12 ms·
What makes you think this is a one solution problem? Very few things in life are black & white. Life comes in shades of gray and problems with multiple solution
by White_Wolf 6y ago
What makes you think this is a one solution problem? Very few things in life are black & white. Life comes in shades of gray and problems with multiple solutions(more or less optimal for the time when the decision is taken).
Every type of energy comes with downsides:
-Solar - storage and delivery infrastructure costs
-Wind - same as above
-Hydro - same as above + if you build many/too big you change the center of mass leading to changes in the planets rotation speed
-Coal/gas/any fuel burned to produce energy - Usually cheaper than other to buil but produces a lot of pollution
-Nuclear - Build cost + waste disposal
Any kind of energy storage you use for any of the above will need to be recycled at some point. I would count this as a downside for any solution that requires storage to handle peak usage and can't be ramped up.
Edit:Some typos(most likely missed some) and formatting
- hannob 6y ago> What makes you think this is a one solution problem? I don't think that. I think Solar + Wind complement each other nicely. I think hydro can be good if the circumstances allow it. I think we'll need to explore a variety of storage technologies, better grids and demand side management to complement wind+solar. I just don't think that an extra expensive technology with plenty of problems is contributing anything.
- willis936 6y agoAll intermittent sources dependent on weather is not a diverse energy mix. Also, hydro is not only scarce but awful for the local habitat and extremely dangerous. An improper or unplanned decommissioning could kill millions of people.