4 ms·
The problem is that QM doesn't account for gravity so far - in QM as it exists today, particles have mass, but do not interact through gravity. This fits experi
by tsimionescu 6y ago
The problem is that QM doesn't account for gravity so far - in QM as it exists today, particles have mass, but do not interact through gravity. This fits experiments, which is not surprising given that any theory of gravity we have today predicts that the gravitational attraction between two masses that low would be much smaller than what we can measure (remember for example that a kitchen magnet's electromagnetic force can oppose the gravitational pull of the entire earth, that's how weak gravity is compared to other forces).
Still, obviously large masses have gravity, so everyone expects that, even if we can't measure it yet, and don't know how to compute it yet, there must be some attraction between particles. There are some theories about it (for example string theory has something that looks like gravity), but since they all predict values much lower than we could hope to measure for now, the problem remains wide open.
However, simply applying Newton's or Einstein's theories of gravity to QM doesn't work. In QM, particles don't have a single position in space and time, each particle is more like a wave with peaks at different points in space at the same time. If you try to compute the gravitational field generated by all these peaks you get nonsense results. So, while we generally believe that there must be some gravitational attraction between particles with mass, we don't know how it would look like.
I think there are also some theories that predict that elementary particles do NOT interact through gravity, that gravity is somehow an emergent phenomenon of a collection of many particles (just like an elementary particle doesn't have a temperature, but a collection of many many particles does have one). I believe this is a pretty fringe theory, but not quite "flat earth" land. Just including it for completeness.
- tumblewit 6y agoThis is what I find interesting. Assuming two quantum particles exert forces on each other. Now they both have mass but the forces they exert on each other are so much more powerful that the gravitational force would be impossible to experiment. Sort of like a man at a distance exerting gravitational force on the Milky Way with instruments the size of galaxy clusters to measure that man or force. Beyond mathematics there would be no experimental way. But my question is if mathematics itself says quantum particles do not have gravity or is that just a limitation of current understanding.
- tumblewit 6y agoUpdate : few other answers clarify this.
- reasonabl_human 6y agoLimit of current understanding. everything at this level is a theory, with math to boot.. most theories say particles have mass and therefore interact via gravity at insanely small levels (which we cannot currently measure), and other fringe theories postulate particles don’t interact via gravity at all... we won’t be able to experiment with these theories until sensor tech / approaches like the OP are refined enough to be in the ballpark of detecting these small levels of interaction.
- tsimionescu 6y ago> But my question is if mathematics itself says quantum particles do not have gravity or is that just a limitation of current understanding. The maths of QM (Schrodinger equation, standard model) currently say that particles don't have gravity. But, they also imply that nothing has gravity - gravity doesn't exist at all according to the standard model. Obviously this is wrong, so we are searching for a theory of Quantum Gravity. There are various pieces of math that do have gravity and are consistent with standard QM, but each of them has various other problems, so none is universally accepted, and they vary significantly in how they add gravity to the standard model.