4 ms·
>deregulation has spawned record growth in emerging economies, as well as massive growth with the newly liberalized sectors in developed economies (e.g., transp
by SkyMarshal 15y ago
>deregulation has spawned record growth in emerging economies, as well as massive growth with the newly liberalized sectors in developed economies (e.g., transportation, energy, communications).
In Energy and Finance deregulation has enabled massive crisies, in the former a crisis that led to shut downs of electricity to the 4th largest and most innovative economy in the world, and in the latter a crisis the size of which hasn't been seen since the Great Depression.
Is it so surprising that less than 10 years after Graham-Leach-Bliley ('99) undid the last regulations put in place after the Great Depression (Glass-Steagal) that we have another GD-level event? We had a historically unprecedented 80-year run without one of those, then some bankers get greedy, captured both political parties, pay them off, and boom, another Great Depression crisis.
In telecom, it's enabling consolidation of the industry into a small cartel that controls the Internet's infrastructure and who are using their massive revenue to lobby against Net Neutrality so they can shape and toll net traffic at will, unleveling the Internet playing field that has laid so many golden eggs.
On a more subjective level, it's also made tons of cheap stuff we don't really need much cheaper, but at the expense of eviscerating the middle class, grossly increasing the wealth (and hence political power) gaps between rich and poor, and making developed economies more dependent and fragile rather than robust and self-sufficient.
Sometimes I think the deregulation/outsourcing mantra is the Emporer's New Clothes, and I wonder when the consensus will change to recognize that economic optimization may not be so good after all, that economic robustness is a better policy for any self-interested nation.
- tptacek 15y agoTelco deregulation correlates with the birth of the entire commercial Internet. The Internet of Ma Bell-era telephony was a toy for wealthy universities and government research labs. In fact, speaking as someone who helped build an ISP in the '90s, the adoption of the Internet --- as provided by indie IP-as-dialtone ISPs --- was owed entirely to the CLECs and their willingness to route numbers in hundreds of telephone prefixes down a PRI to a single server cage. The CLECs were almost literally the manifestation of telco deregulation; deregulation was practically a synonym for "let there be CLECs". I call this out this simply as an illustration of the bogosity of the logic of your entire comment.
- Confusion 15y agoWouldn't a single Baby Bell entering that market (which would be unavoidable in the face of economic viability) have lead to the same outcome?
- Klinky 15y agoThe government broke up the Ma Bell monopoly due to uncompetitive practices. Not until state regulation & later the 1996 Telecommunications Act, which was a regulation, not a deregulation, stipulating ILECs had to open up & allow CLECs on their networks did we see the flourishing(and eventual crash) you're talking about. The dot com bubble probably helped as anything Internet related was hot. Do you really think the Baby Bells would have wanted to share their infrastructure with competitors? Judging by how they're trying to get back in bed with each other, my guess would be no.
- tptacek 15y agoIt is a non sequitur argument to suggest that had telco's not been deregulated in the '80s, we would still have had CLECs building out the dialin and ISDN Internet of the '90s; that argument leaves out the fact that the RBOCs the CLECs piggybacked on were themselves the product of deregulation.
- Klinky 15y agoI am not sure you understand what "deregulation" is. Certainly an antitrust & monopoly busting lawsuit from the US government is not deregulation. When a regulated monopoly is broken up into smaller, regulated regional monopolies, that is not deregulation. It is also not deregulation when state & federal law has to mandate that line sharing be allowed. Deregulation is the removal or simplification of government rules and regulations that constrain the operation of market forces. The break-up of AT&T & the 1996 Telecommunications Act were nowhere near deregulations. Also I certainly do not believe that AT&T would have broken itself up or the regional operators would have opened their lines up, had it not been for government regulatory actions.
- SkyMarshal 15y ago
- speleding 15y agoMost of the problems with energy liberalization can be attributed to politicians bungling the process and ending up with something that is very far from a properly functioning market. That the messy result ends up performing worse than a government controlled market does not prove that a deregulated energy market is much better for the economy.
- Symmetry 15y agoExactly. "Deregulation" without the ability of actors within the system to set their own prices is pretty much a recipe for disaster. In a normal market you make more money by selling more product. In California the energy producers discovered that given their regulatory environment they could make more money by selling less product. The rest is history. California's problems do show, however, that people shouldn't uncritically think that any sort of deregulation is good. Its always important to to think carefully about what sorts of incentive are being created in any deregulation.