8 ms·
Opponents of Oliver Cromwell published his family recipes
- seanieb 6y ago>” the anonymous editor peppered the text with political, personal, and sexual slander aimed at tarnishing the Cromwell legacy.” Stopped reading at this point. If the author doesn’t understand that the Cromwell legacy is already tarnished due to war crimes I doubt there’s going to be much reason to continue.
- andi999 6y agoThats a bit of an anachronism, isnt it? The concept of war crimes was developed a few centuries later, wasnt it?
- barrkel 6y agoThe atrocities are remembered in Ireland as atrocities all the same. > James Joyce wrote in Ulysses, 1922, “What about sanctimonious Cromwell and his ironsides that put the women and children of Drogheda to the sword with the bible text God is love pasted round the mouth of his cannon?” > Winston Churchill’s view in The History of the English Speaking Peoples: The Age of Revolution, 1957, is perhaps less artful, but succinct: “By an uncompleted process of terror, by an iniquitous land settlement, by the virtual proscription of the Catholic religion, by the bloody deeds already described, he cut new gulfs between the nations and the creeds…. Upon all of us there still lies ‘the curse of Cromwell.’ ” Quotes propagated from https://simanaitissays.com/2018/11/28/oliver-cromwell-puritan-lord-protector-and-a-real-piece-of-work-part-1/ https://simanaitissays.com/2018/11/28/oliver-cromwell-purita...
- HPsquared 6y agoOliver Cromwell (1599-1658) James Joyce commentary: 1922 Winston Churchill commentary: 1957 300 years is a lot of hindsight.
- seanieb 6y agoIs there a specific fact, letters etc. from the time you’re arguing against? From what I recall his barbarism was seen to stand out at the time in England and Ireland. He used it as a type of shock and awe, so when arrived at the next town they’d just surrender or flee.
- HPsquared 6y agoJust that the subject is the politics of the time (i.e. what were the people at the time arguing about - what was that "legacy" they were looking to influence), and that modern authors are looking at things from a different perspective.
- morelisp 6y agoLove too read one colonialist war criminal Spiderman pointing at the other.
- dbuder 6y agoOne great hero of the realm pointing at the other as a war criminal as others point at him in the same way.
- arka2147483647 6y agoAt the time, it may have been that the ”Jury is still out”. You have to remenber that things we take as granted nowdays, may have been divisive at the time.
- seanieb 6y agoMurdering women and children, even at that time, was considered bad. Shocking eh.
- morelisp 6y agoThere were two “Reigns of Terror,” if we would but remember it and consider it; the one wrought murder in hot passion, the other in heartless cold blood; the one lasted mere months, the other had lasted a thousand years; the one inflicted death upon ten thousand persons, the other upon a hundred millions; but our shudders are all for the “horrors” of the minor Terror, the momentary Terror, so to speak; whereas, what is the horror of swift death by the axe, compared with lifelong death from hunger, cold, insult, cruelty, and heart-break? What is swift death by lightning compared with death by slow fire at the stake? A city cemetery could contain the coffins filled by that brief Terror which we have all been so diligently taught to shiver at and mourn over; but all France could hardly contain the coffins filled by that older and real Terror—that unspeakably bitter and awful Terror which none of us has been taught to see in its vastness or pity as it deserves.
- rusk 6y agoThing to be mindful of with Cromwell, is that to some he’s a hero and to others he was a monster. A dichotomy heretofore yet unresolved after centuries.
- classified 6y agoHe was a hero to his fellow monsters. Maybe he was inevitable, as some situations just breed monstrosities. That doesn't make his deeds less atrocious.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dash2 6y agoYou are probably thinking about Ireland. Antonia Fraser's biography covers this in detail. Many things that happened under Cromwell's command were standard practice in siege warfare at the time. Of course, by modern standards it's atrocious, but that tells us more about the 17th century than about his personality. He also believed, rightly or wrongly, that he was responding to Irish atrocities against English settlers.
