10 ms·
Loom EGA/VGA Comparison
- jakedata 6y agoSeeing the original EGA graphics gave me a wave of nostalgia I wasn't prepared for. The first time I saw an EGA screen was at Radio Shack, setting up a Tandy 1000 system on the sales floor. Having only ever used a television as a computer display I was absolutely blown away by the clarity of the screen. I ended up using my employee discount to purchase a Tandy 1000 TX and hacking some weird CRT connection together to get the Tandy 16 color CGA working in time for college. Couldn't afford EGA at the time but I eventually moved up to a Trident VGA adapter when I had saved enough. I sort of left gaming behind after Doom and Goldenaxe but the early 90s was a fun time.
- kwanbix 6y agoMy first computer was an original IBM PC XT. It had 8088, 640kb or RAM, 20MB Seagate HD, and a 360kb dd. Software was so lean that we would use smartdrive (or something like that), to use 360kb of RAM as a virtual disk and copy the games there so that they will load faster.
- inglor_cz 6y agoIn 1995 I bought my first computer, a very old original IBM PC XT for about USD 100. That was my economic limit. It had a MDA card, no graphics at all. The rest of the hardware was as you describe. I was at least able to exchange the MDA card for a Hercules and play some very oldie games on a monochrome monitor.
- tonyarkles 6y agoThe details are foggy, but Loom in particular had some way to be playable on monochrome graphics, perhaps with some kind of CGA emulator. I have vivid memories of playing through this game on my Compaq XT clone in black-and-yellow with no mouse. Similar time frame; my family got the machine around 93-94 on a pretty low budget, but I learned a TON on it until we managed to buy a Pentium 133 a few years later.
- trm42 6y agoI remember playing some CGA games with some Hercules graphics card. There was two TSR programs which made it possible to run CGA color games with the yellow-on-black Hercules display. Can't remember the name of the other one but one of them was definitively SIMCGA [https://www.pcorner.com/list/GRAPHUTI/SIMCGA41.ZIP/INFO/ https://www.pcorner.com/list/GRAPHUTI/SIMCGA41.ZIP/INFO/] Without that awesome program my childhood would've been a lot less intresting.
- tonyarkles 6y agoSolid memory! It was definitely SIMCGA that I had and it worked awesome. Thanks for the nostalgia hit!
- Zardoz84 6y agoI remember playing some Spiderman game for PC with ega graphics (or at least had a 16 color palette) on the 286 of my father with monochrome (Hercules ?) display.
- jakedata 6y agoThat IBM XT keyboard would be worth $100 today if you could find it.
- inglor_cz 6y agoUnfortunately it is long gone. Our living space back then was too limited to keep old machines around. Actually, it still is.
- tartoran 6y agoSame with my first PC. It was the around 1991 and that 20Mb harddrive seemed like an enormous space, I had so much software and games on it. And also had windows 3.0 which kindof sucked so I was spending most time in DOS.
- m34 6y agoNice comparison. I wonder what the differences between both would be on real hardware (graphics adapter+CRT screen), especially for criteria like vibrancy and apparent smoothness. I‘m aware that emulators nowadays ship with tube distortion and scanline filters/shaders, but is there a more "physical model"-based approach that properly implements raster and pixel over-/afterglow?
- kruxigt 6y agoThe original is truly beautiful. Makes me want to go play some old games!
- Macuyiko 6y ago> The original EGA background art for Loom was made by Mark Ferrari Obligatory recommendation for this talk by Mark Ferrari: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMcJ1Jvtef0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMcJ1Jvtef0 - truly an artist
- bajsejohannes 6y agoWow, that's amazing. Here is one of the galleries he's showing in the video: http://www.effectgames.com/demos/canvascycle/ http://www.effectgames.com/demos/canvascycle/ I couldn't find the one with adjustable time of day, though.
