4 ms·
> From the point of view of a worker which gets their profits diluted in dividends payed to shareholders, the very existence of a stock market very much looks l
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
> From the point of view of a worker which gets their profits diluted in dividends payed to shareholders, the very existence of a stock market very much looks like a scam.
Only if the worker doesn't understand that the initial sale of stock raised the money that let the company buy the tools that the worker uses to make the profits. Getting that money without paying dividends looks like a scam where the stock owners are the suckers.
- runarberg 6y agoTo me this looks like predatory lending. I.e. selling stocks in order to raise money to get means of production is for all intents and purposes the same as getting a loan which you are never allowed to pay back, and your lenders will continue to collect interests, tied to your profits, indefinitely. Still very much looks like a scam.
- joshuamorton 6y agoIts not a loan though. If you fail to make money from your venture, you don't owe the "lender" anything. So you remove the risk to you (you can't owe someone $1 million without any way to pay it). The tradeoff is that you sacrifice some of the upside.
- runarberg 6y agoThis still looks like a scam though. A predatory lender which never accepts paying down the capital, but assumes risks where some of their clients might not turn a profit and therefor is a net loss, will simply raise the interest (or—in the case of an investor—the share of the profits) from the profitable clients to counter the loss. This is exactly the behavior of shareholders, and to my eyes it still very much looks like a scam.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoThe shareholders don't set the amount of the dividends. That is, in your analogy, the lender doesn't get to raise the interest rate. That kind of blows up your analogy. But by all means, tell us again how it looks like a scam. Maybe we'll start to agree with you if you repeat it a couple more times.
- runarberg 6y ago> The shareholders don't set the amount of the dividends True, the board of directors decide to pay the shareholders dividends. But in a hierarchical company to a worker, this board looks like a part of the scam. The relationship between a well paid board of directors (whom seemingly to a worker contributes nothing of value) and shareholders looks awfully convenient (one might even say conspiratory), and especially so if the board of directors are voted in by the shareholders. > But by all means, tell us again how it looks like a scam Sure. This whole thing looks like a stinky scam to me. And now knowing the relationship between the board of directors and shareholders of an average publicly traded company, even more so. Now it looks like a conspiracy as well.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> the initial sale of stock raised the money that let the company buy the tools Maybe in the movies. Modern IPOs rarely work that way. Some companies take the money and do things, but the norm is that IPO money goes to existing shareholders (founder et al) and the company continues as before. If the money is enough, the founders disappear into ultra-rich-person nirvana, or go on to found other projects, and the new shareholder-elected board heads the company. A modern shareholder could not care less about future profits. All they care about is deltas on future stock price, whether the price moves up or down. Their profits come when they hand their shared to someone else. Whether the company turns any profits is beside the point.