3 ms·
> And the essay presents its position as a general statement void of all context. Are you sure? From the blog (first sentence): > I try to write using ordinar
by lelanthran 6y ago
> And the essay presents its position as a general statement void of all context.
Are you sure? From the blog (first sentence):
> I try to write using ordinary words and simple sentences.
Since the "I" in this case refers to someone who does not write poetry, speculative fiction, drama, tragedies, comedies ... and only ever writes for a technical audience, the context is clear: technical[1] audience not seeking poetry, fiction, drama, etc...
Further one he says:
> So you can't assume that writing about a difficult topic means you can safely use difficult words.
Once again, that indicates to me he is talking about writing something technical[2], not prose or poetry.
[1][2] "Technical" is not limited to IT and engineering; it's about anything that involves technique. Describing dance moves is "technical", as is writing a recipe (which is very similar in technique to writing a tiny program) or anything involving writing down music (Should you use 7/4 for the first verse, or alternate between 3/4 and 4/4? Which will be clearer to the flautist?)
- davidivadavid 6y agoI don't think Paul Graham writes for a "technical" audience only and am fairly certain he would dispute that claim. I'm also fairly certain that the type of writing he's talking about is mostly non-fiction prose, such as the essays he writes himself (even though he doesn't state that explicitly). Would you consider those "technical" writing?
- yt-sdb 6y agoThe title of the essay is "Write Simply." Furthermore, the second sentence is more general than the first: > That kind of writing is easier to read, and the easier something is to read, the more deeply readers will engage with it. That is a general claim. I agree that it is often good advice, but there are caveats which Graham does not provide.
- zhte415 6y agoWhat is an 'ordinary' word? The first sentence threw me for this precise term, which was internally inconsistent with later in the article talking about second or third+ English language users, or even, not mentioned in the article, first language speakers with differing backgrounds. A very odd term to use. I'd open simply with "Think of your audience, think of your goal" and on thinking of audience expand to "Think of your audience, of which there may be some you've not thought of, or it might just be yourself, and think of your goal, if any."