4 ms·
Having consulted a graph [0] of coal production in the UK, it seems a difficult sell to argue that there have been any policy changes in the last century. It s
by roenxi 6y ago
Having consulted a graph [0] of coal production in the UK, it seems a difficult sell to argue that there have been any policy changes in the last century.
It seems likely oil will follow the same trajectory. We've been due to hit the global peak sometime soon, more oil has been consumed than discovered for a while now.
If people persist in using the stuff until it runs out, it is hard to see what the effect of all the pressure was.
[0] https://ourworldindata.org/death-uk-coal https://ourworldindata.org/death-uk-coal
- scatters 6y ago"Discovered" is a pretty flexible term. Geologists will only go out to look for the stuff if there's an expected return on extracting it. Similarly, "reserves" means stuff that (a) we know about and (b) that we think can be extracted economically. In effect, it's tautological to say that we'll "use the stuff until it runs out", because at whatever point we stop using it there'll still be some left that's just slightly too difficult to extract (given, hopefully, alternatives and taxes) for it to be worth it.
- sgt101 6y agoI don't understand your comment - there have been many policy interventions that have changed coal consumption in the UK in the last 100 years. There is a large amount of coal still available for mining in the uk - but lack of demand and low prices coupled with high extraction costs have destroyed the industry. - The clean air act made it illegal to burn many forms of coal and required coal producers to use higher standards. Many areas were banned from coal burning of any sort. This drove the adoption of gas central heating. - Safety measures introduced after many mining tragedies drove up the costs of the industry significantly. - The attack on organised labour in the 1980's resulted in the shuttering of large parts of the UK coal industry. - The development of the EU single market drove the importation of cheap coal from Germany and Poland, dealing a further blow to the domestic industry. - Many initiatives on home insulation driving down utilization. But you may be making a point I just haven't understood - can you clarify?
- roenxi 6y agoThey've been in a steady linear downtrend of coal production for more than a century. Then stopped producing the stuff roughly on schedule for a prediction made in 1970 or 1980. Occam's razor here is they stopped producing coal because they ran out of coal, rather than because of any political will. > There is a large amount of coal still available for mining in the uk - but lack of demand and low prices coupled with high extraction costs have destroyed the industry. That is what running out of coal looks like. Based on the 100 year trendline, Occam's razor is they can't sustain their lifestyle using coal. It wouldn't surprise me if they struggled even with new forms, their energy use figures [0] are eye watering. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_the_United_Kingdom#Overview https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_the_United_Kingdom#O...
- T-A 6y ago> they stopped producing coal because they ran out of coal "The UK has identified hard coal resources of 3 910 million tonnes, although total resources could be as large as 187 billion tonnes." https://euracoal.eu/info/country-profiles/united-kingdom/ https://euracoal.eu/info/country-profiles/united-kingdom/
- sgt101 6y agoI don't get this - is the reduction in energy consumption per head a bad thing in your eyes? And occam's razor states "the simplest theory that fits the evidence" there is extensive evidence that the UK has large reserves of coal and could have continued to exploit them for many decades. However, for political reasons it didn't.
- blippage 6y ago> The attack on organised labour in the 1980's resulted in the shuttering of large parts of the UK coal industry. My understanding is that Thatcher closed down coal because production was uneconomical and she didn't want government coffers propping it up. Your use of the word "attack" is emotionally charged, as if Thatcher was just doing it for evil lulz.
- 6y ago