8 ms·
I'm hoping there's some broad reform coming for jails and prisons in the US. Currently, there's no uniformity in the way prisoners are treated. It's not unus
by tyingq 6y ago
I'm hoping there's some broad reform coming for jails and prisons in the US. Currently, there's no uniformity in the way prisoners are treated. It's not unusual, in the US, for a prison to have no television, no books, little actually edible food, limited human interaction, etc. You can't even write a letter if you don't have someone on the outside funding your commissary account.
That setup, of course, just ends up being a gladiator school and/or permanent psychosis camp.
- yellowapple 6y agoYep. It boils down to rehabilitation v. retribution. Rehabilitation is effective at preventing recidivism. Retribution is politically expedient. And this goes beyond prisons, too. Kinda hard to not turn to crime again if your chances at a career are gated behind criminal background checks that you're destined to fail.
- tyingq 6y ago"if your chances at a career are gated behind criminal background checks that you're destined to fail" That's a great point that I haven't seen discussed in the media. When I was young, only "Fortune 500" type companies could afford background checks, so you had a fighting chance at getting a decent job. Now, anybody can buy a instant background check online, and you can get not just felony data, but misdemeanor data, and even "just arrests, not convictions". And it's dirt cheap to do so. So, job prospects are dim, and even simple stuff like renting an apartment is difficult as well.
- monocasa 6y agoIt'll also show offenses which have been expunged from your record.
- BrandoElFollito 6y agoThis concept of background check on the US is strange. In France, once you left prison, it means that you have served what you had to serve and start again. Nobody can check whether you did prison or not. Some specific jobs require a document stating your juridical past but you bring it, this is not some can do on their own. Then you have military and sensitive civil servants jobs where this is checked for you, but it is really specific. I would not be happy if anybody could check my past online...
- tyingq 6y agoI'm sure there's more in play, but the concept of "At Will Employment" we have in the US creates an environment where only very specifically legally defined discrimination counts as such (race, gender, etc). Outside of that you can fire, or not hire, anyone, for any arbitrary reason you want...even for "no reason given".
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoSo in the US there are rules around court data being public so companies scoop up that data and basically package it as a background check. This data is also enriched with voting data which is also public in most states which includes the people living in your home and other info. The company ADP which deals with paychecks also sells your income information to third parties so someone running a basic background check can actually know where you live, who you live with and how much you make. Luckily the french did give us a tool to fight against this bullshit, it is called the guillotine?
- BrandoElFollito 6y agoI think a less radical solution would be a bit more of "socialism" in the good sense (social protection, protection of the job etc.). It has its pros and cons, but the pros IMO win - bringing some peace of mind to people.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoCan't have "socialism", that's un-american. Now, guillotines, those are french therefore okay, like pastries.
- drstewart 6y ago>I think a less radical solution would be a bit more of "socialism" in the good sense (social protection, protection of the job etc.). That's not what socialism is. Socialism isn't stuff you like done by the government.
- 6y ago
- tossme1231235 6y agoIt is discussed in the media pretty often. By now, it is just accepted that it is terrible, so it is less sensational. Searching 'criminal record employment' in Google News yields > 600,000 results. 'Ban the box' gives millions of results 'clean slate law' gives > 80k results
- slibhb 6y agoNo it doesn't. It's perfectly fair to be against the lack of uniformity in how prisoners are treated without being against retributive justice. That prisoners' lives should not depend on "the whims of the prison's management" (as another poster put it) is just common sense.
- yellowapple 6y agoYou're right in theory, but in practice, being in favor of retributive "justice" tends to go hand in hand with an acceptance of arbitrary application of said "justice", for reasons typically along the lines of "if you wanted humane treatment then you should've thought about that before being a hard-bitten criminal scumbag" (exaggerating, obviously, but not by much).
- SilasX 6y agoWell, if you do give them practical job training, another voting segment is going to scream bloody murder at "prison labor".
- tyingq 6y agoIt's not lack of skills that's being cited here. It's being unemployed because of your criminal background check.
