5 ms·
Ross Ulbricht – Decentralize Social Media
- fandroid 6y agoNot sure why a convicted felon away for life gets any credibility in the tech community. Yes, many in these parts think he was just "running a website", including his mom. Tells you a thing or two about his upbringing. Mr Ulbricht was a kingpin drug trafficker and I really couldn't care less for his technical opinions. If he were to take a modicum of responsibility for his actions, then perhaps there would be a pathway for him to have a voice in the community. His vote is irrelevant until then.
- darig 6y agoWhat about the moms of the people who bought drugs from the people that sold them on "his website"? fandroid is a voice of the irrelevant community of pg's buttlickers until then.
- caseyscottmckay 6y agoUlbricht was not a drug kingpin himself, but rather he created a marketplace for drug kingpins, right? Also it may be beneficial to judge a person's technical capabilities separate from that person's ethics--both good and shitty people have cool tech ideas.
- vorpalhex 6y agoMartha Stewart got done for felony tax evasion, I still read her recipes from time to time. People typically don't consider white collar crimes to be a big deal. (Drug trafficking isn't normally white collar, but in Ulbricht's case it was pretty white collar. Uber, but for drugs?)
- amyjess 6y ago> but in Ulbricht's case it was pretty white collar Ross tried, on multiple occasions, to hire hitmen to kill people he didn't like. I think once you get into wetworks, it no longer counts as "white collar". Thank goodness he didn't actually succeed.
- dantheman 6y agoReally, he was convicted of that? Because to the best of my knowledge all those charges were dropped. https://www.dailydot.com/crime/silk-road-murder-charges-ross-ulbricht/ https://www.dailydot.com/crime/silk-road-murder-charges-ross...
- amyjess 6y agoWhat does it matter what he was convicted of? He still did it.
- h0l0cube 6y agoThere's a distinction between allegation (and even conviction/settlement) and fact. On a case this high profile and with such high stakes there's plenty of motivation for spurious allegations. That they didn't follow through is telling
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lukas099 6y agoThey did not follow through because he failed to actually hire a hitman. He got scammed instead, which ironically saved him. I encourage you to read the transcript in which he attempts to arrange the assassinations [1]. It is pretty obvious what he is doing. To go back to the original point, though, I do not believe that his crimes make his ideas about social networks irrelevant. [1] https://www.wired.com/2015/02/read-transcript-silk-roads-boss-ordering-5-assassinations/ https://www.wired.com/2015/02/read-transcript-silk-roads-bos...
- h0l0cube 6y ago> They did not follow through because he failed to actually hire a hitman. Not sure why that isn't a crime, but I stand corrected. Thanks for responding with legitimate criticism instead of just downvoting
- jaxx75 6y agoDo you also feel the same way about ideas from Peter Sunde, Kevin Mitnick, Shawn Fanning and the like? Dismissing ideas because of the origin rather than the content doesn't seem very open minded.
- fandroid 6y agoWe dismiss a felon's voice at the polls for life. I don't agree entirely with this as they did their time, but that's not the case here. In this case, Mr Ulbricht is doing time, doesn't mea culpa (quite the opposite -- he and his supporters think he's a victim), and is now commenting on yet another technical topic (first was bitcoin) the impacts of which are detrimental to him in his predicament. If he were to have been an ex-con at the time of writing who took responsibility for his actions, I may have had a different opinion.
- ryanlol 6y agoKevin Mitnick is not like the others.
- h3cate 6y agoYou left Alan Turing off that list
- bdcravens 6y agoIf you Google "silk road screenshots" the first image is one showing "Cocaine" as a category. Users didn't create categories; admins of the site did. Kind of blows away plausible deniability.
- esrauch 6y agoI don't think anyone is suggesting that he was unaware that silk road was being used for drug sales. I think the dispute is whether a person who ran such a website can still have interesting ideas to share.
- bdcravens 6y agoI was speaking only to one point: > Yes, many in these parts think he was just "running a website"
- esrauch 6y agoI think they meant "many in these parts think he was just running a website which enabled drugs to be sold" vs the accusation that he hired hitmen or was running a drug cartel.