- dividuum 6y agoJust bought https://pixfabrik.com/livingworlds/ https://pixfabrik.com/livingworlds/ as a result of your post. It has multiple variants for each scene depending on time of day. edit: Also found the web version: http://www.effectgames.com/demos/worlds/ http://www.effectgames.com/demos/worlds/
- Eric_WVGG 6y agoWow, I remember this remaster… I definitely had a feeling of the magic being gone in the CD-ROM version. I blamed the C-list voiceovers and overly lush production of the music… the old “sound blaster” score had this delicate and deliberate (what we would later call “chiptune”) sound, whereas the CD was just _wrong_. But yes, the graphics were inferior too. I would have expected the EGA and soundblaster approach to work great for a cartoonish game like Monkey Island, but Loom was more like a Rankin-Bass or a gothic Disney movie (think Black Cauldron). Everything about the themes indicate that lush visual canvases and a live orchestra would be the way to go. Textbook case of severe limitations leading to great art, I guess.
- Eric_WVGG 6y ago… here’s a vid where you can see a live playback of both versions simultaneously. Yeah, the voices are as cringe as I remember. The music is lacking. Melodrama. It’s just bad. https://youtu.be/Tsmt29AJBaE https://youtu.be/Tsmt29AJBaE [edit] even that video doesn’t quite get the best score. They’re playing EGA with no soundcard at all. Here’s the game with an AdLib / SoundBlaster score, hardware standards that were just catching on when Loom was being developed. https://youtu.be/qxoRHAY3CM0 https://youtu.be/qxoRHAY3CM0 And here’s the Roland MT-32, the card that everyone knew was the best, and no 13 year old could possibly afford. THAT’S the premium experience. https://youtu.be/SVYI2logmXs https://youtu.be/SVYI2logmXs ((It’s all Tchaikovsky, by the way))
- cousin_it 6y agoIt feels like the VGA version got painted over by a non-artist. Look at the trees in the graveyard scene, the pillow shading is inexcusable. The EGA is still great though. Mark Ferrari's other work is good too, check out http://www.effectgames.com/demos/canvascycle/ http://www.effectgames.com/demos/canvascycle/ Many people think the charm of Loom is due to pixel art, but that's not true. The aesthetic was consciously borrowed from Eyvind Earle's work on Sleeping Beauty, which was very much high res and full color. The main antagonist is based on Maleficent.
- JdeBP 6y agoThis hits the nail on the head, I think. Other comments talk about limitations of EGA, but that really isn't the problem exhibited here. The problem here is not drawing things right. The graveyard scene has the trees illuminated from the side opposite to the sunset. The original has them illuminated by the sunset. The scene with the pipes has several of the shadows wrong for the apparent light sources, compared to the original. And where did the birds and the will-o'-the-wisps go?
- raldi 6y ago> Look at the trees in the graveyard scene, the pillow shading is inexcusable. Thanks for introducing me to the term (which led to an explicit definition) for something I've perceived before but never clearly. The tombstones and sunset firmly establish the light source at the horizon. The foreground should be in silhouette (as it was initially) and there's no explanation for why the center of the trunks would receive more light than their edges. (However, both versions of the dock, and the furnace with the angled pipes, are pretty terrible about light sources.)
- StrictDabbler 6y agoLiterally decades of trying to explain this to people and yet Google suggests that this is very thread is the first significant time that the pixel-art term "pillow shading" has been explicitly linked to the acronym "VGA". That's weird because it's the defining characteristic of the cheap art of the VGA era. Epic Games was big into pillow shading. Jill of the Jungle, Solar Winds, Jazz Jackrabbit... They'd define seven hues, 8 shades of each hue, reserve the last 8 shades for monochrome, and then just paint things in from the side of the object. The pillow-shading aesthetic stuck after we moved on to 16.7 million colors and there was no reason to think about color that way anymore. A frustrating legacy.
