5 ms·
Credit to the author for admitting he doesn't really know UX. And he does have a point about the importance of differentiating destructive actions from non-dest
by eyelidlessness 6y ago
Credit to the author for admitting he doesn't really know UX. And he does have a point about the importance of differentiating destructive actions from non-destructive ones.
Determining which those are can be really hard depending on how your users use your app. And won't always be universal. The example of the "commonly used" closed window versus quit app... the destructiveness of the former is equivalent.
When one is a common action and the other causes more pain when performed accidentally, it's been more helpful to add an option to ask if that was the intended action than to retrain now-generations of users on keyboard commands. Cmd+Q/Cmd+W have been used this way since I was in diapers.
- mjd 6y agoThe destructiveness of "close tab" is not equivalent. Control-shift-T will instantly undo the close-tab action. And there is a menu item that lists "recently closed tabs". Try finding the menu item that brings back the app once you've quit.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoOne of the most annoying things about Firefox is its limited reopen close tab implementation: I’ve gotten really used to Safari’s behavior here and is really irritates me when I can’t reopen the last tab because it triggers whatever Firefox uses to reset the history.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoSpeaking of Safari having good UX around undoing state changes that I miss in other browsers: why can a website put a navigation in another tab, but I can’t press back to get out of it in any other browser? (Safari’s implementation isn’t perfect and I can think of ways to improve it, but a simple “yep I didn’t want to go here” should be just as effective if the website specifies `target` as when it doesn’t.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- eyelidlessness 6y ago> The destructiveness of "close tab" is not equivalent. Control-shift-T will instantly undo the close-tab action. And every browser has a way to reload tabs from the previous session. Both are equally destructive if the tab/s had state you were not finished with and don’t preserve that state when reopened. At least quit can be guarded with an “are you sure?” prompt out of the box. > Try finding the menu item that brings back the app once you've quit. The um... Dock or Taskbar or Start Menu or Spotlight or every other thing people use to launch apps every day?
- perryizgr8 6y ago> Control-shift-T will instantly undo the close-tab action. Not if that tab was a google meet meeting.