3 ms·
On the advice of people here on HN, I've started reading Whitaker's "Anatomy of an Epidemic", which is one of the books reviewed here. It's a solid book, but n
by nkurz 15y ago
On the advice of people here on HN, I've started reading Whitaker's "Anatomy of an Epidemic", which is one of the books reviewed here. It's a solid book, but not doing a lot for me. As a counterpoint for pro-drug advertising it's fine, but it feels more like a journalistic expose than science. It's not that it's wrong, rather it feels like the author started out with a conclusion and then did a lot of fine research to find supporting evidence. I feel like I'm being given only half the story: a well-founded and less-told half, but still I worry that the author might have chosen to omit any evidence that weakened his case.
I'm enjoying another book (not reviewed in this article) that I grabbed off the new book shelf much better. "What is Mental Illness" by Richard McNally. He's a Harvard psychology professor who's served on committees for DSM-IV. It touches on a lot of the same issues, seems a little more current rather than historical, and by and large I trust that he's representing the field as he sees it. I also like the prose better: a fun combination of low brow and erudite. It's highly critical of the field, but also balanced in a way that I don't find Whitaker to be. http://mcnallylab.com/ http://mcnallylab.com/
- Alex3917 15y ago"I feel like I'm being given only half the story: a well-founded and less-told half, but still I worry that the author might have chosen to omit any evidence that weakened his case." I've been checking since the book came out and I have yet to find any intelligent criticisms of the book. There was one Amazon reviewer who claimed Whitaker was leaving out specific studies that contradicted him, though when I actually read them studies mentioned they either supporter Whitaker or else were orthogonal to the claims. If anyone has found anything intelligent on the subject I'd love to see it though. It's important to remember also that the best case scenario is that these drugs aren't as outright harmful as the research suggests, the other issue is that most of the research supporting them is of extremely low quality, which is pretty self-evidently true.
- jonah 15y agoIANAP, but after reading about the process towards the DSM-V,[1] I'm reluctant to give its "authority" much credence. [1] http://www.wired.com/magazine/2010/12/ff_dsmv/all/1 http://www.wired.com/magazine/2010/12/ff_dsmv/all/1
- JonnieCache 15y agoDoctors don't diagnose purely on the basis of the DSM or similar statistical tools, and haven't for decades, at least here in the UK which is the system I am most familiar with. This is too big a subject area to go into here in a HN comment but if you want to know more, a good place to start would be by familiarising yourself with the difference between nomothetic and idiographic knowledge, which is completely key to modern diagnostic practices in psychiatry. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nomothetic_and_idiographic http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nomothetic_and_idiographic VERY VERY simply, while someone might be considered severely abnormal from a nomothetic viewpoint, from an idiographic viewpoint clinicians might decide that they have always been that way and they have a history of being happy and getting on well in their society and with those around them and being successful, and therefore they cannot call that person crazy, however statistically abnormal their actions may be. But yeah, it's a lot more complex than that. EDIT: an important point to remember is that not every doctor is some sort of sucker, prescribing whatever big pharma tells them to. When you see a microsoft press release, do you read it and say "well that sounds convincing!" and start building everything on MS platforms? Thought not. Obviously this largely depends on the economic relationship between healthcare practitioners and big pharma in your country and your healthcare system, whatever that might be. If you were unlucky enough to live in a country where MS could just pay you per line of ASP.NET checked in, well I guess there would be a lot of misery and shitty code.