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoLoom was the first quest game I ever played, and it still is a marvel. replayed it a couple of years ago and was really surprised how well it ages - way better than Monkey Island, I must say. This comparison is a very good reminder that severe limitations sometimes produce greater results. EGA version looks so much better than smoothly colored VGA.
- vaylian 6y agoHow appropriate. You weave like a duck! Okay, I'm asking you about Monkey Island: Why do you think it did not age that well?
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoThe interface. All that grid of available actions, just too many options. Later quests evolved to have fewer actions (see Full Throttle), and later the only option left was general 'interact' action. In this regard Loom was already ahead, with all actions replaced by general 'cast' action, and the exact combination of notes was the puzzle.
- nottorp 6y agoI've heard Bethesda is working feverishly to remove all options from their games and just leave an "interact" button. Your dream will come true in Elder Scrolls VI i guess.
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoIt's not my dream per se, but in Monkey Island 1&2, when stuck and without an internet walkthrough, it was extremely frustrating to try out all the actions on all the objects. Full Throttle and Grim Fandango improved on that old model immensely, and Loom's interface turned out to be 10 years ahead of the curve.
- nottorp 6y ago
- overgard 6y agoI think this is a really good example of how adding constraints can really enhance creativity. Frequently the worst thing for creativity is giving people too much to work with rather than too little. The EGA version had to work within strict technical constraints, and so the end result is more nuanced than you would ever expect. The VGA version didn't have that problem, and so it's sloppier and less inspired.
- bstar77 6y agoThe same is true for Monkey Island 1. The reason the VGA versions are inferior is because they replaced Mark Ferrari's amazing dithered EGA backgrounds. Additionally, the VGA versions used scanned art in spots, so it feels less sharp and detailed. I'm not sure who did the VGA treatments, but I doubt it was Ferrari. Ferrari did many (if not all) of the backgrounds in Thimbleweed Park. The guy is incredible. I'm lucky that I played and beat both Loom and Secret of Monkey Island before they went VGA as a kid. We were kind of brainwashed back then to think more is always better. I always preferred the EGA versions but never really knew why until I was much older. I'm working on a few game concepts and made the decision to solely use the EGA pallet. It has to be one of the worst pallets out there, but when done well the results can be astonishing. You have to use dithering and you have to use some unusual colors (cyan and magenta come to mind). This creates a very unique, nostalgic feel that only EGA can produce. I also love adding interesting technical constraints to my game ideas. "The enemy of art is the absence of limitations." -- Orson Welles
- dccoolgai 6y agoDitto on being a Ferrari fan. Been re-reading this article for years, I think you'll enjoy it if you haven't seen it yet. http://www.effectgames.com/effect/article-Old_School_Color_Cycling_with_HTML5.html http://www.effectgames.com/effect/article-Old_School_Color_C...
- herodoturtle 6y agoThat was a fantastic read - especially the linked Q&A with Mark Ferrari contained therein. Thanks for sharing! Edit: Here is a direct link to the Q&A for those that are interested (but courtesy of course to the person above for the original source link): http://www.effectgames.com/effect/article-Q_A_with_Mark_J_Ferrari.html http://www.effectgames.com/effect/article-Q_A_with_Mark_J_Fe...
- modeless 6y agoFans of Mark Ferrari should get the Living Worlds app. You can have his art as your wallpaper. https://pixfabrik.com/livingworlds/ https://pixfabrik.com/livingworlds/
- njharman 6y agoObviously in minority here (wonder if because never having played or seen I have no nostalgia, I’m 50 and played EGA games back then ). But I don’t see it. The VGA looks fine. The space scene OA labels cheap looks way better to me. The EGA scenes aren’t worse or better, just highly stylized. They’re in different styles. You may prefer the minimal style but that doesn’t make the other style bad.
- ratww 6y agoYeah, I also played both and I agree with you. This page also cherry-picked the examples. The EGA shading is ok but it doesn't work as well in the Glass city, Dragon cave or in the the last scene, for example.
