2 ms·
If feels like this could be solved if Google/Yelp/Etc wanted to solve it, but it would cut into their profits. Give the business an app to generate unique QR c
by jedberg 6y ago
If feels like this could be solved if Google/Yelp/Etc wanted to solve it, but it would cut into their profits.
Give the business an app to generate unique QR codes for each customer, and then have that customer use the code to make the review.
Now everyone knows that the review comes from a person who actually bought the product, the reviewer is more likely to be honest because their identity is known to the seller, and the business can even remediate the issue because they know which customer left the review.
To those saying anonymity equals honesty in the review, I really don't think that's the case, nor is it fair to the business. Much like our courts require an accuser to identify themselves to their attacker so their attacker can defend themselves, businesses should at least know who their accuser is, even if the rest of us don't.
- tenebrisalietum 6y agoHow do I know the QR codes really came from a customer and weren't simply created and submitted by the business owner? Also how do I know the seller didn't bribe the buyer with a discount or something to create a positive review?
- jedberg 6y agoWell, those problems happen now, so it's not strictly worse than what we have now, but those are good points. For the first one, it would have to be tied into the payment system somehow so the money would have to change hands. It doesn't totally solve the problem, but it certainly adds a cost, especially if the payment system requires unique customers. Heck, Google could make money like this by only allowing reviews for purchases via Google Pay. For the second one, I'm not really sure, but if they bribe everyone with the same discount, it's not really a bribe anymore, it's just the new price. And if they don't offer everyone the bribe, then they will quickly get bad reviews.
- Spivak 6y agoBecause all reviews are tied to an active Google account which is pseudo-tied to an IRL identity. I don't really care about the second point because it doesn't scale, people will do it anyway, and you can cozy right up to the line of literally paying for a good review in a million different "above board" ways.
- suddenexample 6y agoThere are often a variety of overly simplistic solutions to a problem that address one issue but sacrifice a lot in return. The reality is that fake reviews are incredibly difficult to solve.