5 ms·
> There are irreversible psychological effects from opioid and amphetamine abuse This is not relevant to whether or not they should be legal. The prohibition
by sneak 6y ago
> There are irreversible psychological effects from opioid and amphetamine abuse
This is not relevant to whether or not they should be legal.
The prohibition on drug use is a moral issue. If we aren't free to cause deliberate harm to our own bodies, the one thing to which we can be sure we have a clear and unambiguous title, what else can we possibly own or control in life?
Sawing off my own hand with a circular saw is legal. Why isn't poisoning my own brain?
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoPart of the purpose of law is to protect society. Damage to many individuals damages society overall.
- loveistheanswer 6y agoIs there any compelling evidence that drug or alcohol prohibitions have done an effective job at protecting society? What about the evidence that it has done the opposite, by artifically inflating the price of drugs thereby enriching criminals, gangs, and cartels? In Mexico, we have seen how this can lead to the cartels becoming more powerful than the government.
- sneak 6y ago> Part of the purpose of law is to protect society. What makes you feel this way?
- yellowapple 6y agoThrowing people in jail for daring to medicate themselves damages society far more severely.
- malux85 6y agoBecause by poisoning your brain you go into an addictive cycle and are very likely to harm others via crime and or violence in order to get more. As a society we have to control all negative behaviours - including drug addicts that are willing to harm innocents in order to get their next fix.
- sneak 6y ago> Because by poisoning your brain you go into an addictive cycle and are very likely to harm others via crime and or violence in order to get more. We already have laws that criminalize violence and theft, and those apply just fine to drug users who engage in violence or theft. The only possible use for drug laws that apply to all drug users, including ones that do not engage in the (again, already illegal) violence and theft is to criminalize nonviolent drug use. That's morally unjustifiable.
- malux85 6y agoHmmm, I never thought about it that way, I think you're right.
- mcovalt 6y ago> Sawing off my own hand with a circular saw is legal. Why isn't poisoning my own brain? If it was incredibly addictive and loved ones were dying (literally) to saw off their hands, then I'd want to make it illegal.
- loveistheanswer 6y agoSo do you think tobacco and alcohol should be made illegal?
- mcovalt 6y agoMy point is that sawing off your hand is a false equivalency. tobacco ≠ meth ≠ alcohol ≠ weed ≠ sawing off hands. We are very derailed from the original conversation. No, I don’t think tobacco and alcohol should be illegal. I do think addictively sawing off your hand should be illegal.
- loveistheanswer 6y ago>No, I don’t think tobacco and alcohol should be illegal. I do think addictively sawing off your hand should be illegal. Why should addictively amputating your hand be illegal, but addictively killing yourself by destroying your lungs, heart, or liver not be illegal?
- thatcat 6y agoSawing off your hand doesn't have a profitable business model and lobby group.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoI think it's reasonable to compare tobacco + alcohol to marijuana, but from an outside perspective drugs like fentanyl seem to be in a whole different ballpark.
- nate_meurer 6y ago