5 ms·
Am I the only one who thinks that this concept is perfectly good, and all the things the site doesn't have are just great further development of the idea? What
by Brian_K_White 6y ago
Am I the only one who thinks that this concept is perfectly good, and all the things the site doesn't have are just great further development of the idea?
What's wrong with a "wikipedia for recipes"? I would LOVE that.
All the complaints about the quality of the recipes or the lack of more in-depth explaination of each one, some kind of voting/reputation system for the recipes and for the submitters and the voters, Yes those are all good ideas to make the db more useful than just a db.
But you have to start somewhere. How is the core idea here of a public cookbook not fundamentally awesome? I mean hello... GIT. Recipes that are living documents that can be honed over time, complete with viewable history of what changes have been made so you can decide if you agree with them. Branches and forks for all the hundred variations on any given thing. Revisions by better experts than the original submitter of some recipe.
So, today on day one it doesn't already have the benefit of years of contributions and incremental improvements and revisions, Quelle Suprise!
- monkin 6y agoThe only thing that’s missing for me is pictures of each step, and final dish. Why photos? When I’m doing something for the first time I want to see if I fucked up along the way. :-)
- astroanax 6y agoGit might not be the best way to manage recipes, especially when you're targeting a section of users who might have never heard of what it is. Sure, the idea of 'viewable history' is nice, but the average cook would find trouble with it. A wiki seems much better suited for this. To add a recipe, you need to a learn markdown and create a PR. Learning markdown might not be hard, but learning to create a pull request, after creating a github account might put them off.
- tasuki 6y agoI don't think "people who are good at cooking and bad at technology" is the target audience here. The target audience is tech people tired of ads and nonsense.
- SilverRed 6y ago>What's wrong with a "wikipedia for recipes"? Can you imagine the state of the site after 2 power users have a holy war over whether the recipe is meant to have salt in it or not. Cooking is not objective so it would be impossible to properly collaborate or decide if an edit made the recipe better or worse.
- hnick 6y agoCooking is definitely one place that I think the saying "strong opinions, weakly held" is a great motto. Like I have my way of doing things... and it's the best because I have my own taste profile... but I'll try your way to see if I'm wrong.
- Frondo 6y agoMaybe if such comments were heavily moderated (or edited in-place a la the exile) -- cooking is one of the things where even otherwise very reasonable people I've known have gone off the deep end over what seems absurdly trivial to me. Things like a bagel "toasted" vs "just warmed," dishes that have a variety of regional variations (e.g. a lot of slavic dishes like borsch or stuffed cabbage rolls where I've gotten yelled at by people for pronouncing it the Russian way or making it the Slovak way instead of their own nationality's style) seem to bring up far more intensity than I'd have thought possible, but, you know, I learn more about my friends that way and we've remained friends... in an internet comments section? Tough to maintain that kind of civility, I think. possible, but tough.
- hnick 6y agoYeah the authenticity thing especially gets a lot of people going online. I check in and catch up on r/cooking once or twice a week and there are some very strongly held opinions. The funny thing is, the one that gains traction in a post can be either side of the issue depending on the time of day that it's posted. Reddit's voting system carries so much momentum.
- SilverRed 6y agoAnd if you decide that the edit made it worse after trying it? Its better to have each post be owned by someone and then have a ranking system to sort the most liked versions.
- mulmen 6y agoA site like this is valuable for what it does not have. Hundreds of variations or a comment section is a nightmare scenario. That’s the absence of information. It’s just data. The page needs to show the ingredients and steps so I don’t have to scroll while handling raw meat.
- Qluxzz 6y ago> What's wrong with a "wikipedia for recipes"? I would LOVE that. https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Cookbook:Table_of_Contents https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Cookbook:Table_of_Contents
- Erwin 6y agoThere are some food writers that are good at getting to the core of a dish idea, listing out the variations. Felicity Cloake's "Perfect" column in The Guardian for example. For the Wikipedia of food, Nikki Segnit's Lateral Cooking / Flavour Thesaurus are great -- you start out with basic "stew" technique and then a dozen usual and unusual variations.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bufordtwain 6y agoI think it's great as well. So tired of scrolling on recipe sites looking for the actual recipe.
- PhilosAccnting 6y agoI entirely agree, but HN is filled with ASD savants, so what would you expect? It's not precisely correct, and affirmations about known facts are largely a neurotypical thing. NOTE: I'm ASD, so please don't call it my "NT privilege"! A joke I like to say is that a true geek will hear about the President caught in a sex scandal and will obsess about the fact that it was because the password was easy to guess.