3 ms·
No, it’s not private healthcare that’s the issue, it’s the absurd layer of regulations that were developed over the past 70+ years. Typically some inefficiency
by refurb 6y ago
No, it’s not private healthcare that’s the issue, it’s the absurd layer of regulations that were developed over the past 70+ years. Typically some inefficiency was addressed with regulation that just created a new inefficiency.
To give you a good example - 340b is a govt regulation that requires drug manufacturers to give a 23% discount off drugs to hospitals that treat a lot of low income patients. Great idea right?
Well, that just incentivized hospitals to buy up standalone oncology clinics, fold them into the hospital and then capture that sweet 23% margin on drugs without actually using it to help low income patients.
As a result there are almost no community oncologists now, they almost all work for hospitals and good luck starting your own clinic now.
Good intentions that just made the problem worse.
- rscho 6y agoIn my book, the problems begin as soon as the healthcare system is required to be lucrative. And don't tell me not-for-profit hospitals are not lucrative. It would be even worse without regulations. Care providers would illegally organize into cartels (which is of course already happening) and going to see the doc would then really just be like bringing your car to the garage, with all the 'niceties' that go with that. I don't expect to convince any free market proponent, since to really grasp what I mean by all that those people would have to experience the private system from the inside (as I do). Private interests are very much the problem. Healthcare should be a public service.
- zo1 6y agoI've seen first hand the opposite in my country, where free market private health care is working almost near perfection. All it takes is minimal regulation and then watching the healthy patient incentives aligning with the profit motive without government meddling. And I've been watching in real time as the government is actively blocking and preventing this same functioning private healthcare system from acquiring covid vaccines. Right now, this "evil" private healthcare provider has all the money and willingness to vaccinate us all for free, but the government is denying it because they want a slice of the potential Profit to pay for the vaccines for the rest of the country. So you tell me who is evil because of money.
- rsj_hn 6y agoCurious, which country are you referring to?
- zo1 6y agoSouth Africa...I looked on the wiki page for it now, and it doesn't do the state of healthcare here justice.
- rscho 6y agoOk, so we must have very different views of public health if you consider the south african system to work near perfection. I mean, can you really say that given south african HIV prevalence? And that's just an example among many others.
- monoideism 6y agoI think it's very fair (and as you know as an epidemiologist, correct) to differentiate between a country's public health system and medical system. And between a country's primary, secondary, and tertiary medical care systems. It's true that SA has quite good tertiary and secondary care, while they struggle with public health and primary care. I do think the pricing mechanism of almost any other country outside the US is more reasonable than ours. Insurance, big hospital chains, and yes, to a lesser extent the AMA, have ripped pricing from its market mooring. There are many other countries that have well-functioning market-based medical systems (even as they sometimes struggle with public health system due to poverty): Mexico and India spring to mind. Even catastrophic medical care (eg, cancer treatment, or major trauma) is affordable to the middle class in both of those countries, unlike in the US, where those events can ruin a middle class family even with insurance (I've lived it myself, to some extent). Regulation can play a positive role here, but not by creating more bureaucracies. Rather, we need more transparent pricing. We need enforcement of anti-trust legislation against big hospital chains. With some hesitation, I'd say we also need to resume of significant prior support of basic medical research to push big pharma beyond their current biosimilars business model. And we need to "encourage" the AMA to put out more physicians (the student loan issue can be mostly solved by getting the government out of the student loan game).
- refurb 6y agoYet plenty of countries have well functioning private healthcare. Singapore is a good example. Hell, even in Canada most primary care doctors run private clinics.
- rscho 6y agoSmall private clinics run by a small bunch or even a single practitioner have almost nothing in common with huge healthcare companies. This is precisely what I mean when I say that docs have control over their own turf but no further. Such small private structures are perfectly acceptable since they're much less toxic to the system at large. Independent practitioners will never have the lobbying weight that whole companies have, and therefore are IMO the only form of private healthcare provider that can work. Hospitals should be public.