2 ms·
David Baszucki, the CEO of Roblox (they IPO today on the NYSE) is concerned about "civility" in virtual worlds. Roblox needs about 2500 moderators to keep their
by Animats 6y ago
David Baszucki, the CEO of Roblox (they IPO today on the NYSE) is concerned about "civility" in virtual worlds. Roblox needs about 2500 moderators to keep their users under control.
Second Life, the virtual world, does not have this problem in-world. Second Life averages about 40,000 to 50,000 connected users, comparable to GTA V Online. Second Life does not have an army of "moderators". What it does have is private property.
Anyone can enter Second Life for free, but after a while, you probably want some land and items, which costs money. (Land comes from the owners of Second Life; items are entirely user-created.) You can also rent out land, and so, there are landlords, small ones with a few lots and big ones with square kilometers of land. There's public land - streets, water, parks, railroad track - but you can't build there.
Once you own land, you have the power to exclude others from it. Both users and their objects can be ejected. Clubs, stores, amusement parks, etc. are all privately owned. So there's a form of moderation, one that's entirely local.
Linden Lab has a small "Governance" team. They don't have to do much. They have a public meeting once a month. It used to be every two weeks, but there wasn't enough business to discuss. Most of the issues that come up involve someone obstructing a road, or excessive advertising signage. It's like a city council meeting.
You can file "abuse requests" with Governance. They're mostly about land issues. There's occasional "griefing", but it's a minor nuisance, like littering. Anything being done on someone else's property, the property owner can deal with. Most property is set by its owner with a timeout for foreign objects left there, so stuff left around is returned to its owner after half an hour or so. All public places have such a timeout, usually a rather short one.
Unlike most virtual worlds, Second Life allows sex. There are "adult" areas, and in addition, what you do on your own property behind closed doors is your own business. This keeps sex-based griefing down. In the non-adult areas, annoying users get ejected from private property, and in the adult areas, nobody cares.
Somehow, they got this right.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> Second Life, the virtual world, does not have this problem in-world. Second Life averages about 40,000 to 50,000 connected users, comparable to GTA V Online. Roblox is on a whole different level. Roblox has around 200,000,000 monthly users. That is 4000-5000x what Second Life has. The more users you have, and the more mainstream something is, the more likely you are to have some chunk of the population that are either sociopaths or otherwise think trolling or bullying or getting a reaction from people is fun. In addition, the target demo of Roblox is kids especially young teenagers. At that age, a lot of social skills and introspection and impulse control have not developed for a lot of people. In addition, by targeting kids, they are open to a whole lot more scrutiny. For example, having virtual sex or doing virtual drugs in Second Life would not cause anyone to blink. If that happened in Roblox, it would be front page news on The NY Times and headline news on every news station, and likely a Congressional committee.
- Animats 6y agoNo, only about 40x. Right now, Roblox has 1,797,251 users online. And they're in multiple shards, not one big seamless world.
- hinkley 6y agoStill you might reasonably expect to need 6x as much oversight for 40x as many people. Instead it sounds like they have about 200x as much. Maybe the moral of the story here is don’t try to solve social problems for early teens until you’ve solved it everywhere else.
- Animats 6y agoFacebook has something like 26,000 moderators and is being criticized for not having enough. A system that doesn't need so many moderators scales better.
- hinkley 6y agoThere may be nothing more difficult to manage than an adult who acts like a 14 year old. There was some research done a while back that concluded that a system where members could 'punish' people for misbehavior can be statically stable if (and I believe they concluded, only if) the punishment came at a cost to those meting out justice. Unless I'm mistaken, Stack Overflow read the same paper. Which is why getting upvoted gets you 10 points, but downvoting something you don't like costs you 1 point. You have to want it a little bit more than just the knee-jerk reaction. It means more to you, and therefore it means more to everyone else, too.