2 ms·
A poorly thought of protocol, with political goals. It's supposed to be simple in order to support trivial clients, and to prevent it from suffering the web's
by snvzz 6y ago
A poorly thought of protocol, with political goals.
It's supposed to be simple in order to support trivial clients, and to prevent it from suffering the web's ill fate.
But it forces complexity into clients, by making TLS (of all possible ways to do e2ee!) mandatory and by not even giving the client the length of a response before the response is sent.
Of course, for political reasons, protocol can't be extended, and while it's still new and could be made sane, it won't; The authors don't want outside input.
I'd look into Gopher instead. It's old and tested, not to mention free of political bullshit.
- kaoD 6y agoWhat political bullshit?
- snvzz 6y ago>What political bullshit? Refer to "non-extensibility" in the FAQ[0]. Particularly, as applied to content length in 2.12. [0]: https://gemini.circumlunar.space/docs/faq.html https://gemini.circumlunar.space/docs/faq.html
- kaoD 6y agoI don't see what's political about that. It seems like a design decision you don't agree with (and neither do I at a first glance) but I fall to see any political intent.
- snvzz 6y agoTheir whole decision-making process seems to be political. See 1.1 for their rationale against extensions. Whereas 2.x is full of examples of bad decisions which they're stubborn about not fixing. It is basically somebody's pet project, opinionated and full of rough edges they refuse to ever polish. It lacks the processes and, at the core, the quality expected of a standard, and thus we should be very careful not to mislabel it a standard.
- cooperadymas 6y agoI think the OP means "political" as in its broader definition, meaning that it makes strong decisions about what it is and how it should be implemented. In other words, "opinionated". AFAIK Gemini is not and has not yet been heavily used for the politics of government or social issues. If your concern is whether it's a new haven for left-wing/right-wing/whatever-wing nuts to spew vitriol and hate, I don't think that is the case.
- iamevn 6y agowhy does it matter that response length isn't included? Gemini aims to be a small protocol that doesn't need to handle all types of content. if another protocol is more appropriate for whatever thing you want to link just use that. I'm really confused by how vehemently against Gemini you seem to be and by the claim that the Gopherspace has no politics.
- snvzz 6y ago>I'm really confused by how vehemently against Gemini you seem to be I don't like it, and I explained why. Can you be specific on what it is you're confused about? >and by the claim that the Gopherspace has no politics. A claim made by whom exactly?