3 ms·
I think it's important to note that product lead, system architect, and UX architect are distinct roles, each with distinct responsibilities, for a reason. It'
by valeness 6y ago
I think it's important to note that product lead, system architect, and UX architect are distinct roles, each with distinct responsibilities, for a reason.
It's not my job as a coder to care about your problem past what has been described to me. It is your job, as product lead, to care about the problem and design a sufficient information architecture, subdomain map, and other documentation to model your problem.
This goes both ways. It is not your job to care about my problems past how it impacts the product. I don't expect you to know or care about how we design the software or how it is implemented; whether we use snake or camelCase, if we use openssl or pgp, if we choose mysql or postgresql.
I just think it's important to outline that much of your comment can be applied in the inverse, and saying that "It's less work to become a mediocre programmer than to intimately understand the problem", is the same as saying "It's less work to become a mediocre product analyst than it is to intimately understand how to code".
I agree with your last point, it's important for every department to have humility and empathy for the problems of their peers. But, it's not a problem to be figured out by designers and coders; it's instead an issue that extends further and requires effort from everyone involved, and at every level, to support.
- creeble 6y agoI agree here. I think a big part of the problem, even in big companies, is that those roles blur too much. In particular, it is frequently the case where a product lead says something like “we need a way to...” and leaves the implementation open to discussion to all. This often leads to a programmer, who is more deeply concerned with how that function will operate on the data, coming up with a “how about a button that...” and/or just implementing the button as a suggestion. And then the UX architect and product lead, knowing that they don’t want to piss off this coder for fear of future pushback on their ideas, just caves and says “fine”. That’s the most common scenario I’ve seen at larger companies. That, and having woefully inexperienced UX and UI designers in the first place.