4 ms·
That’s a harsh take in a society that lacks universal income or healthcare. It’s also ripe for exploitation in that anyone can harass your employer into firing
by throwaway894345 6y ago
That’s a harsh take in a society that lacks universal income or healthcare. It’s also ripe for exploitation in that anyone can harass your employer into firing you if you offend them. I’m sure that works great if the mob is on your side, but mobs aren’t exactly known for their fidelity.
- krapp 6y agoPerhaps it's harsh, but it's true, and it's always been true. Employment has never existed in some pocket universe entirely separate from society or its consequences. And many of the same people most vocally complaining about cancel culture belong to the political axis that opposes universal income and social safety nets, labor rights and protections for special classes, and if the "twitter mob" came after progressives, feminists or LGBT people wouldn't lift so much as a finger in protest. So it's difficult in that case to have sympathy with people who want to have their cake but refuse to eat it.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> Perhaps it's harsh, but it's true, and it's always been true. Perhaps it's always been true in the US, but other countries protect employment. > Employment has never existed in some pocket universe entirely separate from society or its consequences. By that logic, someone murdering you is likewise "Social Consequences". But fair enough, if you're ruggedly in favor of at-will employment and you're fundamentally opposed to free speech, then cancel culture poses no contradiction to your views. I think such a position is odious, but I can at least respect your principled stance as a staunch illiberal conservative.
- krapp 6y ago>Perhaps it's always been true in the US, but other countries protect employment. True. >By that logic, someone murdering you is likewise "Social Consequences". Of course it is. Have you never heard of honor killings? Crimes of passion or revenge? Something can be a social consequence and also be a crime. No one is arguing that all social consequences must be legal, or should always be tolerable. >But fair enough, if you're ruggedly in favor of at-will employment and you're fundamentally opposed to free speech, then cancel culture poses no contradiction to your views. I think such a position is odious, but I can at least respect your principled stance as a staunch illiberal conservative. This is why I should stop trying to have political conversations on Hacker News, in the end, everyone just makes it personal. I'm actually opposed to at-will employment and I support free speech, albeit not the absolutist definition of free speech that Hacker News seems to believe in. I do support the right of groups to petition anyone they like - even employers, to air whatever grievances they wish. Cancel culture, while it can be abused, is an expression of free speech. And that's the rub - everyone wants to abridge the free speech rights of the "twitter mob" because of politics, but no one wants to address the fact that the only real power in "cancel culture" lies with the employer.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> Of course it is. Have you never heard of honor killings? Crimes of passion or revenge? Something can be a social consequence and also be a crime. No one is arguing that all social consequences must be legal, or should always be tolerable. I understand your point, but I'm assuming that when people say "free speech doesn't mean freedom from Social Consequences", they're not talking about honor killings, and if they are that really takes the moral wind out of their sails. > This is why I should stop trying to have political conversations on Hacker News, in the end, everyone just makes it personal. Not making it personal; just following the logical breadcrumbs. > I'm actually opposed to at-will employment and I support free speech, albeit not the absolutist definition of free speech that Hacker News seems to believe in. It's not free speech if it's threatening, coercive, harassing, etc. If you're intimidating people into silence by showing that you can get people fired for wrongthink, that's inherently threatening and harassment. Cancel culture is decidedly not free speech. It would be free speech if we strengthened employment protections such that the mob can "petition" your employer all they want, but your employment will remain secure. In that case, there's no threat or coercion, only persuasion. Of course, then cancel culture would go away because it was never actually about speech in the first place. > And that's the rub - everyone wants to abridge the free speech rights of the "twitter mob" because of politics, but no one wants to address the fact that the only real power in "cancel culture" lies with the employer. Raises hand. I don't want to abridge the free speech rights of the Twitter mob; I want to prevent employers from terminating people on account of Twitter mobs.
- pseudalopex 6y agoSaying anyone can harass your employer into firing you if you offend them is begging the question.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI don’t believe it is. At will employment allows for the abuses we see in cancel culture. If you’re asking “are people organizing campaigns to have people fired?”, there are numerous examples. One which springs to mind is Lee Fang—he was targeted by coworkers although he wasn’t ultimately fired. Another would be David Shor.
- pseudalopex 6y agoThat claim is much weaker. Didn't you say cancel culture isn't a very good term?
- throwaway894345 6y ago"cancel culture" isn't a very good term because it can encompass different things, but I've established several times in this thread what I mean by it: harassment campaigns for the express purpose of having an employee terminated because they caused offense. I don't understand why you say this claim is weaker (weaker than what?).
- pseudalopex 6y agoYou claimed previously anyone can harass your employer into firing you if you offend them. The new claim is weaker. Cancel culture is also a bad term because it isn't a culture.
- throwaway894345 6y agoAnyone can harass your employer into firing you if you offend them because we have at-will employment (or more precisely, because we don't legally protect one's employment from cancel culture). Those aren't rival claims... > Cancel culture is also a bad term because it isn't a culture. No argument here, but I'm going to keep using it for lack of a more precise, widely-agreed-upon term.