6 ms·
> How was selling more stock in that situation legal? Why should it not be? Consider the following situation: 1. Alice owns 5 shares of Hertz. 2. Hertz owns
by vkou 6y ago
> How was selling more stock in that situation legal?
Why should it not be?
Consider the following situation:
1. Alice owns 5 shares of Hertz.
2. Hertz owns 5 shares of Hertz.
3. Bob is an ape. For some stupid reason, Bob wants to buy 5 shares of Hertz.
Is it immoral or illegal for Alice to sell her 5 shares to Bob?
If not, why should it be immoral or illegal for Hertz to do so? Especially if they are up front about their incredibly bleak financial prospective.
Is the sale defrauding someone? Who is it defrauding? Bob? Bob wants to buy the stock anyways, because it's a meme stock - why does he care if it's Alice, or Hertz selling him that stock?
If allowing Bob to buy stock is such a bad thing that we need to protect Bob from it, then the correct thing to do is for the stock to be delisted.
- sigstoat 6y agoand: if it is fine for Alice to sell those shares, what if Hertz is willing to sell them for less than Alice? Should Bob have to pay Alice's higher price for a worthless thing, to avoid some immorality happening?
- Spooky23 6y ago1. Alice owns three cartons of unfiltered cigarettes. They are harsh and kids don’t buy them. 2. RJ Reynolds owns many cartons of Camels. Reynolds creates a cartoon camel called Joe Camel, who is as recognizable to 6 year olds as Mickey Mouse. 3. Bob is a 11 year old. For some stupid reason, Bob wants to smoke Camels and be cool like Joe. Is it immoral for Reynolds to sell to an 11 year old? Is it immoral for Alice to sell her cigarettes to Bob?
- vkou 6y agoIt's immoral for Alice to sell cigarettes to a minor, and it is also immoral for Reynolds to do so, so the analogy doesn't work. Since, uh, nobody has an issue with regular stock holders selling their shares to other stock holders. If Bob is not 'sophisticated' enough to be allowed to buy shares of Hertz regardless of who is selling them, then sure, prevent him from buying. Delist the stock. Require you to be an accredited investor to buy shares of a company undergoing bankruptcy. These are all reasonable solutions to the problem. Stopping Hertz from selling shares... Is not. Because if Bob is an informed/sophisticated/accredited investor, then Hertz selling him shares isn't actually defrauding him.
- Spooky23 6y agoJust like RJ Reynolds and Joe Camel, the Hertz management knew that their share offering was targeted at investors ill equipped to make a rational decision. It is bad faith and fraud. The prevalence of the “it’s just the market” argument and corresponding ethical gap here is disturbing. Read the Ben Horowitz “why I didn’t go to jail” post that was reposted earlier this week. End of the day, everyone who signed off on the Hertz offering decided to paper over an obvious moral hazard with sophistry and bullshit to enrich themselves (via bonuses) and bondholders by defrauding the public.
- vkou 6y agoSo, why is Alice selling her shares to Bob, who is clearly an idiot for paying good money for shares in a bankrupt company not a trade made in bad faith? In fact, if Hertz sells enough shares, they are no longer bankrupt - which actually makes buying their shares with the intent to hold a rational decision. That's not why Bob is buying them, though, he's buying them because it's a meme stock, and he, I guess, wants to buy meme stocks. He not so unsophisticated that he fails to understand that Hertz is a shitty company. Why are we protecting him from Hertz, but not from Alice?
- pwillia7 6y agoYou could use the same argument for snake oil, which I think is pretty universally not accepted as moral.
- Lazare 6y agoNope. With snake oil, we would way that it is immoral for ANYONE to sell it. As a result, we (mostly) make it illegal too. With Hertz stock, nobody seems willing to say that all sales of such stock are immoral. And certainly they're not illegal; people have been buying and selling an enormous volume of Hertz stock.
- pwillia7 6y agoBut even if I say -- Hey this is snake oil don't buy it, I'm still not able to say Snake oil. See 'Radioactive weight loss pills! *contains to radioactive materials'
- Lazare 6y agoCorrect. Snake oil is intrinsically bad. We all agree it's bad, and thus, nobody is allowed to sell it, even if they disclose that it is snake oil. But Hertz shares are apparently not bad. We're clearly happy to see people buying and selling them. Before, during, and well after Hetz's abortive at the money offering, thousands and thousands of people were selling Hertz shares, and I haven't seen anyone suggest they should have been prevented from doing so. In fact, it seems like the only entity we, as a society, seem to feel shouldn't be allowed to sell Hertz shares is Hertz. Which would be really strange if Herz shares were, metaphorically, radioactive, no?
- vkou 6y agoSelling snake oil is illegal and immoral because it misrepresents the product. Selling stock, when you make it clear that your stock is worthless does not misrepresent the product. And, again - note that Alice is not even required to make such a disclosure, when selling her stock to Bob. The assumption on the stock exchange is that as long as public companies are up front and honest about their financials, it's Bob's responsibility to not buy stupid, overpriced crap.
- gpapilion 6y agoThe key difference is Hertz created the five shares out of thin air. So Alice now has a diluted position.
- vkou 6y agoA diluted position in a firm that is now more valuable, because it is less likely to be completely eaten by creditors, who will leave the shareholders nothing. If this were a problem, then companies would not be allowed to dilute shares. They are, though. Would you rather own all the shares of a worthless company, or some of the shares of a company with a value > 0?