4 ms·
> Don't hide things from the user that provide the user with information. We already hide 99.9999% of things that provide the user with information. Thank god,
by crazygringo 6y ago
> Don't hide things from the user that provide the user with information.
We already hide 99.9999% of things that provide the user with information. Thank god, because the real maxim should be don't overload the user with information.
We try to show only the things that show the most useful information at the times it's needed, and hide them the rest of the time.
Scroll bars used to be necessary primarily for scrolling. Once people switched to scroll wheels and trackpad gliding this the primary use case disappeared.
Knowing where in the document you are isn't usually that useful. You started at the top and already know how much you've read. For the infrequent moments where you really do need to know, just jiggle the scroll and you can see it instantly.
It's a very elegant solution. It really does work.
- basscomm 6y ago> We already hide 99.9999% of things that provide the user with information. Thank god, because the real maxim should be don't overload the user with information > We try to show only the things that show the most useful information at the times it's needed, and hide them the rest of the time. Surely there's a middle ground between showing a user everything and showing a user practically nothing and then trying to guess what they might need. Software that tries to figure out what I want instead of just letting me just pick what I want is, frankly, annoying. How does software handle a situation where an option I might want is hidden because I have a use case that the developers didn't anticipate? > Knowing where in the document you are isn't usually that useful. Disagree. If I'm reading a document on the Internet, I probably don't know how long it is before I start reading it (and those ridiculous tags that say an article is XX minutes long are almost always so wrong that they're useless for me). If I'm scrolling with my scroll wheel, I'm probably not paying attention to the scroll bar. If I've been reading said document for fifteen minutes and I want to know approximately how far into the document I've read (and if I have any hope of finishing it up in the time before I have to do something else) the position of the box in the scroll bar is a great way for me estimate that at a glance. Jiggling the page or moving the mouse all the way to the side or doing some other incantation to make it appear completely breaks my flow reading the document and can make me easily lose my place (especially if I'm in the middle of a paragraph). A quick glance at the scroll bar also breaks the flow, but not quite as badly, and it's a lot easier to resume where I left off.
- crazygringo 6y ago> Surely there's a middle ground between showing a user everything and showing a user practically nothing and then trying to guess what they might need. Yes, that's what software already does. And a scroll bar that appears but only when you jiggle the scroll is that middle ground. > Software that tries to figure out what I want instead of just letting me just pick what I want is, frankly, annoying. That's literally all software though. Otherwise every screen would be covered in every possible option, and would be unusable.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoI highly doubt that a scroll bar will overwhelm a user.
- crazygringo 6y agoProbably nothing by itself overwhelms the user. But in conjunction, they absolutely do. You can't look at anything in isolation. Which is why, in UX, you have to be rigorous in removing everything that isn't absolutely necessary.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThe use case didn't disappear. If you're looking at a very long list - could be a document, could be a list of files - it's simply quicker to scan it by scrolling than by finger-gliding. Especially with the Magic Mouse. It's physically tiring to scroll through a long document with multiple finger drags on the surface of the mouse. And knowing how much there is left to look at is clearly useful. Worse, the default MacOS micro-scroll bars are too narrow even when they're visible. I assume this is to encourage track pad and finger-drag use - but that's not a user-centric decision.
- naikrovek 6y agoWhy is hiding the scrollbar(s) today so necessary for real estate reclamation, when it wasn't necessary when 1024x768 was an above average screen size? Mice with scroll wheels existed then, and were common, at least in Alaska, where I was at the time. It's only in the last few years of computers with mouse-driven GUIs that suddenly the scrollbar is intolerable for UX people. Suddenly users are saying that a scrollbar is unacceptable? Really? Or are the survey questions worded to produce the results desired by the designer? The latter seems much more likely. (It's hard NOT to bias survey questions, if you don't know how easy it is to bias them accidentally.) I can't believe that is the honest truth of the situation. I worked with my fair share of excellent designers, and I can't recall any of them ever groaning about any browser chrome, like a scroll bar, ever, with the notable exception of the viewable page space consumed by browser plugins which each added their own toolbar to the browser UI itself. What a horrid period of time that was... If it is such an urgent need, where was that need 20 years ago? The web hasn't changed THAT MUCH. Scroll bars were an accepted thing; unquestioned. But today they're too intrusive? Or they consume too much space? What the? I understand that the science of interactivity has matured, so I'm willing to admit that we know more about how users behave than we did 20 years ago. I still don't believe that any UI would ever benefit from hidden scroll bars over always visible scroll bars.