4 ms·
How do you feel about the infamous Microsoft Office ribbon? Compared to standard 2000-era UI design it made a lot more things visible (by taking things that wer
by kibwen 6y ago
How do you feel about the infamous Microsoft Office ribbon? Compared to standard 2000-era UI design it made a lot more things visible (by taking things that were "hidden" in File/Edit/etc. dropdown menus and making them into persistent toolbar buttons), but that didn't keep it from being maligned at the time.
- im3w1l 6y agoThat's now how I remember it. Before the ribbon you had a huge amount of tiny icons on toolbars, then came the ribbon and replaced with a small number of big icons. Many tools are hidden, because they are in different ribbon-tabs from the one you currently have open.
- minikites 6y agoYou didn't ask me, but I think the ribbon is brilliant and very effective.
- birdman3131 6y agoThe ribbon is both good and bad. For low to medium skilled users it increased their ability and speed. For users like myself it was a step back as I skim read incredibly fast and have a hard time with remembering icons. I could vertically scan a drop down menu for what text I want 5X faster than finding the same option on a ribbon menu with half the items. I was the same person who absolutely hated the vista and up start menu. I had about 4 columns on my xp start menu and could find anything I wanted very fast just skim reading it. Vista+ was horrible until I got an ssd as the search was always several seconds long. Now I like the search on a ssd these days but until they worked the kinks out and I got an ssd it was way slower than a popout style menu.
- chronogram 6y agoI personally love that ribbon. It’s so functional. It’s like a tree-based menu.
- RHSeeger 6y agoThey weren't "hidden" in the menus. It's always been very clear that commands live in the menus. They weren't up front and center, but you knew where they were if you wanted them. The fact that there is a menu bar makes it very clear that there's more you can do. The ribbon design is in your face, it takes up valuable real estate, and (to this day) I still find it hard to locate the options I'm looking for. I find it to be a HUGE step down from the functionality of menus.
- bombcar 6y agoThe ribbon changes where things are depending on how big it is! Even reading the instructions online is embarrassing; I do love the fact that Office for Mac still has a working normal menu bar in addition to the ribbon.
- lambda_obrien 6y agoI love the Office 'ribbon' because it has icons whereas the menus don't. It makes it very easy to quickly pick the tool I need by muscle and visual memory. Also, MS does icons and design well, IMO, because they don't make everything too flat or hidden, they give very intuitive indications of mouse position and such, like with a slight popping-up of the button or whatever. With the menus, I have to engage my language part of my brain rather than just looking for an icon and clicking it.
- UnFleshedOne 6y agoWait till they desaturate the icons like they did in Visual Studio recently or make them all look the same splash of colors like google did with their product icons.
- alvarlagerlof 6y agoI hate ribbon because I could never figure out which tab was right intuitively for most things. The Google Docs-style menu works better for me.
- jfengel 6y ago
- qayxc 6y agoIt's a a double-edged sword really. On the one hand it's a much more approachable and user-friendly design (especially the preview feature), on the other hand it blocks valuable screen real-estate; this is especially an issue ever since the 16:9 trend took over the mainstream laptop and monitor markets. The issue most users had at the time (and some still do to this day) was that they felt it unnecessary and obtrusive. Personally, I welcomed the change since the old menus weren't as discoverable and obvious to me. Since the shortcut keys stayed compatible (I think?) and the ribbons could (and still can) be hidden by default, I never really understood the bad reception of this feature by many (old-school & power-)users.
- qyph 6y agoThe problem I always had with it is that the little symbols are inscrutable, and mouse-over for a description is inconsistent. Because of this I found the ribbon far less discoverable than text based menus.
- frosted-flakes 6y agoIf you're referring to Microsoft Office, very few of the options are unlabeled. The only icon-only buttons are on the Home tab, and those are all frequently-used options. Most of them are obvious, and the ones that aren't are easily discoverable with ToolTips. ToolTips also work very consistently. Hover, and a box appears, in most cases containing a full description and keyboard shortcut(s), and sometimes even helpful graphics. I think you just don't like it because it's different to what you were used to.
- trinix912 6y agoI generally like the ribbon, the only thing that bothers me is the occasional little arrow in the lower right corner because it's kinda hard to spot.
- frosted-flakes 6y agoYou can collapse the Ribbon, you know. Then it works similar to a standard menu and auto-closes after you click away. Just double-click a Ribbon tab, or click the expand/pin button on the right-hand side.
- WalterSear 6y agoI hated it, and still do. The cluttered mess of icons makes it harder to find things rather than easier.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI like it when I'm using my sidearm in tablet mode, because I get big touch targets (I learned to appreciate the ribbon in Explorer in particular). I hate it when I'm in laptop mode, or on my desktop PC. My biggest problem is that their layout is unstable - it's context-dependent, size-dependent and seems to magically change with time from one use to another. The second thing that annoys me is that the ribbon only shows a configurable subset of actions - which means I have no easy way to tell if the feature I'm looking for does not exist, or is just not assigned to ribbon.
- smegger001 6y agothat was about the time I said fuckit and went full Linux all the time were i had been duel booting previously. I hated the way MS was going and gnome looked good and got out of my way unless i wanted it to (compiz was fun to play with i miss my wobbly winds and desktop cube). of course they then did their own brain dead UI and I switched to Mate/Cinnamon for saner desktop environments