5 ms·
machines implement stupid broken ux patterns which make shopping hell. on edit: evidently people would like their supermarket checkout experience to be as plea
by bryanrasmussen 6y ago
machines implement stupid broken ux patterns which make shopping hell.
on edit: evidently people would like their supermarket checkout experience to be as pleasing as the typical online shopping experience, thus a quick downvote.
- alistairSH 6y agoI agree. I've found self-checkout (of the variety common in US supermarkets) to be no faster than employee-run checkout for normal grocery loads. It may be faster for a handful of items, but once the shopper has many items, particularly a lot of produce, the lookup mechanism (picture matching, usually) for he produce slows the whole thing to stand-still. Add in manual ID verification for alcohol and drug purchases and it slows even more. Add in problems with coupons, payment, or other errors, it slows more. And then most of them have some sort of scale on the bagging end which never works well - bulk items, too many items to fit on the shelf, etc.
- msh 6y agoI think the average online shopping experience is, at least for me, far preferable to the average supermarket experience with queues and so on.
- megous 6y agoMaybe to you, but until online shopping will be realizable via user chosen User Agent (like e-mail, etc.) via open API, online shopping will continue to suck horribly for anything but single items. Shopping for groceries online is complete hell, for one. There are queues online too. They are just at the delivery side, not at the checkout side.
- msh 6y agoI often shop for groceries online in these corona times, for a family of 5. I usually use nemlig.com (a danish online super market) and I dont have any issues with the UX. Its easier than searching for things in the physical supermarket. On delivery its not really a queue as I dont have to spend my time doing it.
- megous 6y agoNemlig looks clean and good, with the category sidebar that mostly will not slide away, and as you type search, that's actually useful, and product list that's immediately in your face. Great! :) And this is exactly why I'd love the open API. To be able for people to make a client like this or better, and just use it everywhere. Here we have to suffer through websites like this: https://www.rohlik.cz/c300102000-ovoce-a-zelenina https://www.rohlik.cz/c300102000-ovoce-a-zelenina where you open a category, then you see a whole screen useless stock image for a category, then you scroll down through a bloated list of subcategories, then there's half a screen of recipes, and then quarter screen of filters, and then finally you get to a algorithmically selected grouped product lists. And you have to scroll through this every time you change a category, which is also a hassle, because of all the huge multi-column popups and annoying category images everywhere and the constant scrolling you have to do to get to the subcategories from the product list. Other websites are not that great either, due to this being the first mover in our market. So they copycat it: https://www.kosik.cz/maso-drubez-a-ryby https://www.kosik.cz/maso-drubez-a-ryby It takes more time to select all I want online, with this interface, than a bus trip to a shop and back + typical 15 minutes in the shop for a moderate grocery shopping session.
- wasmitnetzen 6y agoI never experienced that "Unexpected item in bagging area" here in Sweden, the UX failures are not universal. Most stores I visited don't even have scales and just trust you to put in the correct items. Especially the ones where you get a handheld device to scan while you walk trough the store. I would guess that fraud levels are much lower here so the stores don't need to do that.
- bryanrasmussen 6y ago>I never experienced that "Unexpected item in bagging area" here in Sweden, the UX failures are not universal. the automated føtex near my house has this, or also put your item in the bag, you need to put an item in the bag etc. crash because you didn't put item in bag fast enough, or you took bag off scale to put new one on. >the UX failures are not universal. yes, because they do not have a universal interface which a human checker provides. By using a machine you switch from having one well understood, pretty standardized ui paradigm: put stuff on track, tracks goes to checker, checker checks them through, you pay and bag your stuff - to having as many ux as there are companies implementing automatic checkout machines and however many versions of their workflow are in distribution. The UX failures for a self-service checkout are unique and unfamiliar to the user, just like the ux failures of a new checkout flow on an online retailer.
- wasmitnetzen 6y agoThe UX of a human being is only good if you have a common language. I'm not fluent in Swedish, so for me the ability to read the text on the machine instead of listen to it is a plus. Of course, I can ask the cashier to talk English to me, but that also has some friction to it. And I only regularly go to two different supermarkets, so once I know their flow, there's nothing new to it. In contrast, humans seem to like to change their interface quite regularly, even between customers...
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoOk, I've gone to shop in lots of stores in countries where I do not speak the language, as part of the whole human checkout system there is always (in non street market situations) a machine display that says how much of the local currency I need to give up. On the other hand I think I may be abnormally sensitive to badly worked out human machine interactions since working out these kinds of interactions is part of my job as a programmer. So when something is poorly thought out I think that I feel it stronger than most people do.
- Smithalicious 6y agoGod, I wish buying things in person was as smooth as buying them online. Being able to add and remove things from your cart in near zero time, being able to shop at any time of day, being able to search for things by name If I could get all my groceries delivered at negligible cost I would do so
- jusssi 6y agoWe have it now, where I live. We started ordering our groceries when the pandemic happened, but it's so convenient that we'll probably keep doing it once it passes. I'm not sure if about 5% of our weekly supermarket spend would be negligible enough for you, but it's been worth it for us. One big factor for us is that we don't own a car, so we'd be (and previously were) hauling all that stuff by hand. My understanding is that the chain is running the delivery service at a loss, though they probably make it up by people buying more at a time. It remains to be seen if they raise prices for the delivery when the pandemic passes.