4 ms·
The definition of life is trivial: it is what biologists are interested in. If you want to know if something is alive, just count the biologists following it. R
by ncmncm 6y ago
The definition of life is trivial: it is what biologists are interested in. If you want to know if something is alive, just count the biologists following it. Rabbits? Yes. Bugs? Yes. Viruses? Yes. Protons? No. Memes? Not really. Computer viruses? No.
Might the definition change, as biologists encounter new stuff and develop an interest? Sure. Does that make the old definition wrong? No.
- chousuke 6y agoThat's not a very useful definition. What is it, then, that biologists are interested in? If you answer "life", your definition is circular and without informative value.
- ncmncm 6y agoIt is a perfect definition for exactly that reason. The boundary between life and not-life is exactly where biologists' interest fades. If you wonder why something is not alive, just ask any biologist why it is not interesting. Different biologists may give you different answers, but all their answers are useful.
- benjaminjosephw 6y agoRemember when science was the pursuit of knowledge of the observable world? What you're talking about is a rigid classification of facts - almost as if "organizing the world's information" from a single dominant perspective was a worthwhile ends in itself...
- ncmncm 6y agoThat is inherent in trying to define "life": inventing a word for a distinction the universe doesn't care about, but people do. The people who care most are, exactly, biologists. If you don't care much, then you aren't a biologist, and don't need an answer.
- gizmo686 6y agoThat is empirically not true. Sugar is not alive, but it is of interest to biologists. Viruses are not generally considered to be alive, but are of interest to biologists. Priors are not alive, but are of interest to biologists. Additionally, scientists do not actually divide themselves into neat little boxes. A Biochemist does chemistry. A Quantum biologist does quantum physics. A Computation biologists does compute science.
- lisper 6y ago> Priors are not alive Did you mean prions?
- wiz21c 6y agoThese are Bayesian prions...
- ncmncm 6y agoBiologists are interested in sugar only insofar as things alive are using or making it. A biochemist decides whether a chemical is interesting according to whether it is made by or affects something alive. And so on.
- RobertKerans 6y agoThis is a very Twain-esque definition. It's very good, thank you for posting it (and for providing entertainment by patiently replying to those arguing vainly against its irrefutable logic).
- pvaldes 6y ago> The definition of life is trivial: it is what biologists are interested in Computers, bikes, music and pizza I almost forgot money from grants... silly me