- SilasX 6y agoThey're not independent. Sufficient skills can overcome the stigma of a criminal record. But providing prisoners skills usually involves some on-the-job training to be useful.
- yellowapple 6y ago> Sufficient skills can overcome the stigma of a criminal record. Not when there's an HR department in between the applicant and the hiring manager. People with "sufficient skills" get rejected all the time for reasons far more benign than e.g. having killed someone 30 years ago. Like, this ain't about "stigma". This is about Kafkaesque corporate bureaucracy actively driving crime rates.
- SilasX 6y agoSo you're saying the problem isn't the prison system.
- yellowapple 6y agoI'm saying the problem ain't just the prison system - and neither is the punishment.
- SamBam 6y agoThat sounds like a straw man. There's a big difference between practical "practical job training" and "breaking rocks." If the labor is entirely volunteer and something that actually requires some training, it's job training. If it's forced (which is legal in many states) and it's entirely grunt work like janitorial duty or highway cleanup, then it's prison labor.
- ravenstine 6y agoI think you can have a level of both. Obviously we don't want crime to be free of consequence, but we also don't want inmates to commit crimes again after their sentence(both for the sake of others and their own). In the US, we mostly care about retribution, even when we say that we want reformation. All the time I hear from people about how we need to focus on rehabilitation, but then hear a lot of the same people shout "lock 'em up!" even for property crimes. I'm not one to be in the "America is bad at everything" camp, but I think one of the most negative aspects of our culture is that we act entitled to everything like the world is Burger King and we should get everything our way(or your money back). Fries too cold? Send 'em back and don't tip the server! Someone backed into our rear fender? Sue 'em for all they've got! Someone stole your TV? Lock 'em up and throw away the key! It all stems from materialism.
- Gibbon1 6y agoYears ago I read an interview with a prison warden. The interviewer at the end asked him what he would want the public to understand. The warden said, I would like the public to understand that everyone here is going to get out eventually.
- FpUser 6y agoI live in Canada although did visit US few times. In my opinion the United States is great. Problem I think is that it is great at too many things. It had accomplished incredibly good things. It had also fucked things up royally. And keeps doing all of this. For the people I think it would be worth paying more attention to the dark side.
- paxys 6y agoPermanent psychosis camp is an apt description. The US makes its prisons as hellish as possible – and post-prison life as difficult as possible – as a form of punishment, and that results in some of the highest rates of recidivism in the world. What's worse is that people get incarcerated for increasingly severe crimes. A drug offender spending a stint in prison is very likely to go back in for a more violent crime with a few years of release. https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2019/may/3/long-term-recidivism-studies-show-high-arrest-rates/ https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2019/may/3/long-term-re...
- tyingq 6y ago"get incarcerated for increasingly severe crimes" I'm guessing at least partly due to the "gladiator school" aspect.
- wongarsu 6y agoEven without that it would be a vicious circle. You might initially lead a fairly normal life with some "side-hustle" to earn a little cash, and go to prison for that. Now when you come out you are an ex convict (with barely any assets because life in prison is expensive). So you look for a space to rent (that takes ex-cons) and a job (that hires ex-cons). Chances are you won't find a full-time job, so you turn to crime to pay your rent. But now crime turned from a side-hustle to a half-time job.
- caconym_ 6y agoI broadly agree with you but I think you're ascribing too much coherent judicial intention to the way we treat prisoners. Sure, people are sent there as punishment, but it seems more like the way they're treated once they get there is mostly down to profit motive on the part of big prison-industrial players who outright run some prisons and provide services to most (all?) others, and individual depravity on the part of the bullies and sadists who are drawn to working in the industry. Just the fact that I can reasonably call it an "industry" should be setting off major alarm bells. Our prison system is one of the most terrifying and evil things that exist in the real world.
- Karunamon 6y agoUnlikely. Far too many people willingly short-circuit all rationality in favor of ineffective, but emotionally-satisfying stances like being "tough on crime". Treating prisoners as crappy as they can get away with is usually something in favor of a US politician with any ability to do something about it.
