2 ms·
I wish I could accept the article's belief that this is something that "the Internet" can fix. Or that if things had been just slightly different ~30 years ago,
by jfengel 6y ago
I wish I could accept the article's belief that this is something that "the Internet" can fix. Or that if things had been just slightly different ~30 years ago, all of this could have been avoided. I wish I could follow their line from what de Tocqueville saw, of happy communities, to a better 2020s.
Unfortunately, I don't see it. The grievance culture that I believe is at the root of it goes back long before the Internet, by decades if not centuries. The Internet could not have redirected it. It would have been swamped by it, regardless of its architecture.
The kinds of shifts they're talking about are easily coopted to feed the grievance culture. People booted out from the monolith complain bitterly, and use it as proof that their grievance is justified. Eliminate the monolith and you'd create silos for people to nurse their grievance in -- and then go seek out the other silos to poison. Until they were removed, at which point they'd head back to have their grievance reassured and topped up.
The Internet didn't create that. It may date right back to de Tocqueville, who politely only applauded us for our positive attributes.
I'd love to believe that the Internet can fix it, but I am doubtful. I don't think any algorithms can overcome divides when there is so much content produced to exacerbate them. And when people are already so invested in the latter as to deliberately ignore the former.
- schnevets 6y agoI see "grievance culture" as a side-effect of America's role as a global leader in the 1940s. I always contrasted America's "victory gardens" and "industrial machine" during WWII to the Afghan and Iraq Wars, where the government merely expected the average citizen spend money and bolster the economy. In between those two periods, you have ceaseless military campaigns whose purposes were muddled and a widening gap between the government and its constituents. It's a gradual enfeebling of a culture known for its "Frontier spirit", that was fueled by a mixture of individualism and a collective good. Now these bored, helpless people are trying to form coalitions against overblown (or outright fictional) adversaries as if pushing such a fabricated purpose will personally help against the crises in their lives.