4 ms·
The limits of regulation. There is no way to plug all loopholes. That said, the added labor ensures a more finished product is exported. Was that the intent, o
by tomrod 6y ago
The limits of regulation. There is no way to plug all loopholes.
That said, the added labor ensures a more finished product is exported. Was that the intent, or was the intent to force the wood to stay in NZ?
- minitoar 6y agoCertainly the former, but clearly not in the spirit of it. However as long as the tax man got his share maybe that’s all that matters. Presumably the more finished product is taxed higher.
- TheIronYuppie 6y agoBoth the letter of the law and the spirit seem to point to just using the regulation around finished furniture as a way to limit over harvesting. Why do you see it differently?
- lostlogin 6y agoNot here in NZ. The wetlands were being plundered and trashed with all the raw logs shipped to China. The tax wasn’t the issue, it was getting paid.
- weregiraffe 6y ago>The limits of regulation. There is no way to plug all loopholes. Sure there is. Just ban export of wood and wooden items.
- tomrod 6y agoThen you find wood called "cellulose products" and the cycle starts again. It's impossible to limit creativity, and also why would a government want to pursue a ban as it impacts negatively woodworkers?
- weregiraffe 6y ago>Then you find wood called "cellulose products" and the cycle starts again. Inventing new words doesn't magically absolve you of crimes, you know.
- tomrod 6y agoActually it does. Consider "bribe" versus "campaign donor." "Execution" versus "murder". Many cases exist. But that is beside the point. Laws have to be specific, and that is the issue. If you can perform a minimal treatment to the object under the law, then it can be transmuted under the law and the spirit of the regulation is sidestepped.
- shuntress 6y agoLaws cannot be specific for this exact reason. Reason, judgement, and consensus must be part of the process. To ban the export of unprocessed domestic wood, is it preferable to pre-define and include every possible "process" or is it better to have judges who asses whether any given would-be export is "processed"? Also, lets skip the argument of regulatory capture/neglect by just agreeing that government transparency/accessibility and voter enfranchisement are critically important to maintaining any reasonable consensus-based system.
- mellavora 6y agoI really want to agree with you; this is how law should work (and why "law is like software" analogies are so fundamentally wrong, software doesn't make judgement calls). The problem is that people are involved, which means some of the judges will show poor judgement, including possibly okay'ing something if their friends do it but not if other do, or other less obviously unfair things. I don't see a solution; the obvious choice of trying to make the law more specific and thus less reliant on judgement gets us back to the idea you are opposing.
- tptacek 6y agoA bribe is a donation made with an overt expectation of quid pro quo. A murder is an unlawful killing.
- aantix 6y agoLawmakers are slow and playing defense all of the time. You're always a step behind when you have to react to moves.
- SavantIdiot 6y agoYes, but still better than no regulations. It's an arms race.
- tomrod 6y agoWhy is that better, specific to this instance?
- jayd16 6y agoI would venture to guess the regulation, weak as it was, still slowed the exports.
- tomrod 6y agoI would imagine so, if only a minor amount. Seems like it increased the price I would gather, unless the international market for unique wood doesn't behave as I'm speculating :)
- BurningFrog 6y agoRight, but I'd argue this export was beneficial, both to NZ and China.
- sandworm101 6y agoThere is also an environmental aspect. Limits on the export of unfinished wood/logs ensures that the wood isn't being sold to become firewood. Firewood is a thing. Something like 8-10% of UK electricity (2017) came from firewood harvested in the US. https://www.pri.org/stories/2018-06-20/uk-s-move-away-coal-means-they-re-burning-wood-us https://www.pri.org/stories/2018-06-20/uk-s-move-away-coal-m...
- lostlogin 6y agoThe wood dug out of swamps in NZ is far too valuable to be firewood, but wrecking wetland does have a massive negative impact. It’s worth googling images of swamp kauri if woodworking is your thing, the logs are truely massive.
- brabel 6y agoI did just that... and found this interesting article about swamp kauri and how they helped understand what happened last time the Earth's magnetic poles reversed, 42,000 years ago: https://www.nzherald.co.nz/northern-advocate/news/ancient-northland-swamp-kauri-solves-42000-year-old-mystery/R3KTH5HHDBEWICCI3B63FXM2OM/ https://www.nzherald.co.nz/northern-advocate/news/ancient-no...
- njarboe 6y agoThe Earth's magnetic poles last permanently reversed about 780,000 years ago. The magnetic event that happened ~41,000-42,000 years ago is called the Laschamps excursion. An excursion is when the magnetic field gets very weak, becomes non-dipolar, but then returns to the original polarity that the field was before the excursion. Occasionally durning these excursions the field flips directions and becomes stable in the opposite direction. That did not happen for the Laschamps. Many of these excursions have occurred since the last reversal of the field. The article you linked to is a bit woo-woo, especially with all the Douglas Adam's stuff and the number 42. The article did not link to the scientific paper, which is an interesting read. It seems to be open access, so check it out[1]. [1]https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6531/811 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6531/811
- CPLX 6y agoThe intent of finished goods laws like this almost invariably is to protect domestic jobs. Many other countries have variations on these type of laws. The concern is that a raw material export based economy is bad for the people who live in the country because most of the value is extracted from the country and only the most unskilled jobs are left. This type of resource extraction was a hallmark of the colonial era, which is one reason governments are very wary of it.