4 ms·
For anyone who has had extensive experience in MUD and early MMORPG, including Ultima Online, is there anything you would like to be implemented in modern MMO a
by markus_zhang 6y ago
For anyone who has had extensive experience in MUD and early MMORPG, including Ultima Online, is there anything you would like to be implemented in modern MMO and is technically possible? For example I heard from time to time that people claim UO is actually more complex than modern MMORPG, but because I don't play either I'm wonderig what's missing here.
- jakestevenson 6y agoIn my time with a MUD, my absolute favorite parts were: 1. Social interaction 2. Automation! Maybe not all MUDs allowed it, but the one I played was absolutely fine with you using specialized clients such as tintin++ and writing scripts. I started with smaller scripts to automate movement between zones and managing inventory, and I moved on to full bots in there that would take "spoken" commands from trusted players. From what I hear, that'll get you banned in most MMORPGs these days, which is a shame.
- markus_zhang 6y agoThank you. This is very interesting. I know some MMORPG provides you plugins for automation but many new games don't give you solutions for scripting. I'm wondering if there is any MMORPG that actually gives some serious scripting to players for building their own worlds and sharing with others. It's going to be a hell lot of job to balance out but could be really fun.
- duskwuff 6y agoIn older text-based gaming: MUCKs tended to be more oriented towards creation and social interaction than MUDs. Many MUCKs would allow players to create their own areas, with a limited degree of scriptability. In modern gaming: Second Life, VRChat, Roblox, et al.
- markus_zhang 6y agothanks, those are interesting games. I'll check out the MUCKs and see how they balance things (or maybe they just didn't care). The game Neverwinter Nights(2001) introduced a powerful editor so that players can create their own world and join servers. But those servers have to be separated because of different scripts. It would be really fascinating if somehow we can have a connection center (thinking the Sigil city in Planescape) and players can join different "worlds" which maybe have completely different sets of rules (but have the same meta rules to make the connection possible).
- duskwuff 6y agoMUCKs tend to be primarily social; any "game mechanics", beyond absolute core functionality like movement and communication, exist only by consent of the players. Game balance isn't really a concern. Second Life and VRChat roughly follow this model as well. Roblox worlds are more isolated, kind of along the lines of what you're describing for NWN.
- markus_zhang 6y agoI also thought about some MMORPG that have events, but no real quests. You can figure out whatever quests you want in an event. Events could even be triggered by players. You setup the rules (by powerful scripting) and wait for players to trigger them. For example, maybe some player discovered a summoning book, read a page, and somehow opened a maw to another plane and attracted an endless stream of demons. This is a player-triggered event and other players can do whatever they want. They can ally with the demons, they can fight them and craft items from their remainings. The game designer just make sure that every event doesn't break the whole game. Maybe I went too far there with my imagination, lol.
- ianbicking 6y agoIt would be cool to use automation to turn yourself into an NPC. I almost wonder if you could train an RNN or something on player action and have it start to clone behavior...
- myko 6y agoThe game I played (NCMUD) allowed this and it had a lot to do with me becoming a programmer (MUDs in general did really). At one point I wrote something to generate zones somewhat randomly using the editor the game had built-in - it would transition from "zones" of a particular type (forest/water/desert) and take a few random strings to create (hopefully) reasonable descriptions of a place that could exist. Not the most interesting zone but it allowed me to create blank canvasses to put more interesting elements into. All done with ZuggScript
- PebblesRox 6y agoThere are some fun stories by u/Patches765 on reddit about MUD scripting. I especially like this one: https://www.reddit.com/r/patches765/comments/5euzt2/intelligent_gaming_trekmush/ https://www.reddit.com/r/patches765/comments/5euzt2/intellig... And if you scroll past the D&D links here, he's got a whole series of stories from his time on the Shadowdale MUD though I forget if they involve any scripting. https://www.reddit.com/r/patches765/comments/5isji2/intelligent_gaming_index/ https://www.reddit.com/r/patches765/comments/5isji2/intellig...
