4 ms·
As cynical as I'd like to be towards Musk, I'm sending this comment over a Starlink connection that has made me rethink what my future could be. Living in a rur
by smoldesu 6y ago
As cynical as I'd like to be towards Musk, I'm sending this comment over a Starlink connection that has made me rethink what my future could be. Living in a rural area, I was always under the impression that I'd need to move to the city and get a fiber connection eventually. With Starlink, that's no longer a concern. My latency is rock-solid at <50ms and download speeds are pretty capable as well.
Obviously Elon isn't entirely responsible for it, but I'm constantly impressed by his initiative in tech world. If Starlink weren't available, I'd be waiting ~3 years for Amazon to build some sort of equivalent service.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stanford_labrat 6y agoWhat’re your download and upload speeds like?
- olyjohn 6y agoMine gets between 50-150mbps, sometimes 200-300 down. Up is between 20-40 from the tests I have done. Exactly as promised. My ping has gone from 40-60ms, and now is regularly around 20. This was just in a matter of months, and also me fucking with it for hours to try to find the best placement. I still have the occasional drop out... I can't make it through a video conference, or wifi call without a freeze up or audio drop. My Starlink app says "No obstructions" but also says "Obstructed for 4 minutes" on a regular basis. Many people seem to echo this. I'm not honestly sure if this is what to expect or not. I generally switch to my 1.5Mbps DSL line for phone calls and video conferences, which lowers the quality a ton, but at least I don't have to ask people to repeat the last 30 seconds. Web surfing and downloading large files is blazing fast, and multiple people sharing the link seems to have no impact on the quality. Video streaming is fantastic. Another downside is that you're behind a CGNAT, so you'll never get a public IP address. Then their router puts you behind another NAT... StarLink is better than nothing for sure. But if Comcast didn't want $25,000 to run 550 feet of cable to my house, I would probably use that instead. I now have to call in an arborist or someone and top some trees that I am guessing are causing temporary obstructions, but I'm not really sure. I have a lot of trees on my property.
- tyingq 6y agoCurious if what you're seeing for data speeds matches what they say on their FAQ page. Your latency is just past what they are promising, which I suppose is not terrible. "users can expect to see data speeds vary from 50Mb/s to 150Mb/s and latency from 20ms to 40ms" https://www.starlink.com/faq https://www.starlink.com/faq
- Kye 6y agoThey probably have a disclaimer somewhere in the contract saying the guarantee doesn't include latency added by the user's computer or network interface.
- tyingq 6y agoYeah, I'm not even sure if it means round trip latency.
- brokenmachine 6y agoFully Self Latency!!
- smoldesu 6y agoI get 50Mb/s on a bad day, and latency tends to be 40-60ms on my ethernet cable. I've found it to be just shy of what they promise, but certainly not far off.
- pomian 6y agoNot to distract from original post, but! What download speeds are you getting? Do you suffer from throttling, for example of more people are connecting at the same time? Are there high and lows during the day? Our invitation arrived and we are tempted, but it seems very expensive.
- smoldesu 6y agoIf you're getting less than 1mbps, I'd wholeheartedly recommend it. Download speeds are between 8 and 16mbps, and I haven't noticed any throttling with 6 people simultaneously connected. Latency is pretty mediocre right now, but it's a massive improvement over traditional satellite networks. I can play online games without issue, and my SSH connections are snappy and painless. My only concern has been the stability of the connection, there are still intermittant disconnects happening on a daily basis, and it comes out to <3 minutes of downtime per day. If that's a dealbreaker, it might be best to hold off until they get it sorted out. Besides that, it's a great deal. The dish is dead simple to install, and even the router they provide is pretty damn good (sadly it only provides a single RJ45, so keep that in mind)
- TinkersW 6y agoYou either have a fan named tesla_fan_88, who reposted the exact same comment, or are some kind of robo? tesla_fan_88 is brand new so I think maybe they stole your msg..
- rsj_hn 6y agoHaving a strong reality distortion field is a necessary, but not sufficient condition to be a great innovator. You have to have some crazy ideas (landing a rocket!) and be able to convince people to invest with you or work for you. But no one bats 1000, and Musk's obsession with "autonomous" things, whether evil AI overlords or self-driving cars, tends to be his weak spot.
- johnfn 6y agoI wouldn't trade one CEO working on actual important problems, like automobile deaths, global warming, space travel and universal internet access for a hundred CEOs working on the next social media startup or crypto idea. No matter how many stupid jokes he makes about "$420.69" on Twitter or whatever, he's had so much more quantifiable impact on the world.
- m463 6y agoI think the "$420.69" jokes are a sort of biomarker. Sort of like self-deprecating humor might not be the entire picture of mental health, but a sign that it is probably ok. EDIT: I think if Elon Musk gets too serious, or gets shut down, I suspect some ingredient of entrepreneurial spirit might be lost. The "do the right thing poorly" vs "do the wrong thing correctly"
- sabhiram 6y agoHmm, he certainly is working on automobile deaths by releasing this nonsense, and giving unsuspecting masses confidence that they should not have.
- sschueller 6y agoWatching the stark difference between the rover on mars and Musks starship experiments I have little faith that starship will ever be realized. Elon over promises and under delivers almost every time.
- caconym_ 6y agoSpaceX, in the last decade or so, has: * Achieved dominance in the commercial launch market, arguably with an even more substantial technology lead. * Performed the first landing and reuse of an orbital rocket booster. * Developed a heavy-lift version of that rocket that has the largest payload to LEO out of any currently operational launch vehicle. Also with reusable boosters. * Delivered a new human spaceflight system to NASA, the first such system since the Shuttle ~4 decades ago despite decades of promises and plans to the contrary. Starliner, the incumbents' entry for the commercial crew program, has not yet flown and is not expected to until later this year at the earliest. * Developed the first full flow staged combustion cycle engine to leave the ground under its own power. It seems really questionable to bet against them at this point, and minimizing their accomplishments to date is really, really silly. Not sure why you have to involve the rover in your comparison, though—it's also a monumental achievement, but it's barely comparable to the domains SpaceX is working in with their launch vehicles.
- anonporridge 6y agoI'm dubious that Starlink will really be all that great once it really scales up to tons of users. It's not surprising that it's great for a limited beta run. Driving on a highway is an amazing experience when it's mostly empty, and a nightmare in rush hour traffic. Has there been any good write up about how well Starlink (or any other satellite internet) could feasibly scale? Even if SpaceX can start dumping tons of satellites for dirt cheap with Starship's economy of scale, surely there's a limit where the risk of a Kessler syndrome event makes further expansion impractical.
- krisroadruck 6y agoSpace is really big. As a simple thought experiment, let's say each satellite is the size of a car (they are actually smaller but let's pretend). There are currently about 1.5 billion cars on the planet. They are confined to land which only makes up 29% of the earths surface. If evenly distributed on that 29% (~57m sq miles) of earths surface (196m sq miles) there are about 25 cars per square mile. The orbital shell in which SpaceX is flying satellites starts 550 miles up. If you confine yourself to a 2D spherical plane, this shell already has 30% more surface area than the earth, and you can use all of it, not just the 29% that is over land. If we "packed" orbit at the same density as cars across that 2D spherical plane we could fit 6.3 Billion satellites with a separation of 1000 feet minimum between any two satellites. Of course we aren't limited to a 2D plane in space. You can fit millions of satellites in orbit with miles of separation between any 2 without issue. The bigger problem would be signal interference.