3 ms·
Nuclear is actually very safe. The article cites a tot of less than 100 all-time deaths of plant operators. It’s hard to find global statistics, but 14 people
by hedora 6y ago
Nuclear is actually very safe. The article cites a tot of less than 100 all-time deaths of plant operators.
It’s hard to find global statistics, but 14 people were killed by wind turbines in 2011, in England alone:
https://www.quora.com/On-average-how-many-people-do-wind-turbines-kill-a-year?share=1 https://www.quora.com/On-average-how-many-people-do-wind-tur...
Roofing is the second most dangerous profession in the US. I’m sure solar panels have also killed more people than nuclear incidents.
As for pollution? All energy sources pollute. Nuclear is better than coal. I don’t know how it compares to solar + wind + batteries + hydro, but those last two are definitely big sources of pollution, and batteries are obviously creating more waste by volume than nuclear.
- dan-robertson 6y agoThis is a fact that it seems impossible to convince people of (though maybe France was successful), so within the constraints of current politics it might as well not be true.
- legulere 6y agoSafety is not about deaths alone. You can’t ignore the massive costs and negative personal effects of Chernobyl and Fukushima.
- AstralStorm 6y agoI cannot ignore negative personal effect of loud wind turbines and healthcare cost of the PM10 and finer particulates either. No, renewables cannot provide all the power we need even if humanity scales down the energy use, which is not going to happen. (Batteries, even sodium-sulfur, at these scales are impossibly expensive, same with pumped storage.)
- legulere 6y agoWhich renewables are producing PM10 emissions? The problem of renewables is not the power they can produce, but how to handle intermittency. Better electricity networks are one part of the solution, batteries can be as well. Even with 50% renewables Germany has one of the most stable electricity networks in the world. Also in the traditional base-peaked system you still need peeking power plants and you have problems with weather effects (in summer water in rivers can get too warm to use it or dry up, in winter it can freeze)
- lucb1e 6y ago> Safety is not about deaths alone. You can’t ignore the massive costs and [...] Actually, if we're talking about safety, we can. There are some good total cost analyses, since governments also want to know how power can be produced most cheaply. The US and UK both published reports about this with somewhat varying (but ballpark similar) numbers. But anyway, we were talking about safety. > [...] and negative personal effects Okay, please bring on the stats then. I agree that this is relevant to the safety discussion and, thus, the discussion whether we should use nuclear fission going forward, but I never see anyone cite comparative stats on displacement, illnesses, etc. All I ever see is that nuclear kills very, very few people per TWh compared to current energy sources, making it seem very attractive to build as a replacement when looking at this metric. You'd have to have a huge number of people falling ill or being displaced (but not dying) due to nuclear disasters or uranium mining to make it better than our current energy sources.
- pfdietz 6y agoNuclear's problem isn't safety, it's cost. If nuclear were 10x safer but no cheaper, it would still be moribund. If nuclear were 10x cheaper but no safer, it would be the dominant energy source on the planet.