- BaseS4 6y ago17 years in Afghanistan is the US responding to Islamic atrocities against New Yorkers. How does that frame taste?
- rgblambda 6y ago> Many things that happened under Cromwell's command were standard practice in siege warfare at the time. If that were true he would have done the same thing in England.
- dash2 6y agoWere there towns which refused to surrender? Colchester, when it finally surrendered during the second civil war, had to pay a ransom of £14,000 in exchange for not being pillaged, and the leaders of the defence were executed.
- wrongdonf 6y agoI was suffering from super bad bipolar episodes and a general mental health crisis recently when I came across a documentary about Cromwell. It was so inspiring to see someone struggle with the same problems and overcome them, accomplish such great things, and do it all before it was even recognized as a legitimate illness. I really came back from the brink thanks to that coincidence.
- fiftyacorn 6y agoThis would make a good horrible histories sketch
- dash2 6y agoThere's not surprisingly a lively debate about Ireland in these comments. A quick reminder about some other aspects to Cromwell's political career: * Lobbying to allow Jews back into England (officially, there probably were unofficial Jewish residents already). * Pushing for religious toleration. * A big expansion in primary education, which was later reversed under Charles II. * The development of science by the Invisible College around Samuel Hartlib, later to become the Royal Society. * Fighting the Dutch and Spanish.
- rusk 6y agoYou could argue that his legacy is still alive and kicking, interfaced in Northern Ireland. Also: * Hitler fixed the roads * Communist Russia got the first Satellite into space
- Grimm1 6y agoThat's neat. Cromwell's legacy is his treatment of the Irish the rest of his legacy can be safely disregarded. "Estimates of the drop in the Irish population resulting from the Parliamentarian campaign range from 15 to 83 percent.[11] The Parliamentarians also transported about 50,000 people as indentured labourers.[2]" We don't go but, "oh Hitler painted pictures too". Edit: Swap "painted pictures" for "built roads", or "helped progress rocket technology", my point is unchanged and in fact strengthened.
- carmen_sandiego 6y agoI'm not sure the things listed are the same as 'painting pictures'. I'm not even saying you're wrong about Cromwell, but at least take the points fairly.
- Macha 6y ago* The first two are simply a rotation. Jews were back in favour, and Catholics were out. * The third was something that happened in Cromwell's reign, but there's no evidence he contributed positively or negatively, and the fact that the monarchy followed up by supporting it and actually chartering the royal society seems to indicate that it had little connection to what the actual regime in power was. * Primary education good, sure. * So I was not familiar with the anglo-dutch war so I read the wikipedia article. This appears to be a trade dispute because the English wanted to look the dutch out of shipping to England that was escalated to war by the English after the Dutch refused their ultimatum? This is being offered as a "good" act? So overall, I don't think funding primary education is an achievement that even begins to counterbalance his actions, sorry. Besides, to go back to the example of Hitler (and no, this is not Godwin's law, Hitler is the most appropriate comparison to Cromwell in Irish history), Hitler was _great_ for technology. The germans started modern rocketry which led to our modern satelite communications, the allies invented computing, both sides made big leaps in industrial production. I don't think anyone sensible thinks the above should be considered in a judgement on Hitler's actions. Neither do I think education/scientific funding should excuse Cromwell's.
- pbnjay 6y agoIn case you just wanted to read the contents: https://archive.org/details/courtkitchinofel00unse https://archive.org/details/courtkitchinofel00unse
- 11thEarlOfMar 6y agoThe recipes start on reader page 74.
- yawaworht1978 6y agoHe should have died for many other things, but eventually they came up with treason and......heresy. So much for implementing religious tolerance. As soon the tides have turned, catholicism was the new trend and predictably, he would be guilty of heresy by catholic definition. Of course all the religious banners and labels always have been an excuse for power and money grabs. Cromwell has a place in history right next to people like pol pot, Himmler and other such figures.