4 ms·
Don't. Compare. Percentages. Stand-up Maths called this out recently and it's good to mention. I think this might be the video: https://www.youtube.com/watc
by hinkley 6y ago
Don't.
Compare.
Percentages.
Stand-up Maths called this out recently and it's good to mention. I think this might be the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aokNwKx7gM8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aokNwKx7gM8
Give me the output and our total consumption please.
- kylegill 6y agoIt actually served to make me more skeptical to the article only seeing percentages. Thanks for calling that out as well.
- hinkley 6y agoPunchline is at ~12:45 for anyone who doesn't want to watch a bunch of stuff about voting. Basically you can only compare (or add, or subtract) percentages if the quantities they represent are exactly equal. And since the quantities of power production change from year to year, they're doing the same thing he's complaining about.
- lucb1e 6y agoSkipped to 12:45, still talking about voting. Something about voting by party vs by candidate and that being why the math with percentages didn't work out in the earlier example, which seems to be context I'm missing from the previous 12 minutes.
- rrrazdan 6y agoWhile usually people use percentages in the wrong way, in this case they used and compared them the appropriate way. Percentage here is used as a ratio of total output and a decline in that ratio over time is a decline in role. Exactly what the articles headline asserts. It doesn't matter that nuclear may have grown in absolute numbers. The assertion is that its role has declined which is true.
- hinkley 6y agoIt's still a bit sketchy because total output matters in a world where we push for more efficient use of power. Could we put enough fancy light bulbs and triple glazed windows and heat pumps out there to run everything on nuclear (I am biased against nuclear but I'm also biased against coal externalities) and solar/wind? What's our shortfall? In this case it's not the % of nuclear I care about. It's how much base load it can provide. Bad budgeting is one of my peeves about software and so I get a little grumpy when I see it happening elsewhere.
- _Microft 6y agoDon't compare absolute values only either, show both.
- hinkley 6y agoYes! I'm glad to see this idea seems to be spreading around HN . Show both, or you're lying to part of your audience by omission.
- tchvil 6y agoHis books and Rubik's appearing little by little in the back are hilarious.
- hinkley 6y agoI didn’t even notice it until right after he bagged on the other guy for doing it. By the end it’s just a shelf of his books.
- flor1s 6y agoHe says you can't "combine" percentages, not that you can't "compare" percentages, "you can't add and substract between them".