3 ms·
MiniDisc user here. It's for a couple of reasons. First of al, ATRAC is a strange format. It's optimized for perception as far as I understood it. It doesn't c
by bayindirh 6y ago
MiniDisc user here. It's for a couple of reasons.
First of al, ATRAC is a strange format. It's optimized for perception as far as I understood it. It doesn't color sound but can reproduce the dynamics and details very well. It's important to understand ATRAC has quality levels: SP, LP2, LP4. SP fits 80 minutes to a 80 minute MD. LP2 fits ~160 minutes, LP4 fits ~320. SP is extremely detailed and transparent. LP2 is really pretty good. LP4 is not good. Is not bad, but for listening on the move. It's not suitable for joy-listening on higher resolution systems. The deficiencies will be definitely heard.
This sound quality has another reason. The DSP/DAC combo on MD players itself. Earlier versions were called Type-R, improved versions are called Type-S. Latter one can reconstruct sound very impressively. It can make SP and LP2 sound really good. It also has a digital amplification section. So, It's only converted to analog at the latest stage. Result is a very dynamic and clean sound. Especially if you convert to ATRAC from CD or any lossless source.
My Hi-Fi (Sony CMT-HX3) also has a 35W version of that DSP/Amplifier combo. It really sounds fantastic* with CD, MP3 and AC3. Didn't try ATRAC, but it won't disappoint I presume.
Sony's higher end systems and DSPs are a work of art. They sound clean, crisp and detailed. They can sing through a pair of good headphones or through 2x85W behemoths. This is why they're timeless and regarded highly. With just Bass & Treble settings, it beats a lot of presumably higher end portable players.
A similar sound quality was present in Creative's Muvo^2. It was plain enjoyable to listen. Apple's iPods famously use Burr Brown DACs but, the sound was too flat and dull in the earlier versions, lacking punch and energy. They fixed it after iPhone 5.
TL;DR: Sony's DSP/DAC/Amp stuff makes any well designed audio codec shine. ATRAC can store dynamics very well. This is why being a Hi-Fi company pays in the portable space.
*: I have a more conventional, but vastly higher powered system. This small guy is not a match for it, but for a small hi-fi it really hits above its league. If you scale this design up (to 80+ watts) with proper speakers, I'm sure that it'll make a lot of more expensive systems sweat.
- cosmotic 6y agoThe DAC isn't part of the format; although I respect the desire for a good DAC. I believe all lossy compression codecs from the past 20 or 30 years are perception based; ATRAC may have been one of the first ones, but it sure doesn't beat a CD which has no loss at all, unless ATRAC/minidisc regularly used higher bit depths than are supported by CDs. The sample rate is already "perfect" (in that humans could never hear a difference)
- bayindirh 6y agoYou're right however, the DAC can make or break the resulting sound. If the DAC wouldn't be important, we wouldn't have Wolfson, TI Burr Brown or other extremely expensive units. Sony's DAC in this pipeline is like a polish. It doesn't blemish the sound after all that meticulous reconstruction. On the paper and spectrogram, an SP ATRAC track is not a match for WAV or FLAC, however it has all the ingredients to saturate a high-resolution system and create an enjoyable listening experience. Also it had enough resolution to handle higher-end amateur mastering (in SP mode) and general recording needs (in SP and LP2 mode). While 44.1KHz is perfect mathematically, 48KHz and 96KHz can create a smoother sound. That needs higher end equipment to hear clearly, but the smoothness is definitely there.
- apecat 6y agoThe guy who created the Vorbis codec explains why this really isn't the case and why high sampling rates with ultrasonics actually are bad for playback quality. https://web.archive.org/web/20120306150922/https://people.xiph.org/~xiphmont/demo/neil-young.html https://web.archive.org/web/20120306150922/https://people.xi... I would really encourage blind testing of one's assumptions about audio quality. Foobar2000 has this super nice ABX plugin that can handle automatic conversation to different codecs and or PCM sampling rates and depth from lossless sources. https://www.foobar2000.org/components/view/foo_abx https://www.foobar2000.org/components/view/foo_abx I can personally recognize full bitrate mp3 (this ancient codec maxes out at 320 kbps where it still sounds colored). This is a well-made pre-configured test https://www.npr.org/sections/therecord/2015/06/02/411473508/how-well-can-you-hear-audio-quality https://www.npr.org/sections/therecord/2015/06/02/411473508/... But move on to anything more modern than mp3, such as Apple's AAC encoder (there's a ton of bad AAC encoders out there) or Vorbis with VBR settings averaging at 256-320 kbps. You'll find it very hard to spot the lossy encodes in a blind test. Opus is astonishingly good at even lower bitrates.
- apecat 6y agoActually, here's an online ABX blind test set with several modern codecs at high bitrates, as well as the bad old mp3 garbage that ruined the reputation of lossy compression. I really challenge you to reliably detect the lossy sample in the tests for Apple iTunes AAC ~256 kbps and Spotify high quality. http://abx.digitalfeed.net/list.html http://abx.digitalfeed.net/list.html
- setpatchaddress 6y agoThis is getting into wooden volume knob territory, but MiniDisc did sound remarkably good compared to MP3 at the time.
- astrange 6y agoNone of this stuff is real unless you can pass an ABX test. I doubt it's real just reading it. ATRAC is not optimized for anything that other codecs aren't (and technologically it's quite bad, especially compared to Opus but even compared to AAC). And there aren't magically better DACs any more than there are better power cables; they're all good enough as long as they're electrically compliant with your headphones.
- bayindirh 6y ago> None of this stuff is real unless you can pass an ABX test. I doubt it's real just reading it. That's of course fair. I can't ship you my MD player (that thing is priceless for me), but I can share a triplet of files for ABX testing. If you wish, I can do the following: - Rip a track from an album before loudness wars began to FLAC. - Rip the same track with Sony's own MD studio to ATRAC SP. - I can re-encode said ATRAC SP track to FLAC. - Ship you three files (A, B, X) where A is FLAC, B is ATRAC SP and X is either of one. If that's OK for you, I can do it this weekend. I'm not claiming anything or hoping for any outcome. My aim is to test, discuss and broaden my mental horizon. I've written these things by listening same stuff in many formats through the same audio pipelines (audio cards, Hi-Fi systems and speakers/earphones) for many years and, I instinctively know how every one of them behaves with any combination. Also, I've played in orchestras (big bands and symphonies), so my ear is somewhat trained to find nuances. Making the some tests and discussing these things will only make me happy, and I'd gladly stand corrected.
- chucktorres 6y agoPlease post this! I’d love to take a listen with good headphones
- bayindirh 6y agoFor everyone interested in what I've told in the GP, can you please register via the form [0]. This Sunday took a different turn but, I don't want to leave this on the table. Thanks. https://forms.gle/miaP5zmefLxtBhNp7 https://forms.gle/miaP5zmefLxtBhNp7