- aidenn0 6y agoLoom is arguably the best looking EGA game. I hadn't seen the vga version prior to this. There doesn't seem to be the coherency of style that the originals had
- gorgoiler 6y agoHow can I play the original EGA version?
- ghostDancer 6y agoLoom is easy to find, you can get it on GOG, is on reduced price several times a year. And then use SCUMMVM and you can even play it on your phone.
- Narishma 6y agoBut does it include EGA graphics or only the remastered graphics like a lot of re-released old games do?
- ghostDancer 6y agoThe one on GOG is the VGA version, for the EGA one you need to resort to other sources more on the spirit of Monkey Island :-) .
- gattilorenz 6y agoUsing ScummVM on any existing platform. The game should be easily... found online.
- logbiscuitswave 6y agoYou can buy from Steam for pretty cheap, and then customize by loading in a recent version of ScummVM. This also works in 64-bit only versions of MacOS as where the base title is otherwise incompatible. Beyond the graphical changes, I also seem to recall that the script is somewhat different in the EGA version. I wouldn’t be surprised if there was a fix from the community for this, though.
- enneff 6y agohttps://archive.org/details/msdos_Loom_1990 https://archive.org/details/msdos_Loom_1990
- kjrose 6y agoI am always amazed as I look back at cga and ega graphics how incredibly versatile the designers were. Working with extreme limitations and still able to produce a mood and look that blows my mind. Same with really good ansi artists.
- smrq 6y agoFans of Loom might want to check out Brian Moriarty's earlier masterpiece, Trinity. It lacks the beautiful EGA graphics, of course, but the atmosphere of the game feels very similarly moody.
- vanderZwan 6y ago> Hover the cursor over the images to see the remastered VGA version. If you're on a iOS device, you can simply tap the images. I only see the remastered images for some of the images, is that as intended?
- nine_k 6y agoThe difference is striking. I only played the EGA version, and showed it to my children. This is a great example why making things look realistic is not always a good idea in game design. There is a good reason why some games should not look like your daily life. The dream-like rendering of old games is one of their principal attractive features. This is what I dearly miss in modern games, which sweat over hyper-realistic rendering and tend to look like a documentary with some haphazard CGI / AR effects slapped onto that. Some old games instead would take you to a visually impossible but utterly beautiful neverland, as shown so well in the article. I hope some game designers will realize this, and try to make another explicitly visually unrealistic game which is a piece of art.
- tartoran 6y agoYes. I remember playing the game in EGA because thats the most I had at the time and it was very iconic. Looking back, it and many games of the time remain iconic Lucasart/Sierra/etc. Modern games have advanced enormously but they’re lacking a certain aspect that is very hard to engineer and all that complexity anounts to something but in the end it all looks the same and lacks the personility games used to have.
- modeless 6y agoThere are billions of non-photorealistic games out there with every aesthetic imaginable, both retro and non-retro. It's not an exaggeration to say that there are far more options today if that's what you like. You just have to do a little searching. https://obradinn.com/ https://obradinn.com/ http://www.antichamber-game.com/ http://www.antichamber-game.com/ https://www.supergiantgames.com/games/hades/ https://www.supergiantgames.com/games/hades/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/1057090/Ori_and_the_Will_of_the_Wisps/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/1057090/Ori_and_the_Will_... https://store.steampowered.com/app/239030/Papers_Please/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/239030/Papers_Please/ http://kentuckyroutezero.com/ http://kentuckyroutezero.com/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/48000/LIMBO/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/48000/LIMBO/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/557600/Gorogoa/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/557600/Gorogoa/ https://www.monumentvalleygame.com/ https://www.monumentvalleygame.com/
- pmontra 6y ago> If you're on a iOS device, you can simply tap the images. Surprisingly it works on Android too and probability with every other mobile OS. s/iOS/touchscreen/ ?