- Teever 6y ago> Not sure why a convicted felon away for life gets any credibility in the tech community. Because the fact that he is a convicted felon or the duration of his sentence have nothing to do with his technical skill or ability? (Aside from the fact that his failure in opsec lead to his arrest and incarceration.) Just because someone is punished for doing something bad doesn't mean they suddenly stop having good ideas. Another way to look at it, if you were in a room with Ross Ulbricht and he was telling you to not touch a wire because while you're standing in a puddle because the wire is electrified are you going to ignore him because he's a convict? Think of the most terrible thing you've ever done, the thing you tell no one. Do you think that other people should instantly discount all your good ideas if they found out about the terrible thing that you've done?
- fandroid 6y agoNo, because he is without remorse and his ideology doesn't support reparations for his crimes. If Mr Ulbricht were so motivated to make amends for his actions, he would offer solutions for reducing suffering. Instead, with simplistic ideals, he proposes to redo social media in a manner that has no clear pathway to reduce suffering. It is, at best, haphazard. The dangerous wire analogy doesn't hold. Very different situations. Personal demons are similar. Make reparations for pain and suffering.
- StopHammoTime 6y agoThe US Federal Government allowed Perdue Pharma to ravage the US with a corrupt OxyContin prescription system? Sure he was a drug dealer, but if you’re that holier-than-thou the attitude should extend to the whole pharmaceutical industry who are just drug dealers in white coats a lot of the time.
- hitekker 6y agoIt's similar to when Hans Reiser murdered his wife. Bloodlust was similar, the minor difference is that Ulbricht was too stupid to verify the deed was done. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2131449 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2131449 > Because he was a programmer, contributing to Linux, people on /. and elsewhere wanted him to not be guilty. They identified with him on some level. As the evidence started to mount against him, it made people look for crazy ways in which he could not be guilty. Ulbricht's supporters see themselves in him. Each one of them fears the idea of being imprisoned for murder. Therefore, seeing Ulbricht as extension of themselves, they want him to get away with murder.
- mito88 6y agoopinion noted.
- Lammy 6y agoI believe in rehabilitation and forgiveness because bearing a grudge weighs on me, not on the begrudged party. There’s already too much negativity in the world for me to want to add more. Plus he’s in prison for cutting into the TLA drug monopoly more than for anything he actually did imo
- orliesaurus 6y agoAnyone else laughing at the irony of this being written on Medium.com?
- rahimnathwani 6y agoPerhaps ZeroNet and similar decentralized options aren't available in prison.
- idlewords 6y agoI bet this could be built on ReiserFS.
- hggh 6y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26427348 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26427348
- corobo 6y agoNot much of a discussion haha. You linking back here and someone asking "The Ross Ulbricht?"
- qeternity 6y agoWould love to know if he is writing and posting this himself or if he is writing his thoughts (and drawings it seems) on paper and passing them off to someone else to post. Is there any way to authenticate this?
- benlumen 6y agoRight? The hand-drawn diagrams suggest they're being sent from prison.
- eric4smith 6y agoThere’s no point in decentralizing social media. Hardly anyone would use it. The whole point of why social media is so popular is people want attention. In large numbers. Likes, follows, comments. That’s for example, why it will be hard to dethrone services like Instagram or YouTube. The only way they fall is if someone swallows up all the attention. (Eg: tiktok) Decentralization is a Pipe dream that goes against natural human behavior and instinct.
- INTPenis 6y agoI think you can decentralize certain demographics, the same demos that were frequently socially active online for long before big social media came along.
- dragonwriter 6y agoBut those demos are already somewhat decentralized, and engage with centralized social media to largely to engage outside of their demo, getting back to the original objection.
- INTPenis 6y agoYes but what I mean is that there will be two groups of people online. Those who seek out specialized fora outside of big social media just like they would have in 2005. Some were active then, others are too young to have been. The other group will simply go for the easiest choice, big social media, and use that. We had the easy choice and the hard choice back in the 90s too. Internet usually came with some provider, in Sweden it was Spray and in the US it was AOL. You could get online and just go through their network to find anything you wanted, news, message boards, chat. I was a young teenager and didn't even look twice at what Spray offered here in Sweden. I was curious, I looked further, deeper for more specialized places. People haven't changed. Many of us will still do that and end up on decentralized platforms. But at the same time we have a ton more netizens today than we did 20 years ago so the large majority will most likely just go with the easiest option.