- csnover 6y agoI’m not optimistic about it, but I do wonder if the experience of living through a pandemic will give folks a fresh perspective on just how rough imprisonment is, and a willingness to consider alternatives. If it’s torture to be stuck in your own home for a year—with your own bed, food, schedule, entertainment, family, and hot water—just imagine how much worse it must be for someone locked up in a cage for decades without even those basic freedoms. If you believe that long prison sentencing is a deterrent, and someone told you that breaking a law would cause you to have to live another year of pandemic life, does that not feel deterrent enough?
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoHas pandemic lockdown really changed that many people’s views? In some countries it has become a faux pas to complain about lockdown conditions. Often that is because people don’t want to hear complaining about things we seemingly have little control over, but sometimes it is because some people honestly don’t see any problem with life in lockdown. For example, when scientific advisors to some governments appear in national media and say there could be upsides to maintaining social distancing for potentially years into the future, and this evokes little popular outcry outside a tiny fringe of wacko “great reset”/antivaxxer conspiracy theorists on Twitter, then you start to wonder if a lot of the population has simply accepted the new normal. That might create less sympathy with prisoners, not more.
- dj_mc_merlin 6y agoExtending COVID restrictions for years into the future would cause huge outcry, what are you talking about? I would immediately join protests and do everything in my power to get the current government out if that happened, and I'm not one for "viva la revolución!" normally.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoWe're coming up on a year of restrictions now, and many countries simply haven't seen much protest activity. Politics in some Asian and European countries is very much consensus-based, and if the main parties have converged on the idea of maintaining some level of social distancing, there isn’t much space for the populace to voice opposition to that. Large protests in those countries tend to be unlikely because 1) protests have been banned on epidemological grounds, and the authorities have made it clear that any protest will be swiftly suppressed by the police, and 2) QAnon and antivaxxer conspiracy theorists tend to be very visible at protests, and normal people are unwilling to be associated with that. So, the bulk of the population is not going to be willing to go out and protest.
- meddlepal 6y ago> I'm hoping there's some broad reform coming for jails and prisons in the US. Doubtful. Prison reform isn't popular at all amongst voting blocs that matter to politicians and it's a hard sell to the public tuned into a "safety first" and "lock 'em up and throw away the key" attitude.
- tyingq 6y agoI say I'm hopeful because there have been meaningful changes in bail reform and decriminalizing drug possession recently. Some attitudes do seem to be changing.
- spoonjim 6y agoI think suburban America broadly does not want psychopaths running around which is what burglars and drug dealers become when they spend 10 years in prison.
- kube-system 6y ago"then they don't deserve being released" -- suburban America
- spoonjim 6y agoI’m of the opinion that you shouldn’t send people to jail for more than 3 months if they’re not going for their entire lives. I don’t want people coming out of a place like that into my suburban neighborhood.
- vharuck 6y agoThis is interesting. Is the 3 months number something arbitrary? Are there major groups advocating this? Beyond limiting the harm if prison, short stints could make gangs harder to form in non-lifer prisons.
- SilverRed 6y agoWould that not push for more life sentences? Would you now send a rapist to prison for life instead of 10 or so years? 3 months is far too short.
- spoonjim 6y agoSure, send the rapists and murderers and child molesters to life without parole. The rest of the violent criminals to Singapore style whipping which is actually far more humane than prison.
- stouset 6y agoI don't think I agree with this, but it has made me think about the problem differently. We don't send somebody to the hospital for "30 days", or "1 year". We don't do it when putting somebody under the care of a psychiatrist either. We deal with the patient until they're recovered. Perhaps this should be the approach we take with prisoners. They're in prison until a professional determines they're rehabilitated and ready to reintegrate back into the rest of society. With—potentially—minimum and maximum durations to ensure some safety rails on the system. I have to admit I don't know what this looks like, and I don't mean to gloss over the fact that there are incredibly difficult questions this raises that don't have good answers (what does it mean for a murderer to be "rehabilitated"?), but I do wonder if at least considering the problem from this perspective might prove helpful.
