Completely agree. And the thing I love about your comment is that even though you've found solid argument for why the OP's criticism was right, you articulate

Completely agree. And the thing I love about your comment is that even though you've found solid argument for why the OP's criticism was right, you articulate the tradeoff and explain why you think it was the wrong one. This is a dramatically more effective and compelling approach IMO. If you happen to do design work and are looking for a job, I'd love to chat and see if there are any possibilities for collaboration. If you're interested, feel free to drop me a line at my username at google's mail service.