5 ms·
As impossible as the physics seems I think the social problems are bigger. Scientists are currently unable to convince people to act against the potential cata
by guelo 15y ago
As impossible as the physics seems I think the social problems are bigger. Scientists are currently unable to convince people to act against the potential catastrophe of global warming. Humans are too stupid to organize a planet wide self preservation effort that requires any significant amount of resources. I think the more likely scenario for humanity over the next 10 thousand years is several cycles of civilization and population collapses with a constant degradation of the environment and fewer and fewer available resources. This century might be the zenith of human achievement. It might take a smarter species a few million years from now to escape this rock.
- billswift 15y agoHumans are too smart to let a bunch of bureaucrats with their pseudo-scientific rationalizations destroy the economy in the pursuit of more power for the bureaucracies.
- itg 15y agoAnd this is exactly the type of short-sighted thinking that dooms us. The vast majority of scientists have come to a consensus yet you don't like it so label them bureaucrats with some sinister motive of destroying the economy behind it.
- drcube 15y agoJust because we know there is a problem doesn't really mean anything. That's just the beginning. Ask yourself these questions: How much does/will the problem cost us? IS there a solution? How much will the solution cost? Then you do cost benefit analysis and decide the best course of action. THEN you try to talk everybody else into it. I'm happy to concede global warming is happening and will only get worse. Hell, I was one of the first people I know to understand and accept that. I just haven't seen the follow up yet. It's always "Yep, got yourself a problem there", but no solution offered other than "buy a Prius".
- troutwine 15y agoClimate shift implies a necessary change to infrastructure: cities that once did not have to deal with flash floods will, for example. Municipal trees will die. Areas that grow colder will have non-insulated water pipes burst. There is no need to form greater bureaucratic nightmares to adapt for such problems, only a general willingness to remake our urban environments before it becomes dreadfully expensive. Note the work Chicago is doing, as a function of it's normal maintenance; anticipating a hotter and wetter climate alleys and sidewalks become water permeable, tree species are changed. > Then you do cost benefit analysis and decide the best course of action. THEN you try to talk everybody else into it. This is overly simplistic. Who is the decision maker? Democracies function as distributed consensus makers--very little _can_ or _should_ be dictated by some benevolent cabal. Moreover, for the rather complex problem of adapting _human civilization itself_ it is hard, if not impossible, to perform a cost benefit analysis. Where do you even get the possible solutions from if: * no one but a few know about the problem and * domain experts you consult with might have implicit biases against the problem without significant preparation and * the hypothetical cabal is composes of like minded (hence like-blinded) individuals? > Hell, I was one of the first people I know to understand and accept that. I just haven't seen the follow up yet. It's always "Yep, got yourself a problem there", It's entirely possible we've gone past the point of short-term return. Still, the follow up, as you put it, has been to reduce or eliminate the primary sources of the problem: * decrease the reliance of Heavy and Light industries on coal/oil * decrease and reverse global deforestation * decrease and reverse water vapor production from urban areas Each one of these points has large cultural and economic implications. It is, however, very difficult to discuss them when so many deny the premise, or have a vested interest in convincing others of the invalidity of the premise. It is entirely wrong to assert that the follow up, as you put it, has been absent from the discussion; mostly it's drowned out. Communicating complex ideas is difficult in a culture with strong debate traditions; God have mercy on us for our Shouting Heads. > but no solution offered other than "buy a Prius". I think that's willfully cynical of you, or uninformed. Even ignoring the obvious vested interest car manufactures have in misinforming us that a _different_ kind of car is a viable solution, the perverse effects a Car Culture has on an Urban environment--heavily paved, strongly lateral development--is likely unsustainable in the long-term.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoI like the ambiguity of your response.
- guelo 15y agoIf the scientists are all in a giant evil conspiracy we're doomed anyway, my point still stands, humans are too stupid to save ourselves if needed.