6 ms·
That seems like a potentially risky move from YouTube. Won't every other country now demand that they do the same for them? This is going to be extremely confu
by mrweasel 6y ago
That seems like a potentially risky move from YouTube. Won't every other country now demand that they do the same for them?
This is going to be extremely confusing for creators. I can't imagine anyone but the very largest YouTubers being able to handle getting taxed in multiple countries and figure out what exactly they need to pay at home.
Actually, the large YouTubers may be better of simply demonetizing they videos and just sell sponsored videos and embedded ads directly.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Won't every other country now demand that they do the same for them? What other countries have major services like YouTube that pay their content creators in the US where they could 'do the same for them'?
- tinyhouse 6y agoI think they meant that Spain can now demand Youtubers to pay tax for money they made from Spanish viewers on Youtube. Etc.
- chrisseaton 6y agoRight - my point was YouTube can just not show the videos to viewers in Spain. The company isn’t based there - it can forget about it if it wants. What would Spain do about it?
- tinyhouse 6y agoAre you suggesting Youtube stop showing their videos outside the US? You're probably not aware that Youtube has far more users internationally. They will get crashed.
- totalZero 6y agoIt would be a pretty effective deterrent against foreign governments attempting to collect tax revenue on views from within their own jurisdiction. Not sure that anyone will do so, but I think this is what GP is saying.
- realmod 6y agoAt the same time, giving up a market will give another competitor a golden oppurtunity which could come to bite them. And countries could probably somehow force Google to continue operating Youtube there by threatning other Google products.
- tekromancr 6y agoI kinda doubt it. Youtube's "moat" against competition is the fact that storing, processing, and serving video is insanely expensive. Google can only afford to do it to begin with because they are the world's largest digital advertising company. It would have to be another player willing to invest a ton upfront, and continue burning ludicrous amounts of capital over many years before they could actually compete
- realmod 6y agoI mean the competitor could also be large company, for example, dailymotion.com could take over from Youtube without any major hassle. And EU would probably love it since dailymotion is local company.
- 5560675260 6y agoThis would be great, could lead to creation of several national level alternatives.
- unnouinceput 6y agoGoogle has offices and/or servers in almost every country. Spain could simply say "your data moves through our cables, pay up".
- darig 6y agoNobody made any money from Spanish viewers... they made money from YouTube.
- chrisseaton 6y agoYou are hellbanned btw. They are making money from Spanish viewers - Spanish YouTube premium and Spanish advert impressions.
- Ajedi32 6y agoYouTube makes money from Spanish YouTube Premium subscribers and Spanish companies buying ad slots. Spanish YouTubers make money from YouTube.
- ricardobeat 6y agoYouTube is operated by Google Ireland Limited, which is not in the US, so your base argument is flawed...
- Ajedi32 6y agoI don't know which Alphabet subsidiary the payments to creators actually come from, but YouTube itself is headquartered in San Bruno, California; not Ireland.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ricardobeat 6y agoI believe the HQ location has no bearing on the entity you're doing business with. The one in the YT terms & conditions as of now is Google Ireland.
- darig 6y agoAll you dummies can't handle the truth btw. You fundamentally don't understand how YouTube and accounting in general works.
- mywittyname 6y agoThat's not a bad thing. It's also probably not onerous for a company with the resources of Google to deal with. The technical work is already done to handle the US.
- yoz-y 6y agoHow is abiding to the U.S. law, where Google/YouTube is incorporated a "risky move"? It's not like there is a choice. https://support.google.com/youtube/thread/101463270?hl=en https://support.google.com/youtube/thread/101463270?hl=en
- bilbo0s 6y agoI thought that was a strange phrasing as well? Since when is YouTube more powerful than national governments? People seem to be under some confusion as to how business works. The governments tell YouTube what YouTube has to do to operate in their jurisdiction, and YouTube either does it, or leaves that jurisdiction. If Togo made the demand, you can leave. If the US or Germany make the demand, you say, "Right away sirs", and you start collecting their taxes.
- Isinlor 6y agoThen I guess EU should do the same. Americans on YouTube should pay taxes in EU on EU ad views or YouTube should leave EU. But I think in practice EU is thinking more in direction of simply taxing global profits of tech giants.
- systemvoltage 6y agoTax global income of a company not based in EU for doing business in the EU? Is that what you mean?
- Isinlor 6y agoYes, EU seems to be looking to establish rules to determine how much profit a company generated in the EU and tax that [0]. > The new rules will also change how profits are allocated to Member States in a way which better reflects how companies can create value online: for example, depending on where the user is based at the time of consumption. Seems like currently EU is in the process of public consultations on a new digital taxation [1]. I'm not sure how the details changed since the proposal, or where they will go. But EU is certainly moving on it. [0] https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/business/company-tax/fair-taxation-digital-economy_en https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/business/company-tax/f... [1] https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12836-Digital-Levy https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-sa...
- ssijak 6y agoIn the same TOS change Google added a point where they say that they can show their own ads on demonetised videos https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/10090902?hl=en https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/10090902?hl=en
- mavhc 6y agoWell, they are hosting and streaming and re-encoding them for free
- bitcharmer 6y agoYou really think they do this for altruistic reasons?
- mavhc 6y agoNo, but it's weird when people get annoyed that Google are putting ads next to the videos
- TeMPOraL 6y agoProbably not. The US is one of few (two?) countries with tax policies that cross jurisdictions like these, and so far there doesn't seem to be much of a pushback from other nations. Might have something to do with who has more aircraft carriers. But yeah, YouTubers are going to be confused. And it makes me wonder, what's next? What about ad revenue from Google / Facebook? Or is that handled through their offices in Ireland?