4 ms·
i disagree with the validity of cultural fit. if there is a problem with someone fitting into the culture, then it is the culture that needs to change. letting
by em-bee 6y ago
i disagree with the validity of cultural fit. if there is a problem with someone fitting into the culture, then it is the culture that needs to change. letting someone go because they don't participate in after-work activities or because they don't drink alcohol is unacceptable. as is letting someone go because of gender differences.
yes, some people have a problem working together. carl in the story is a good example. carl is someone i would let go because he is uncooperative. this again has nothing to do with cultural fit.
and especially if the difference in cultures falls along diversity lines, i would very carefully examine what the actual culture is and make a strong effort to push for a culture change.
- pmarreck 6y ago> if there is a problem with someone fitting into the culture, then it is the culture that needs to change. I don't think this is realistic. Suppose I move to Texas and manage to start working for a company that likes to watch rodeos on weekends and listens to country music all day in the office. Meanwhile, I'm a techno guy who can't stand rodeos nor country music. I start to get irritated with the all-day-country thing, and (as it turns out) work sometimes gets discussed at these rodeos everyone else is going to that I'm missing, so I always end up a little behind where everyone's at regarding work stuff. The rest of the team starts to perceive this as me "not really caring" or whatever, and eventually I get fired due to "lack of fit". I cannot claim veiled discrimination because I am a white male getting fired by other white males (and perhaps some females, but not 50%). Do you really expect the entire company to conform to my taste in things? I took race and gender out of the picture here to try to show that this is unrealistic. > carl is someone i would let go because he is uncooperative. Honestly it's weird that he was even kept around. Sometimes, people who are willing to butt heads on something are good workers, though. > if the difference in cultures falls along diversity lines, i would very carefully examine what the actual culture is and make a strong effort to push for a culture change. I think the best time to do this is at the start, because I also think that after you get above, say, 20 people, the cultural trajectory has already been set and it becomes massively harder to change.
- em-bee 6y agoi don't expect either of you to change your preferences, but i do expect everyone, and in this case you too, to not put so much weight on your personal preferences, and to stop to expect others to conform to them. there is no reason that you could not get along. that part of the culture is what needs to change. everyone needs to be more tolerant of different preferences and interests. in other words the culture of the company needs to change to be more tolerant and you are right of course, the larger the company, the more difficult the change. company culture comes from the top. it is the leaders that need to give good examples. i'd say though that 20 people should still be manageable. as long as everyone knows everyone else. it takes longer and more effort in larger companies
- njharman 6y ago> problem with someone fitting into the culture, then it is the culture that needs to change. So the team should change to accept a racist, a rude asshole, an elitist narcissist, all the other toxic personality types. In my experience "doesn't fit culture" is code for they're an asshat. Culture in this context doesn't mean ethnic culture. It's referring to work culture, work ethics and personality at work. Also thinking the world needs to change to fit you is the epitome of entitled snowflake attitude. A cultural misfit anyplace I have or would work.
- em-bee 6y agoi am not talking about toxic hires. especially when it comes to gender, it is usually the male majority that is being toxic towards the new hire. the writer of the article certainly was not an asshat. and most culture-fit issues that i read about are bro-cultures where someone didn't fit in because they didn't join the rest in their behavior. i am not saying the world needs to change around the new hire. i am saying the world needs to learn to tolerate different interests and not expect everyone to conform to their personal norms. but that also goes for the new hire. they shouldn't complain about about different norms unless they are rude or unreasonable. on work culture, if for example someone leaves on time, while everyone else works late then that is a difference, but not a reason to fire. a woman in a male team is usually not a culture fit, neither is an older person in a team full of 20 year olds. both are not a reason to fire someone for lack of culture fit, but require the team to adapt their culture to be more tolerant.