10 ms·
The border war is basically petty. Its people clubbing each other to death with lumps of wood and iron because neither side wants to go back to firing guns over
by ggm 6y ago
The border war is basically petty. Its people clubbing each other to death with lumps of wood and iron because neither side wants to go back to firing guns over the mountain passes.
The trade war is not the same as the US trade war in any way. Its real. Nepal and Bhutan are on notice: if they take service from China beyond a level India can accept in a field like telecommunications, the oil and electricity pipeline will turn off.
India has a huge market. And, has raw foods and goods China wants. China has engineering India needs. They both want to trade but they're fighting for supremacy with a border. The trade war with the US is a different set of risks, China holds the debt and US consumers pay the tariff often. India and China, there is a real border. They don't want this getting to lobbing bombs.
Visiting each other is sensible. Both economies have pretty baroque trade laws, investment risks. Learning more about each other's culture and style is sensible.
- Clewza313 6y agoI don't disagree with most of what you say, but it's worth noting that Bhutan exports electricity to India, not the other way around.
- ggm 6y agoThey're still told very firmly not to form trade links with China without India's permission. If its not electricity there is some other dependency which is used as a holdover. Construction materials i would guess.
- devdas 6y agoThat border controls the sources of major rivers for both countries. Water is a critical resource.
- qart 6y agoWater is one aspect, and the other (in Kashmir) is land for their Belt-And-Road project. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d_00Xx9b87A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d_00Xx9b87A
- ggm 6y agoBelt-and-Road is trade war by other means. As is the investment in the pacific island economies (help == votes on a nation-state basis in the UN processes) and in Africa (we get the coltan, you get the money: we don't care about your human rights) In australia, we're about to pass enabling legislation to let the federal government prevent states and territories signing to belt-and-road without federal oversight. Without insulting India or Kashmir,Nepal/Bhutan, I think this kind of "no, not unless we say so" thing, is not that different really. India knows it has to deal with capital investment led state risks. From a finance side, this is called "soverign risk" but from a sovereign state side: what else is it, to be a nation-state? don't you get to say "no" to these initiatives, inside you (enclaves or states or disputed territories)