- markus_zhang 6y ago> There was several courses I had to complete to "graduate". Each of these were run by a real player who took their job WAY too seriously. I found this kind of things very fascinating. Isn't immersion the ultimate goal of MMO games? Don't the designers want to create a full virtual world so that people can join and forget about real life for a couple of hours? In that perspective, maybe having terrefic graphics actually hurts the real objective. I'm not saying we should go back to MUD, but I'm saying that MMO development teams should invest more in world building. Thank you for introducing such a great poster to me. This guy is a gold mine.
- bcrosby95 6y agoI guess it depends upon what you mean by complex. UO was a 2D world, MUDs are text worlds, and modern MMORPGs are 3D - that right there is going to make any given feature more complex in a modern MMORPG than UO or a MUD. What I think they mean is MUDs and early MMOs were more sandbox-style. This can create complex and unplanned interactions in the game. But the market has mostly decided they don't like these style of games. So you won't get a AAA developer making them because the money just isn't there. Many people loved these interactions. But even more hated them. These days you have options. Back then you didn't. Back in 2000, if you wanted to play an MMO, you had 3 options. Nowadays you have dozens. MUDs also have the benefit of not having millions of dollars on the line. And a million monkeys typing all at once. There's literally thousands of MUDs out there. Most of them are really bad and uninspiring. It's funny to think about how things have shifted. Back when WoW was released, instancing was controversial. Some didn't completely consider it an MMO because it let you opt out of a shared experience with others you don't know.
- rsync 6y ago"... is there anything you would like to be implemented in modern MMO and is technically possible?" I don't play any games like this anymore but I did play a lot of MUDs and, later, years of UO. What I always wanted were procedurally generated items - like weapons and armor and so on. roguelike games randomize the names and colors of items, but we all know what they all are and there are a fixed set of them. UO was even worse - you knew exactly what every item was and what it did and that was that. It seems obvious to me that a very enjoyable and delightful aspect could be added to games like this if every time you picked up an item you had no idea what it might be, or what it did, or how it could be used. Obviously there would be some kind of templating involved and a number of attributes that could be randomized, etc., and perhaps even some kind of generalized discovery mechanism where you could divine exactly what this plain looking sword does. Bottom line: I, as a brand new player, just outside the beginner town, should get a plain old short sword off of this dead orc 99 times out of 100. But 1 time out of 100 I should get a short sword that glows blue when I get close to undead creatures and has +X against wolves. Or whatever. To put it another way, there should be an infinite number of different items I can run into throughout the game and they should do lots of unexpected and fascinating things (albeit rarely).
- gverrilla 6y agoI played on a private shard (server) of ultima online for a long time. Official server players might have had a different experience. I have tried a lot of online rpg's since then but never even got close to feeling similar to these days. - Core experience was free. - A lot of emergent gameplay all around. Games today feel more planned-out most of the times. - There were no quests. (sometimes there would be unique quests for a limited time - events) - The necessity to kill a same monster 700x times to try and find X item didn't exist. Because - Items were created using skill, which you had to train from 33.3% to 100%. - When you attacked a player inside a town, the guards would immediately kill you. But when we left town, there was a message saying there were no guards around. PK allowed. And if you got killed, your corpse would be standing there with all the items you were carrying. - Stealing was allowed as a skill you could train (and steal directly from another player backback - he could flag you if he noticed though and guards would come). There was also snooping which was the skill to see other player backpack. - Scamming, home invasion, and all that stuff was allowed. This may seem cruel, but it allowed for so much emergent gameplay that it was incredible. Also - The economics felt more playful, not so hard. Players not necessarily had to do the same stuff or take long time to achieve wealth. You had to be smart. - Scripting. Because to train most skills you would have to do repetitive tasks. - Small server with not that many players, but intense interaction. - There were a lot of bugs to explore, more loose systems, and it was fun :)