4 ms·
Beeple JPG File Sells for $69M, Setting Crypto Art Record
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoThe auction page: https://onlineonly.christies.com/s/beeple-first-5000-days/beeple-b-1981-1/112924 https://onlineonly.christies.com/s/beeple-first-5000-days/be... Unlike the collectable NFT's of content that is available on youtube, it appears that this image is unique and you actually own the rights to it - so has some traditional intrinsic value - in the same sense that a painting has anyway.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoExcept its native format can be infinitely copied and enjoyed. And has started down this road, as the OP had a copy of it embedded, which we all saw without paying. That's nothing like 'traditional intrinsic value', seems to me. Theres absolutely nothing different from my experience and the 'owners' experience.
- rafale 6y agoYou could say the same of a high quality replica of the Mona Lisa or a Picasso. It's all about the status of having the "real" thing. If you wanna argue it's vain, I agree, but many people find it impressive at the same time they look down at any copy as pathetic no matter how close to the original, even when to the point to being identical.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoNo, at the point of being identical, the distinction evaporates. That's my point I guess. Imagine for instance that I register the image with a different blockchain. Do I now 'own it' too? Yes, I do, by this modern tortured logic.
- gcollard- 6y agoThere’s rights and licensing fees associated to it. In a couple years this might be displayed in a museum somewhere. Modern art like monochromes are still displayed to this day.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoThere's such fees on any copywrite material. This 'blockchain proves ownership' stuff doesn't add or subtract from that?
- thwarted 6y agoMaking a high quality replica of the Mona Lisa requires work, and it still won't be identical—thus the term "replica". Making a high quality copy of a digital work requires exactly no additional work. It actually takes more work to make a non-exact copy (say the CPU time of recompressing a JPEG with different compression settings). Because there's no work required to make an exact, indistinguishable copy, there is no scarcity. If this was just about recording the rights to use/exploit a work, digitally and mathematically backing the concept of copyright, that would be one thing. That would help with, say licensing stock photos. But what does it mean to "own" Jack's first tweet? How does one exploit that exclusive ownership? Is it the words of the tweet? An image of it?
- vallas 6y agoPeople seem cynic towards those NFTs - as well as the public reaction to the first stock papers or the first crypto currencies. One important question is what will enable NFTs? Maybe it's virtual hang outs places with digital scarcity, then it makes sense.
- bellyfullofbac 6y agoJust like crypto or Hertz stock, people will buy NFTs because they expect tomorrow or in 10 years there'll be a bigger fool that will be willing to pay them even more money to own the thing. (This is the "greater fool theory"). At least classic cars or limited edition supercars actually have proper scarcity, and they are things that can actually be enjoyed and shown to people for bragging rights (i.e. to gain social value) or to attract a mate. In my view NFTs is just yet another digital ponzi scheme, kudos to whoever came up with it, even Jack Dorsey saw the $$$ and got attracted to it.
- illwrks 6y agoSo... if I was to own the rights to it I could DMCA all reproductions of it?
- doggodaddo78 6y agoI don't get it. It seems like selling virtual gold mined from Ultima Online macros circa 2001. Without anything of intrinsic worth, it doesn't seem like a durable investment. It does seem like a good way to dodge taxes and export drug money. I'd rather have a real van Gogh rolled-up somewhere in my FU money civilization-escape yacht.
- ct0 6y agoYeah I agree with this, something has to be going on. Every time the price makes the headline for something, be it art, real estate, etc I usually think laundering is the main driver of extraordinarily high price.
- ethanbond 6y agoIt was apparently purchased by the CEO of the largest NFT... marketplace (?) So yeah it’s basically a marketing expense for NFTs broadly.
- rasz 6y agoIts a scam. Like https://www.engadget.com/2019-02-15-super-mario-bros-cartridge-auction.html https://www.engadget.com/2019-02-15-super-mario-bros-cartrid... "Super Mario Bros. is now jointly owned by three buyers: Jim Halperin, the founder and co-chairman of the collectibles auction company Heritage Auctions," classic fake pump of assets you already own a bunch and want to create illusion of value
- ChainOfFools 6y agoor, in the time honored tradition of the ICO, it's one entity moving money from one obfuscated pocket to the other, under the pretext of a "sale," to inflate the value of an asset class they want to draw unsophisticated attention ($) to. Pretending two wallet addresses are unaffiliated prior to a transaction is trivial to arrange and with some forethought would be invisible to blockchain analysis. But the superficial story is too juicy for the tech (and now, art) press to ignore, and the people savvy enough to expose the fraud also happen to be elbow deep in Eth/crypto HODLings and stand to benefit far too much by letting it proceed without criticism.
- karmakaze 6y agoFor that much, it should have been an HDR png or tiff. Unless the compression artifacts 'add to the charm.'
- dannyw 6y agojpeg at high quality settings is fine.