3 ms·
Same basic mechanism, but social media is a lot more efficient because (mis-)information travels much faster and reaches more people in shorter time, so you don
by flohofwoe 6y ago
Same basic mechanism, but social media is a lot more efficient because (mis-)information travels much faster and reaches more people in shorter time, so you don't get the "cool down effect" of a slower transport medium.
- kmeisthax 6y agoThis is only partially true: in prior media eras, low-quality journalism was notorious for doing what Facebook and Twitter are now. We only notice it because we've come out of an almost century long period in which the most effective broadcast mechanism was regulated by the FCC. This is an accident of engineering; the only reason why the FCC was even allowed to what is blatant government censorship is because of the scarcity of radio spectrum. This died the moment cable news networks became widespread. The only restriction on what, say, Fox News, CNN, or MSNBC can publish is their carriage agreement with the cable companies, which usually just dictates genre, not content. Social media is that but laundered across millions of users who "choose" what to share and like out of what platform algorithms recommend. Prior to television, there was radio, which was also regulated under a similar regime. However, newspapers ruled the roost before that, and they had practically no limits on speech save for extremely weak defamation laws. They also were instrumental in spreading a lot of outright bullshit. "Yellow journalism" is an anagram of "clickbait", after all; and the press were perfectly happy to engage in exactly the same tactics we see today... for pretty much the same reasons. Selling lurid descriptions of political foes and foreign threats makes more money than level-headed explanations of the same controversies. I'm not sure if either scenario could be described as "good". The FCC effectively engaged in a soft censorship regime through the means of spectrum scarcity. This meant that every information passed through [the five filters](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_model) of ownership, advertising, sourcing, flak, and (at the time) anti-Communism. On the other hand, it's clearly obvious that a good subset of any group of political ideologues is either incapable of or uninterested in making level-headed assessments about themselves. Self-critique is heresy in the eyes of someone more extreme than you are, and we live in times where the extremes might be right about at least one thing.
- flohofwoe 6y agoWell, "old media" isn't any better, just less efficient. Goebbels would be a big fan of Facebook and Twitter if he lived today, having a "direct wire" into everybody's brain must be a propagandist's wet dream: https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2008/oct/09/radio.hitler.bbc.czechoslovakia https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2008/oct/09/radio.hitler...
- solosoyokaze 6y agoThat flow goes two directions though. Anyone can leave a comment on FB/Twitter posts. I would think propagandists would still prefer the one way broadcasting of MSM, instead of allowing dissent to be stuck directly to their message.
- jvanderbot 6y agoAnyone? Or any account? Let's not forget all the sock puppets that can amplify sources at first, after which a few million political enthusiasts can take up the mantle.
- Rule35 6y agoNo, they need the genuine man-on-the-street rage posts for the five-minute hate to really be effective. They need to cut to shots of normal people screaming. It's worth it to them even if they have to go through and delete all the compelling counter-narratives. (And in a truly captured society, they'd come and pick them up later for re-education, so you posting would really just be helping them find you.)
- at-fates-hands 6y agoPerfect example is the recent Harry/Megan interview with Oprah where social melt down over it. In the interview Megan said she had not talked to her sister in some 10 years and grew up an "only child" and barely knew her. She also said her sister changed her name when she found out she was engaged to Harry. an off handed insult. The counter story is getting very little press right now, allowing her blatant lies to be spread without any scrutiny. Inside Edition interviewed her sister and her sister brought proof she was lying: She said: ‘I don’t know how she can say I don’t know her and she was an only child. We’ve got photographs over a lifespan of us together. So how can she not know me?’ The US broadcaster showed four images of Meghan and Samantha together during the clip. Two were from when the duchess was a baby, another from when she was a small child and the last and most recent from Samantha’s graduation, 13 years ago in 2008. Samantha also disputed Meghan’s claim that she only changed her surname back to Markle after the royal struck up a romance with Harry in 2016. ‘She changed her last name back to Markle… only when I started dating Harry. So I think that says enough,’ Meghan told Oprah. But Samantha hit back: ‘I was a Markle before she was.. Markle has always been my name.’ Samantha then showed Inside Edition her petition to change her name that was dated back to December 1997 and her college diploma, which says Samantha M. Markle. This is a fairly non-political, pop culture example, but it highlights the fact lies spread so much faster than the truth, that actually finding the truth is nearly impossible. For me, there are no facts anymore, its all about the narrative now. Whoever controls the narrative, controls the "truth".