- wnevets 6y agoReducing privatization of prisons is the first step. Prisons as a profit center is just legalized slavery.
- GhostVII 6y agoLess than 9% of prisoners are in private prisons, so I don't think that would make a significant difference. I mean it might be a good thing to do, but won't help the vast majority of prisoners.
- Gibbon1 6y agoAlso need to consider the privately owned industrial complex built up around prisons. Just like defense contractors built up around the military.
- wnevets 6y agoThe "food" providers, communication "providers", the companies paying virtually nothing for labor, etc. The folks focusing on the raw percentage of prisoners forced to stay in private prisons are missing the forest for the trees.
- Gibbon1 6y agoThere are also police unions which seem to promote much worse policies than regular public service unions.
- wnevets 6y ago> so I don't think that would make a significant difference. I think it would make a significant difference to the prisoners at these prisons
- GhostVII 6y agoSure, but the grandparent was talking about how it's not uncommon to have no TV, bad food, etc. in prison. Given that private prisons are uncommon, clearly privatization isn't the main cause of these problems.
- irrational 6y agoIs there a prison review website? Let's say I wanted to get sent to the "nicest" prison in the USA (not a white collar "tennis-camp" prison). What crime would I need to commit where to have the highest chance of getting sent there?
- temp0826 6y agoStartup idea- RodIronDoor, GlassDoor for prisons?
- everdrive 6y agoNo books seems unusually cruel. And to what possible benefit?
- tyingq 6y agoTo be fair, that's not true everywhere, but it is true in many places. Though in some places where it is allowed, someone on the outside has to buy it for you. Not everyone has someone on the outside.
- duskwuff 6y agoAnd even when books are allowed, they're often subject to arbitrary restrictions: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/27/us/banned-books-week-prisons.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/27/us/banned-books-week-pris...
- nashashmi 6y agoStories of prison bring up ideas like this. But I don’t think uniformity in treatment would work. If a person is in prison for violence then treatment would be no more violent games and videos. If a person was in prison for theft or gambling related, then treatment would be prohibiting acts that deal with money or games of chance. If a person was involved in bribery or lying, then treatment would be avoiding anything that involves cheats.
- tyingq 6y agoI meant uniformity of rules across institutions. I don't have an issue with different rules for different types of prisoners. Just that those have some uniformity across the various places. Right now, you can do prison time in a county jail (yes, serving an actual sentence in jail), in a state prison, or in a federal prison. The state prisons, particularly, are all over the place on rules and environment. And those serving sentences in county jails are also typically getting the short end of the stick, as the facility rules aren't made for long-term inmates.
- jMyles 6y agoThe abolitionist movement has been mostly dormant since the reconstruction era, but seems to be alive again this past year. We need to ensure that these dots are connected; prisons are not only the moral successor to slavery, but the literal legal framework by which it continues. Strictly speaking, slavery is not against the law in the United States; this carve out in the 13th amendment was seized upon immediately and remains with us today.
- njharman 6y agoOne of the biggest in progress "reforms" is decriminalizing marijuana and end of the "war on drugs" in general. Keeping 20% of prison population from ever going there.
- ROARosen 6y agoI sometimes wonder, since prison is meant for those who commit crimes, so presumably when society decided prison is appropriate for certain crimes, didn't that mean automatically no social interaction for prisoners, since the ideal society would not have (any other) criminals? If yes, that would mean solitary confinement is the only real imprisonment. There are lot's of other ways to take this question with this line of reasoning but I'll leave it at this for now.
- LocalH 6y agoThis comes from a common mindset that people in prison deserve no rights because they broke the law. They don't take into account the fact that there are people there who don't deserve to be (either because they are innocent, or because the law they violated was unjust), and if incarcerated people have "no rights", then they can't fight for their freedom.