3 ms·
> How was selling more stock in that situation legal? They asked the bankruptcy court, and the bankruptcy court's job is to maximize value for the bondholders
by dragontamer 6y ago
> How was selling more stock in that situation legal?
They asked the bankruptcy court, and the bankruptcy court's job is to maximize value for the bondholders. Turns out that selling worthless stock (for money) is really good for the bankruptcy proceedings (getting maybe 70% of the money back instead of 60%).
Then the SEC came in (whose job is to protect retail investors), and the SEC told them to knock-it-off.
Different jobs for different courts and bureaucracies. Ultimately, the SEC determined it was illegal for them to proceed. But I guess the SEC assumed the bankruptcy courts would do the right thing. When that clearly wasn't the case, the SEC stepped in (a bit late: after $29 million was raised. But better late than never)
- dalbasal 6y agoThat's very well explained. I think that trips people up, in stories like this, is that the SEC has a pause button but not a reverse button. What's done is done, for the most part.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoWhat I don't understand is that Hertz specifically wanted to sell an amount of shares that wouldn't raise enough money to pay off their debts. Their prospectus noted that shares sold would automatically become worthless unless their debt was paid off, which they didn't anticipate. But why not try? What if they sold so much stock that the bondholders could just be paid back? Why do the stock sale specifically planning for failure? Why include a limit that guarantees failure even if you would have otherwise succeeded?
- dragontamer 6y agoMany would suggest that such an action you propose is fundamentally immoral. Lets say a hypothetical company is overall $-4 Billion in debt (total assets - liabilities). You successfully raise $5 Billion from some means. Now you're in a position where you sold $5 Billion worth of shares on a company that (by all fair evaluations) is only worth $1 Billion after the capital raise.
- HPsquared 6y agoThe people buying the shares are making the "true" valuation of the company, being the ones buying it.
- ineedasername 6y agoPeople buying shares were acting on what they believed to be the true valuation. A big difference. Imagine two people are "long" on some stock. Person A decides to sell; They believe the true valuation is lower. Person B decided to buy more; They believe the true valuation is higher. One of them is wrong. In this case, the buyers of Hertz stock were most likely wrong, although things are not yet finalized and another comment here notes that alternate plans are being proposed that would not wipe out share holders.
- dragontamer 6y agoDo you think the buyers of HTZGQ at $5.50 in June 2020 will be proven correct? Or do you think, that like most other bankrupt companies, HTZGQ will be worthless once these bankruptcy proceedings are done? The stock is almost certainly going to go to $0. That's just what happens as bankruptcies play out. If you disagree, you're welcome to toss your money into buying some HTZGQ yourself. ---------- The issue is that Hertz CEOs / board / CFO have extra information and better ideas into how those bankruptcy proceedings are happening. For them to issue shares in this time is grossly immoral. Especially when they're publicly pointing out that yes, bankruptcy proceedings are carrying on as expected: shareholders are expected to be wiped out and assigned a big fat $0.
- brandmeyer 6y agoIt already has gone to zero. The bankruptcy proceedings wrote off all of the old stock and issued an entirely new set of shares, mostly to the debt holders. (I cannot reply to your response when you edit so often... looks like it resets an anti-spam timer or something) The proceedings behind a deal at this scale are so private that it is rare to see major salient revisions after a public announcement like this. Nevertheless, I concede the point that it isn't completely final. Presumably they'll be de-listed once that actually happens.
- nextaccountic 6y ago> They asked the bankruptcy court, and the bankruptcy court's job is to maximize value for the bondholders. Perhaps the court can do this without violating the law? This is fraud.
- dragontamer 6y agoThat's not the bankruptcy court's job. That's the SEC's job. Ever heard of the phrase "you cannot have two masters" ?? By splitting the job into two organizations, we ensure that both jobs are accomplished. Otherwise, only one job gets done (at the expense of the other).