3 ms·
Thanks for taking my question seriously. I guess I get hung up on the quantum field part because I don't understand what exactly a quantum field is in a physic
by criddell 6y ago
Thanks for taking my question seriously.
I guess I get hung up on the quantum field part because I don't understand what exactly a quantum field is in a physical sense. I get that there's a mathematical concept of a quantum field, but does that map to something concrete? Is everything essentially made of nothing?
- tsimionescu 6y agoI'm pretty sure we are not yet equipped to answer this question. In the end, QFT and QM are extraordinarily successful mathematical models that predict to extreme precision the behaviors of small numbers of particles interacting. Whether they are directly describing reality or some kind of approximation remains an open question. I believe that some progress on the measurement problem, when it happens, could help point in this direction.
- tsimionescu 6y agoNote: when I'm comparing "describing reality" vs "approximation", I'm thinking of the following examples: 1. An account for how the world actually works are Newton's laws of motion - they describe how exactly objects interact and how it affects their movement. It is of course an approximation, and only works at certain scales and speeds, but it describes mathematically the phenomena that we can see happen. 2. An alternative account that gives the same values is Hamiltonian mechanics, which describes the system in terms of how its energy changes over time in certain coordinates. They both give the same predictions, and Hamiltonian mechanics is more suited for actually computing the motion of complex systems, but it is much more abstract and doesn't give a clear account of how the system actually works.