3 ms·
This is a classic challenge in interface design: this confusion pops up every time you have a button which both toggles state AND represents the current state o
by simonw 6y ago
This is a classic challenge in interface design: this confusion pops up every time you have a button which both toggles state AND represents the current state of the world.
It's rare to see it solved cleanly. I try to avoid interface elements that attempt to combine these two roles entirely.
I quite like the way the Twitter "Follow" button works: when you click it the text changes to "Following", which I think is just clear enough, but only because it's a button that every Twitter uses frequently enough that they are likely to remember how it works.
- 3np 6y agoI don’t get this obsession of removing all textual elements. “Muted” wouldn’t be that bad would it?
- XorNot 6y agoGiven that's it's an absolutely critical state, I don't get why "You are muted" isn't in white text on a red background. This and "Your video is OFF" are states I care about when video conferencing because the reason to enter them is important.
- draugadrotten 6y agoIf I mute my TV, a big crossed-over speaker icon is shown on screen. That UX is how a muted microphone should appear in video meetings. There is perhaps a patent which prevents it for financial reasons.
- oftenwrong 6y agoHow about a checkbox? [x] Mute microphone (apparently HN doesn't permit the checkbox character)