all lobbying legislators, whose metaphorical bag of money is the winner and gets all of their hopes and dreams fulfilled when Congress starts meddling?
- dane-pgp 6y ago> [who] gets all of their hopes and dreams fulfilled Well, not the citizens of the country, which is kind of the point.
- SllX 6y agoWhat, the Americans working at Apple and Google and Microsoft and own stock in them suddenly aren’t citizens? What about the Board of Directors at each of them? Legislative bodies is where politics is supposed to happen, and legislators don’t live in a vacuum. We don’t elect them and send them up to the top of an ivory tower for two years to philosophize about policy with the occasional edict sent down. So how do legislators know what kinds of policies people actually want when there’s about 700K people in their districts (and 39M constituents if you’re a California Senator) unless people show up and say, “Hey, this is what I want from you, this is why I elected you.” You get a mixed bag because legislatures are a mixed bag representing a larger mixed bag, and sorry, newspaper polls aren’t a good stand in for showing up and putting your name down for consideration. Your interests as a citizen are not identical to the other 699,999ish of your neighbors, and the guy or gal representing you is just one person of a larger body.
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoIn what way do you see Alphabet getting raked over the coals? They obviously are a monopoly in both search and in the Android app market and should be broken up according to antitrust law. That isn't even being considered.
- SllX 6y agoHow is calling the CEO to come testify before Congress so members of the House and Senate can score talking points not taking a company over the coals? Or passing disturbing crony-handout legislation like the Australian Parliament did to the clear detriment of specific companies? Or all the nonsense going on in the EU? Or the political discussions to do as you suggest, breakup Alphabet, by people with the power, though not the moral standing, to do so?
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoMaking the CEO testify costs Google very little. Could you provide links for this part? > Or passing disturbing crony-handout legislation like the Australian Parliament did to the clear detriment of specific companies? Or all the nonsense going on in the EU? Or the political discussions to do as you suggest, breakup Alphabet, by people with the power, though not the moral standing, to do so? It's vague and confusing.