4 ms·
I would hope lies to protect another person from harm are allowable. We suspect an enemy of the revolution is being harbored in hour house. Are you hiding this
by mc32 6y ago
I would hope lies to protect another person from harm are allowable.
We suspect an enemy of the revolution is being harbored in hour house. Are you hiding this person? (forgive the preposterous example, but I hope you get my intent). It could be someone hiding from a jealous lover, someone hiding from loan sharks, etc.
- nullserver 6y agoNot being Murdered is one level. Did you do the dishes is another. Have kids. Did you eat chocolate bar? No!!!! So how did the chocolate get all over your face?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoThat's why I mentioned surgery at the end of my comparison with blade cuts. Much like cutting into a body is traumatic for it, but is sometimes require to save it, sometimes the ethical benefits of a lie far outweigh the costs. Yours is a very good example. There are also more fuzzy ones. Since I mentioned medicine: there's an ongoing discussion in the medical community as to if and when lies by omission are OK - is there a point to informing the patient about something they can do nothing about, when if they learn about it, it would cause them great amount of emotional distress? Caring for health doesn't mean just servicing the body like a mechanic, but also catering for person's emotional well-being. The point I was trying to make is that lies, by default, are bad things (much like being cut by a blade). Intent, care and consequences are what can make lies very bad, or - sometimes - good.
- nullserver 6y agoGrowing up in Church, not lying was a big issue. 10 Commandment and all. Caused a lot of heartache for a lot of people. Met lots of missionaries who Preached in extremely bad countries and situations. Quite annoyed to find out it was a translation issue. You don’t lie then testify against people. Which is a highly specific and malicious sort of lie.